Yum! We saw this on the show and was in the area so stopped bye. It was pricey but very good. Cheesy goodness.
1 - 10 of 42 reviews
This pizza is the BEES KNEES. I have eaten here several times, & it's always good. Fresh tasting, crispy (but not too crispy), satiating in every way. I take my pizza standards pretty seriously, and Paul's does it for me every single time.
If you like thin crust, New York style pizza then this is your destination. If you want thick, gooey, pre-frozen commercial cardboard then keep moving. Pizzas are made fresh right in front of you. Very large slices that you fold and enjoy. Great service, even...More
Big slices for cheap by-the-slice prices, excellent specialty pizzas (I like the godfather, my family likes the Pepperoni special and the Olive special), very big serving sizes.
A party of three. We saw this place on Diners Drive Ins and Dives and were quite excited to eat there as we all love Italian food. What a major disappointment. We had looked up the menu on the internet and had each decided on...More
We had the largest pizza to share among four of us. The slices are huge, we folded the slices order to eat them. Good beverage selection.
Kayaking Humboldt Bay in the morning - Hiking Fern Canyon in the afternoon and we were all looking for someplace casual with a diverse menu. We found it at Paul's Live from New York Pizza. Saw the Eureka restaurant on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives and...More
This place is delicious! I love their pizza and specially their veggie Lasagna ( it is so cheezy!). It is just a bit more expensive than your average pizza place.
Paul's in Arcata is now located at 655 Samoa Blvd. The pizza is still just as good. In future visits I will try the calzones and the sausage, pepper and onion sandwich.