Delicious prime rib! Varied menu - not just steaks. Attentive service. Restaurant busy - always a good sign! Good value.

My husband and I ate at this restaurant during an overnight stay in Show Low in April, 2022. We both had steak, baked potatoes, and salad. Everything was delicious and served very quickly after we ordered. The steak was especially good and very tender. I...would certainly recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting Show Low.More

My wife & I had her birthday dinner here. We both had the Prime Rib.....Awesome! It was very tender & super tasteful.

We are spending Thanksgiving weekend in Show Low and came to eat some Prime Rib here. It was so excellent! We are from Las Vegas and recently took my Mom to Lawrey's which cost way more and was not as good as this was. My...husband and I split a big portion - no problem - I hate when some restaurants charge for splitting. Any way I highly recommend this place and will come here again and try other things.More

I needed to get out of Tucson for sone much needed rest and relaxation. I decided to go north for cooler weather in Show Low. I wanted a nice steak dinner and front desk at hotel suggested Cattleman's. So glad she did. I only order...filet mignon and usually 6 oz. They only have 8 oz but omgosh, the best steak I've had ever and I'm 65. It literally melted in my mouth. The loaf bread they serve is awesome. The people were so friendly. Service was amazing. The steak came out popping hot. I was totally happy and satisfied, not to mention stuffed. A little pricey ($30.99) but worth every penny. Will definitely come back when I'm here again.More

As busy as it was, Choncta our waitress never ignored us! She as always on top of anything we needed. Good as always great and tasty. Love this go to place!

Food was marginal nothing great. However the service was good. Prime rib OK, salmon not good at all. Side marginal, mostly starchy, only one vegetable offered besides a salad. Would not go again.

Ate here once before, food was pretty good. Called at 5pm to place a togo order and was told they wouldn't take my order until after 8pm.

Went for dinner, wife ordered Salmon. Arrived under cooked, waitress took it back they re-cooked it, was pretty lousy. Let on duty MGR know, they appeared not to care. Will never go back.More

Although locals love it, coming from Chicago, I was not totally impressed with the cut or cooking of my steak and the sides were just...meh.

After a short wait we seated and greeted promptly by our waiter; Drink order was taken and delivered promptly. Our steak was cooked to order and delicious. My husband and I were there celebrating my birthday and they brought ice cream and surprised us both....Nice touch. Thank you! visit date 6/24/21.More

My wife and I ate here for dinner off the Twighlight (Happy Hour) menu. This place is BUSY. I am glad we made a reservation else we would have been waiting a long time. Hostesses, waitresses, all top-notch. Very courteous and attentive. I had the...signature prime rib, and honestly, it wasn't good. Very tough and chewy, pretty tasteless. My sense is the meat had been steamed not roast as it had that consistency that one gets when meat is steamed not cooked over a high enough flame. So I have to say it was a disappointment. My wife's salmon was OK -- average. If I go again I'll avoid the prime rib.More