We were recently in St-Paul-de-Vence for four nights and had made reservations for Le Tilleul for our second night's dinner. Walking past the restaurant several times on the days leading up to our reservation, I was exceptionally excited to be having dinner here. Unfortunately, I...think my expectations got the better of me as our experience was, at best, average.
The outside seating area is lovely and as the sun was setting, it was an ideal spot. But what one fails to realize on walk-bys is how close the tables are placed to each other. Thankfully, we had a lovely couple from Paris next to us who were delightful, but I think they were looking for a little more privacy as were we.
The food was presented lovely, but lacked much flavor or style. I had the special ceviche, which appeared beautiful, but was ill-prepared and actually made me ill later in the evening (the ceviche wasn't cured long enough, thus basically serving sushi, which requires a special cut of fish. If properly cured, the fish will be opaque throughout...which this wasn't). We have a house in Costa Rica, where ceviche is prepared frequently and expertly, so I'm familiar with under-cured preparations, which this was. I wanted to tell the waitress, but she couldn't be found or bothered with my views (see below). And while my shrimp entree was properly cooked, it lacked much flavor and was basically grilled shrimp.
Compounding our less-than-perfect food experience, our waitress was perfunctory at best. I've owned hospitality establishments and I can immediately tell if staff is just going through the motions or if they're being professional and attentive. Clearly our waitress was simply going through the motions. Outside of delivering food and taking orders, there was never any interaction (hence my inability to question the preparation of the ceviche).
We spend three weeks in the south of France and,outside of this experience, never did we ever have a less-than-wonderful meal. I don't leave less-than-glowing reviews often, but this place deserves it. It was terribly disappointing and I was expecting so much more.More