We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
TripAdvisor
Aurora
Post
Inbox
Search

Pumpkin Hill - CLOSED

Claimed

Ratings and reviews

Certificate of Excellence2015 - 2017 Winner
RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Details

CUISINES
Wine Bar, American
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
Meals
Dinner, Lunch
View all details
meals, features, about

Location and contact

Improve this listing

Menu

FROM THE GARDEN​
Starting at 5.95
The Days Harvest
A fresh selection of seasonal fruits, vegetables & grains that changed w/ the seasons priced accordingly
5.95
The Aurora
Spinach, NY sharp cheddar cheese, apples, candied walnuts & crumbled bacon finished w/ a maple vinaigrette ...
5.95
The Garden Bounty
Our house salad w/ fresh seasonal vegetables, greens & your choice of dressing
5.95
SOUP DU JOUR​
Our homemade soups change to embrace the season’s bounty & …cookie’s creativity!
BEGINNINGS​
Tapas starting at 7.95
(Available from 3pm to close)
The appreciation & allure of “small dishes” to whet ones appetite is alive & well at pumpkin hill
Featured appetizer dujour…priced accordingly
Sautéed Shrimp
In a zesty citrus BBQ butter served w/ grilled French bread…
7.95
Jumbo Baked Crab Phyllo
With a lively blend of three cheeses & lump crab meat wrapped in paper thin dough over greens finished w/ a lemon vinaigrette…
7.95
Ménage a’ Trois
Olive tapenade, hummus & warm feta served w/ grilled homemade garlic flatbread…
7.95
Portobello Mushroom Tart
With local cheese & caramelized onions on greens w/ a balsamic reduction…
7.95
MAIN EVENT​
Starting at 8.95
Cookies’ Chicken Pot Pie
Tender poached chicken, peas, carrots & celery in a thyme laced veloute’ finished w/ a tender crust…
8.95
Shepherd's Pie
Comfort food at its best! Local ground beef, carrots, portobello mushrooms, corn & peas simmered in a rich brown sauce, topped w/ potatoes & asiago cheese…
8.95
Charred Sugar Crusted Salmon
Served w/ a three cheese polenta & finished w/ a lemon beurre blanc…
8.95
Tortellaci Du Jour
Cheese stuffed half moon shaped pasta finished w/ fresh seasonal accompaniments priced accordingly
8.95
Finger Lakes Maple Farm Duck Breast w/ Goat Cheese
Pan seared w/ fresh fennel, caramelized apples, & candied walnuts in a three berry sauce served w/ fresh greens & a risotto cake
8.95
Grilled Flat Iron
Smothered w/ wilted spinach, roasted red peppers & feta cheese over garlic smashed potatoes & grilled baguette… available dinner only
8.95
When Pigs Can Fly
Our​ tender roasted pork wings served w/ sautéed apples, fresh fennel, red onions & roasted potatoes, finished w/ an apple horseradish sauce… available dinner only
8.95
BURGER ON THE HILL​
“The all about me burger”~ our famous burger served on a
Grilled ciabatta roll
"From the Hen House”
Grilled​ marinated chicken breast on a ciabatta roll*…
7.99
Your combination
The Not So Average Country Burger
A hearty burger topped w/ ny sharp cheddar, portobello mushrooms & caramelized onions…
7.99
Our Homemade Black Bean Burger
On grilled ciabatta served w/ greens, tomato relish & cilantro dressing…
7.99
Served w/ Choice of Our Daily Sides
7.99
PANINIS​
8.99 (available during lunch from 11:30 am to 3pm)
Our pressed sandwich served on a choice of ciabatta, wheat or country white
The American
Smoked turkey, apple wood bacon, blue cheese & caramelized onions
8.99
Ciabatta
Wheat
Country white
El Cubanito
Cuban style roasted pork, thin sliced ham, pepper jack cheese, caramelized onions, dijon mustard & dill pickle
8.99
Ciabatta
Wheat
Country white
The Athena
A marinated medley of tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers & fresh herbs tossed w/ fresh spinach, feta cheese & olive tapenade in a wheat pita
8.99
Ciabatta
Wheat
Country white
East Meets West
A blend of curried chicken salad w/ festive moroccan chutney in a wheat pita
8.99
Ciabatta
Wheat
Country white
All sandwiches are served w/ a choice of our daily sides
FOR THE CHILLINS'​
Baked Chicken
Tenders w/ ranch or honey for dipping
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Served w/ marinara…
Corn Dog
Always a favorite…
Pasta Du Jour
With butter or marinara …
DESSERT​
Pie Du Day
A new creation daily
Dessert Du Jour
One never knows what cookie has come up w/ today!
New "Fat Chance Pop"
Our popular white chocolate frozen soufflé swirled w/ lemon curd & rolled in
Shortbread Cookie Crumbs
Inspired by the child in all of us! flourless chocolate decadence… Rich warm & sinfully good… Topped w/ fresh whipped cream & Melba sauce dawn
Goddess Crème Caramel
With a hint of orange "just godly"
Pumpkin Hills Very Own Dirt Pudding
Rich chocolate pot de' crème layered w/ oreo and
Graham Cracker Crumbs Finished w/ a Chocolate Flower Cake in a Cup
With grandma's
Old Fashioned Carrot Cake
Cup cake style w/ cream cheese frosting & finished w/ candied walnuts.
Reviews (168)
Filter reviews
168 results
Traveler rating
102
42
10
8
6
Traveler type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveler rating
102
42
10
8
6
See what travelers are saying:
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 168 reviews
Reviewed May 27, 2019

