Ate here twice while enjoying the area and the Creeper Trail. Delicious food, great service. Take time to enjoy the Tavern’s history. Street parking was not a problem either time. Price for quality was fine for my husband and me. Definitely going again when we...visit again.More

Loved this place. We came from SC to stay a week and looked for places to eat. I always look at the 1-3 star reviews first. Some made the management and hostess sound snobby and unfriendly. Some said it took 2 hours to get your...food, some said they did not have reservations,hmmm...First, the staff were unbelievably friendly. Josh the manager was super nice! They greeted us with huge smiles. Second, it states on their menu that it can take up to 2 hours to get your food so that was no surprise. Even with the crowd, it was super quick. Third, they require reservations. If you walk in without one, they may not be able to seat you. They are a very popular restaurant. We were there on Halloween so I was not surprised they were so busy. Beautiful old building and our waitress Emily was dressed as the manager Josh and Omgosh, on point! I would have thought she was a guy until she spoke and her long fingernails gave her away. The pic of her as Josh is the one with the nametag.There is a pic included of Miss Emily below and she is a beauty. The real Josh is dressed as a pirate.That being said,you have to visit this very old house with so much history. But, make those reservations and you won't be dissatisfied or disappointed!!!More

This was the best meal I have had in years. The filet was amazing as was the brie, and crème bru le for dessert. Mostly German dishes, which were impressive. We sat on the balcony outside in the warm evening air. MUST have reservations and...book a day or two ahead.More

My wife & I ate here for the first time on October 10, 2020 for our 31st anniversary. The atmosphere & the food was absolutely outstanding! Ezra, our waiter, was exceptional. He gave us some interesting history of the building and his service, manners, and...knowledge of the menu were excellent! We thoroughly enjoyed the entire meal: the Norwegian Smoked Salmon appetizer followed by the French onion soup; then came our dishes of Kassler Rippchen and Jagerschnitzel. Dessert was Tiramisu & Creme Brulee (the best ever!) Oh my! This is definitely on the list of places we plan to visit again.More

I had a fabulous dinner of Norwegian Smoked Salmon Appetizer, the freshest of salads & a delicious Grilled Trout. The NY Style Cheesecake with Caramel sauce was a perfect ending to a night of culinary delights. When there were no Uber’s available to return me...to my hotel, Mrs Fuller volunteered and drove me herself. What a special night it turned out to be!! I highly recommend this lovely Historic Tavern, their delectable cuisine and it’s warm, welcoming staff.More

Phenomenal! Oysters Rockefeller appetizer was very tasty, Caesar salad & garden salad were excellent with house made dressings, scallops & polenta cakes were spectacular! Stuffed filet was very tasty, the blueberry cheesecake was great & the creme brûlée was perfection!!! And the martinis were spot...on! Definitely worth a trip to this beaut gem from 1779!More

Great experience Cool place to visit. The old building is full of history make reservations. We sat upstairs and were greeted by a friendly helpful server. The Jagerschnitzle was very good and the beef medallions were excellent. We also had the no flour chocolate cake...and loved it. I highly recommend this restaurant! We will be backMore