Stopped here for lunch after spending the morning at the laundromat. Good pizza. Nice and fresh salad bar. Opens at 11:30 for lunch.
1 - 10 of 45 reviews
I LOVE pizza. It's my favorite food. In the world. So when we travel, we inevitably order one. Had a take out from goodfellas tonight. Just pepperoni and Italian sausage. Holy cow! Great pizza! Best crust I've had in ages! And the sausage was so...More
My husband and I recently stopped by Goodfellas for a pizza dinner. Although the pizza was good, the overall feeling of the restaurant felt shabby and neglected. Order your pizza to go!
Cashier was very dry I completely cleaned the table minus wiping it down brought everything up to the counter. Didn't get a thank you & on the way said thank you the pizza was very delicious all you heard was crickets. I would buy again...More
I am a local so I have visited almost every month of the year. I am a pizza snob and a s far as I am concerned, there is NO pizza outside of New York. Having said that, I actually love their sandwiches best. Their...More
We ordered our pizza to go so we could take it back to the hotel. Pizza and wings were both very tasty, although we were a little disappointed with the limited selection of sauces for the wings. We had the Goodfellas special, which was very...More
Not fancy, but good food. Love the pizza and sandwiches. Skip the chain fast food and try this! The staff is kind and helpful.
I'm a Tahoe local and have been going to Goodfellas for years. They make a good pizza, not the cheapest in town by any stretch, but good. The attitude of the owner has never been great, warm or welcoming, but today it really hit a...More
We compared many pizza places and their prices in the South Lake Tahoe area. We chose Goodfellas Pizza because of their price. After tasting the pizza we knew we had done well. Not only were the prices reasonable but the food tasted delicious! We had...More