We were in Eleuthera the week after New Years. This time of year was great almost every beach we went to was like have a private beach. What a beautiful Island with so many different beaches. Twin cove, Queens Bath, Lighthouse Beach, Ten bay and...French Leave. The Anchor Bay fish fry was so much fun! The staff is super friendly, but like I said get here early. It starts at 7 and they were sold out of fish and chicken by 8:15. The pork here is also good. They close the street and a DJ plays music so everyone can get there grove on. All in all a great experience.More

We stopped in to get a drink before our dinner at the Buccaneers Club. Very fun to walk around and see and talk with people. The Food look great, fried fish and BBQ chicken with sides. Everyone was having a great time

Super fun place for a Friday night on the island. All the tourist get there earlier and locals around 9 or so. We got there before 8 and they had nothing but pork chops left which were okay (fish and chicken should have also been...available). The highlight was the conch ninja which technically is not a part of the fish fry. Giving the rating based on the food. Because of the experience, I do think it’s a must stop for visitors on a Friday night in Eleuthera.More

Beware, the rum Bobby’s are quite strong! Came and had a few rum drinks ($7 each) and the fried fish, and let me tell ya the rum drinks had us on our asses! Was definitely a fun night filled with good food, music, and limbo....Wouldn’t recommend the pork chop thoughMore

What a great time! The food and drinks were fantastic (one Rum Bubba may be enough!), the dancing and limbo were a ton of fun. The whole family enjoyed a great evening out. We didn't get to try the conch salad, but some delicious baked...goods were being sold that we had to try. To hear that all of the workers are volunteering, and that the proceeds go to a good cause made it even better.More

This place is a party! We ate yummy food and danced the night away. The potato salad is the BEST!! The conch salad is alright but expensive...$16 for one small salad.

I read so many great things about Anchor Bay Fish Fry. We bought special outfits to dress up and go hang with the locals. Well...this more of a tourist party than a locals party. There are some locals that join in on the fun but...not like I was expecting. Don’t get me wrong...this fish fry is A LOT OF FUN! Eleuthera does a great job of putting on a fun party for their guest on the island and you definitely need to go if for no other reason the experience and to support the island with revenue. Everyone needs to try a Rum Bubba in their lifetime!! I had the fish and fresh conch salad for dinner. The guy makes the conch salad right in front of you as you order it. It was delicious and I ate it before I remembered to take a picture. My other family members had the pork chops and chicken. We really enjoyed our food and the drinks.More

I missed this on my first visit in February and was determined to make it this time around! Got there early, which was a good thing as they get really busy really quick! Fun to watch the guys bbqing the food, you meet all kinds...of folks from all over the world. Rum bubba's, yep, it's true, only have 1 (or 2...)! There was a sweet little potcake roaming around very daintily taking food from those who offered. Did I mention music?? It's a fun time, I left before dark, don't want to drive after dark, especially after a rum bubba (or 2)!More

Make your way down to the waterfront on Friday night to enjoy a beautiful meal. Even as a vegetarian, they had a bunch of sides you could eat in addition to some local beer and/or cocktail. The fish was fresh, perfectly sautéed and flavored to...perfection. Just make sure you are not afraid of an entire fish on your plate.More

A really beautiful evening and a great way to wrap up a week on Eleuthera. The music, local food, and atmosphere are not to be missed. We had rented just down the street so walking to dinner was a plus!

This was a really fun night. Lots of locals and people out dancing and enjoying the evening. The food was my favorite on the island- peas and rice along with fish, pork or chicken.

It's a fun gathering. No, it's not the finest food on the island, or even in town. It's a community fundraiser, and put on by volunteers. It's a fun opportunity to mingle with other travelers and residents, and see the town at night. If you...can't have a good time here, you probably shouldn't be in the Out Islands. Relax, have a Rum Bubba and enjoy the music.More