So no point visiting anymore. It was OK in its day for fried food, mostly fish, and its shark hash was good
1 - 10 of 82 reviews
My husband and I enjoy the atmosphere of Black Horse Tavern. Its very relaxed and you don't have to worry about the dress code. The lobsters are wonderfully served and the food is inexpensive. Its a place for the whole family
You cannot beat the view. It is a little difficult to get to, but the view is fabulous. Food is OK, not Great but not bad. Service is not consistant. I do recommend it for the view though.Bar service to the swimming area is also...More
This classic island fish eatery and pub has closed. Rumours are a marina will be built on its waterfront location. Standby for news and progress.
Black Horse Tavern is 'off the beaten path' but if you want to try some good local dishes this is the place to go. The fish dinners are great and the fish chowder is tasty! give it a try!
By far there crumb topped lobster is AMAZING!!!!! We order a 4 pound lobster... it was fabulous.... Coconut Shrimp was delish.... Highly Recommend. NOTE: It is a rather far & costly taxi ride from Hamilton so be prepared.. Also have diver return to pick you...More
Nice waterfront spot with decent, reasonable food. Was here twice and liked it both times. Service was a bit slow the second time.
very good fish relaxed atmosphere. If you go by cab make sure that they return for you. The views are excellent and again the food is very good
According to the local's, the manager and her husband got a new job in January and the Black Horse Tavern never reopened. However, the owner is trying to reopen so stay tuned as this place was an amazing restaurant.