I can understand why this restauarant gets the rave reviews, but I feel it's over-reated, and most of the high ratings are really down to its location and quirkiness rather than its food.
So - location first. It's out of the hustle and bustle of...Ubud centre, which is good, but a climb (if you're walking) up a steep hill with less than good pavements. The restaurant is tucked away off the main road, just past the Bintang shopping plaza, and on the opposite side of the road. There is ample parking. The sides of the restauarant are open to wonderful views across the tree tops and steep valley, making it a photographer's dream, and there is certain quirkiness with some of the seating - low sofas and cushions for instance.
The menu at The Elephant is vegetarian, which suited two of our party as we are veggies but, having said that, there wasn't a great deal that appealed to either of us, as it seems to cater to - if I dare say it - Foodie Snobs. All the salads have animal names, there is pasta which I opted for, with the mushroom sauce and it was really good. The other veggie had pasta with pesto - equally good. Other members of the party had the laksa and said it was "okay", and the fifth person couldn't find anything that appealed so had a couple of the side orders, which again were said to be "okay". So the verdict on the mains is Good, but nothing to rave about.
There was quite a discussion over dessert, all of which appealed, but having ordered three different ones the server came back to tell us that two of the three weren't available! This wasn't a late dinner - it was around 8.00pm by this time - so were were a little surprised, and an alternative choice made. Mine was tiramasu which was really soggy and heavily laced with rum flavouring - not nice. The lemon tart - chosen as the alternative - didn't taste of lemon and the pastry was thick and chewy - again not nice. Ice cream - what can you say about it other than it's not the best quality.
Finally when it came to paying the bill, I wanted to split it into two separate ones, but was told - in a somewhat brusque and curt manner - that "we don't split bills for parties over four". I was shown a typed notice to this effect taped to the side of the counter whiere it couldn't easily be seen - now, surely, if this is restuarant policy, this should be displayed somewhere prominent? Maybe at the entrance, or on the counter near the till? I understand the policy, but come on Elephant, put it where it can be seen - even on the menus might be an idea.
All in all, whilst the meal was acceptable, it was absolutely nothing to rave about. Location, maybe, food maybe not.More