Cafe/Bistro type atmosphere with antiques and gifts on two floors. Indoor and outdoor dining. Their soups and salads are wonderful.

Date of visit: June 2018
Thank Dawn041658
Reviewed December 2, 2018

My friend and I had lunch and loved it. There is also a sweet little gift shop attached. Pumpkin Hill is such a wonderful place to have lunch and the view is SPECTACULAR!! I rate this establishment a 10+

Date of visit: July 2018
Thank juliescooter
Reviewed July 27, 2017

My friend and I come to Pumpkin Hill every year after the MacKenzie Childs sale, but last year, we had to miss our traditional visit. We have always found the menu to be nice and the food good. This year, the menu seems to have...More

Date of visit: July 2017
1  Thank Robin047
Reviewed July 22, 2017

Just stopped in for a lite bite after shopping at the MacKenzie-Childs barn sale, which has been our tradition for the past 5 years. Very limited, light menu. Good food, but iced tea and lemonade were served in plastic cups and we were charged for...More

Date of visit: July 2017
1  Thank snostorm53
Reviewed July 16, 2017 via mobile

I am sorry to hear that Pumpkin Hill is now only open for catered events. I would have loved to return for another meal. We attended a lovely wedding reception at Pumpkin Hill over the weekend. Pumpkin Hill is a beautiful venue overlooking Cayuga Lake....More

Date of visit: July 2017
1  Thank Katherine8183
Reviewed June 2, 2017

We always loved this restaurant...great food, service etc. Unfortunately they have decided to close their doors to their regular restaurant and only open for venues which is great for weddings, etc but not good for those of us who would love a nice restaurant around...More

Date of visit: May 2017
Thank CrownPoint
Reviewed May 23, 2017 via mobile

They are now allegedly a "special event" only venue. They accepted my reservation for a party of 8 for my daughter's college graduation May 27th. One week before the date they sent an email saying due to licensing issues they would not be able honor...More

Date of visit: May 2017
Thank GR914
Reviewed September 12, 2016 via mobile

At last visit, new chef,menu limited, higher priced and smaller plates not available. Meals were excellent and atmosphere on the deck much enjoyed..We all would like to see more varied menu.

Date of visit: July 2016
Thank Sherrie S
Reviewed September 3, 2016 via mobile

I had the duck and she had the salmon. The Proud Red was good pairing. Also had the roots appetizer. The old country house is very nice. Also good to stroll around the property

Date of visit: September 2016
Thank J3128JWchrism
Reviewed August 26, 2016

New owners, staff and menu. Food was good, but would find it difficult to return often as the entree menu was very limited. Always have enjoyed the farmhouse setting & outdoor seating. Hope to see an expanded menu soon.

Date of visit: July 2016
1  Thank Julie B
View more reviews
Nearby
Nearby HotelsSee all nearby hotels
The Gould Hotel
445 reviews
14.49 miles away
Plum Point Lodge
186 reviews
14.61 miles away
Quality Inn Near Finger Lakes and Seneca Falls
481 reviews
15.05 miles away
Hampton Inn Seneca Falls
858 reviews
15.06 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 8 nearby restaurants
1833 Kitchen & Bar
287 reviews
2.65 miles away
The Thirsty Owl Bistro
261 reviews
3.31 miles away
Cream At The Top
15 reviews
4.31 miles away
Fargo Bar & Grill
242 reviews
2.63 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 7 nearby attractions
Water to Wine Day Tours
257 reviews
3.72 miles away
Sheldrake Point Winery
170 reviews
3.89 miles away
MacKenzie-Childs
165 reviews
4.14 miles away
Bright Leaf Vineyard
15 reviews
4.48 miles away
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing