Saw this shop described online so decided to take a road trip. From St Augustine where we spend the winter. The quiche one of the best we've ever tasted. Ditto for chicken pot pie. Only complaint is about the dessert pies with fillings as some...didn't have much filling. But recommend it nonetheless.More
The pies are made in the building are are very good.hey do not offer discounts for quantity so a six slice pie costs six times a single slice and a slice is not cheap to begin with. But if you want cheap pies go to...Publix. They have a couple tables so you can eat there. They can even serve your pie ala mode. But they really are basically just a bakery.More
I am so happy I discovered this wonderful bakery. It has taken me years of living here to find a good bakery and one that can make a good lemon meringue pie. Their pies are beyond good, they are absolutely fabulous. The pies are made...with love and the best ingredients. It is a gem that is not to be missed. I highly recommend Pie Heaven.More
We stopped here for lunch to check out the various pies they had for lunch. We tried the Shepherd's Pie and Quiche South West and both had Country Chocolate pie for dessert. We both loved our pies and are planning a return trip. I even...bought a piece of Strawberry Rhubarb pie to bring home.More
These baked from scratch pies are truly delicious. Lots of love goes into them, it is obvious. They also used organic ingredients whenever they can, which I appreciate. Chicken pot pie is my favorite, but the organic cherry is my second favorite. Oh and then...there's the blueberry pie, oh and the chili pie with cornbread crust and.....haha, you have to go check it out for yourself. Such sweet people work there and their pies are delicious. They give some of their profits to charity and they are always giving pies to people who help them with any kind of labor (I saw it a few times as I was waiting in line for my pie). Love supporting Pie Heaven!More
My daughter buys me a key lime pie from here every year for my birthday. It's always outstanding. This year she added a slice of berry pie. That was even better than the key lime. Now I want to try every pie they make.
Off the beaten path - locally made pies. Delicious pecan and key lime pie and kids love their savory chicken pot pie.
We heard about this place and our son decided to try it in place of a birthday cake this year. He chose the blueberry pie and it was amazing! So full of flavor and the crust complemented it wonderfully. They even sang Happy Birthday to...him when we came in and were just a super sweet group of ladies. I definitely plan to try their other options and appreciate the military discount they offer.More
Noticed this little gem on way to Timacuan for a hike. Stopped in today w/ a friend for a slice and cup of coffee. Only Margarita Key Lime available by slice due to heavy baking of whole pies mfor Thanksgiving. Excellent flavor, smooth as silk...texture and easy on the booze. Great French press coffee. Very friendly staff. All about feeding the hungry children of our world. Bought a whole mincemeat for holiday — beautiful pie.More
My sister discovered this charming bakery café when looking for a last minute gift for a dinner party. She bought a pie for the dinner only to discover that her host had also bought one from the same store because it was her favourite pie...shop. Pies are available by the slice or whole (large or small) and they can be made gluten free. The selection changes daily and seasonally as the store uses the freshest ingredients and does everything by hand from scratch. The service is friendly and the store supports charities that feed children. You will have a hard time selecting. My family had a reunion in April and ordered several different slices and pies. My sister's favourites are the caramel apple pie and the chocolate bourbon pecan. My brother-in-law loved the margarita key lime pie and I liked the chili and corn bread pie, the chocolate cloud, and the coconut cream. The wild Maine blueberry pie and the chicken pot pie were also big hits. Don't miss this delicious place if you're in Jacksonville!More
My husband is a pie lover. He is such a pie lover that he always wants pie for his birthday instead of a cake. So when we saw the sign for Pie Heaven we just had to stop in. We both had chicken pot pies....He said the crusts were good. The filling was so-so. He had a blueberry pie and I had key lime. His blueberry pie was on the dry side. My key lime was way too sweet. For a place that ONLY offers pies we were kinda disappointed.More
The pies from here are great! We have tried the Chili Pie, Chicken Pot Pie and Key Lime Pie - all are very good.
Stayed in Mayport my first trip to Jax Beach and after driving by this several times, I had to stop. The pie is INCREDIBLE! (Get some Whit’s vanilla custard for the top to really blow you away). Highly recommended!
What a fantastic place this is! Amazing pies fresh made either to go, or to order. Absolutely charming, definitely get your next pie here!
Aw, thanks! We truly appreciate that you took the time to say such nice things.
Can't come to the Jacksonville area without getting some pie from The Pie Haven Bakery and Cafe. Their crust is full of flavor and when available I can't resist getting the pie crust cinnamon pinwheels, just like Mom used to make! The strawberry rhubarb had...just the right amount of sweet tart mix, the coconut custard silky and just sweet enough. Find this Pie Haven if you're in the area!More
