Frequently out of food & drastically understaffed. Deserved to close. Replaced by the "Picnic Basket", which we haven't tried yet

This place is now closed and is the site of the Picnic Basket. I thought Nifty's would make it; it had good food with generous servings. However, the service was really slow.

The service and food was great . Homemade to order not fast food. Tasty and healthy, served hot with all the right flavors. Good job Niftys Keep up the good work and high quality.

I had some family up for a visit and was looking for a place to eat. Since our normal restaurant was extremely busy we decided to try Nifty's Diner in Pinetop, AZ. The restaurant had only 4 tables occupied and it took over 10 minutes...More

Yesterday, I met a friend for a late lunch at Nifty's. I had not been there yet, but my friend has been a number of times, and it was his suggestion. When I arrived, somehow my friend had convinced them to give us both a...More

I love the size and quality of their portions. Their appetizers really were amazing. I had the battered mushrooms and the onion rings. You get a massive plate. I'll be back.

Nifty's has a good choice of Burgers and sandwiches but my favorites are the Fabian burger smoothered with sauteed mushrooms and cheese and the Green Chili Cheeseburger (Not on menu yet but available on request). The burger are big and very tasty. Homemade chips are...More

I quit going there after I was told this one Sunday at lunch. To be fair, they had only been open a few weeks at that point, but there are too many good places for wasting time on this kind of thing to be productive....More

We enjoy having breakfast out a few times a week and find ourselves coming back often to Nifty's Diner. There is a friendly atmosphere and the service is done with a smile. The meal itself is always made from very fresh ingredients (I especially like...More

I love the macaroni bites and the Reuben sandwich. My husband's favorite dish is the Fabian burger, which is smothered in sauteed mushrooms and usually comes with Swiss cheese, but he has them substitute melted blue cheese crumbles instead. The staff is always friendly, and...More