Zaytinya's menu is a combination of Turkish, Lebanese and Greek cuisine, a delightful Mediterranean melange. Most dishes are served as "small plates" (which would be called tapas in a Spanish setting or mezze in the Middle East). Our weekend lunch included some of the creamiest,...purest and best hommus ($10) we've had in a long time, and a plate of crisp falafel ($12) served with cherry tomatoes and delicious tahini sauce. We also enjoyed a plate called "bantijian bil laban" ($11), which turned out to be crispy-fried eggplant balls with roasted garlic sauce and mint, cardamom and pistachios. A plate of mushroom "kapnista" ($16) proved surprisingly satisfying with its dates, walnuts and cumin. We decided to share a serving of spanikopita ($14), which was served, unusually, as a modestly-sized roll of phylo encasing pureed spinach; it was very tasty.
We couldn't resist ordering for dessert the Turkish chocolate cake ($9), a satisfying, warm lava-cake served with roasted pistachios and a small ball of ice cream.
Seating at Zaytinya is very comfortable, at light wood tables with generous cushioned seats. The restaurant's high ceiling, huge windows and open interior dividers give an airy, uncluttered feeling. Our server was excellent, fully knowledgeable about each dish's ingredients, careful to inquire about allergies and even cross-contamination issues, and attentive to our desire to "stage" our dining by spacing the arrival of our small plate choices. Our water glasses never went dry, and plates were cleared promptly, but only after asking our permission. Zaytinya's trademark warm, puffed pita was addictive with its olive oil accompaniment. Our reservation, made using the restaurant's own online system, worked perfectly and was honored promptly upon our arrival. The sound level was definitely "energetic," but not intrusive, allowing diners to converse without raising their voices.
There's an upstairs area offering long tables for large groups, and the semi-secluded bar area allows for dining either at the bar or at nearby tables.More