We ate breakfast here on our last day of vacay and I wish we'd have eaten here much sooner! The food was great! The staff was very friendly with great attitudes! They all seemed happy to work there & the owner stopped by our table...to say hi and ask if we enjoyed our meal. We rally enjoyed sitting at their outside tables eating breakfast in the AMMore

We went a few times for coffee here and the owner always greeted us by the door! It is a friendly bustling atmosphere and lots of room to sit inside or outside. It was my go-to place for grabbing a coffee to go.

We love the vibe and the food at Shay’s. We also enjoy dining al fresco and visiting with other tourists.

This is a wonderful place for breakfast or lunch. Fresh food, bloody Mary’s and Mimosas. Owner is on hand to help with anything you need. We will definitely return. Fair prices and fabulous food.

After seeing the reviews I was looking forward to checking the place out. First impressions were good, it was busy and the owner was super friendly. However the food let it down, the Mrs went for eggs Benedict which was very undercooked, she ended up...not eating it. Her crepes were too thick, almost like pancakes in the UK. I had a chicken panini which was average. The server noticed the plate of eggs Benedict left over and I said it was too sloppy. She nodded and said "OK" and walked off, that was the last we heard. I wouldn't go back.More

Greatest oatmeal with fruit ever…. We’ve been going there for years and it’s a great place to catch up with old friends

With, virtually, nowhere else to eat (no IHOP, Denny's, etc) Shay's became my everyday breakfast place. You order and they bring it to your table, so, sought of semi-service. Food okay, nothing outrageous.

Great breakfast place with fantastic crepes and lots of other goodies! Cute outdoor seating with reasonable pricing!

My friend and I went here every morning during our short, 5 day stay. The food was great, we enjoyed breakfast sandwiches, omeletes, french toast and eggs benny. The food came out quickly and tasted very fresh. We also enjoyed mimosas and friendly conversation from...the staff. Shay cafe was a great start to our day every morning! Thanks againMore

Very well run and ready restaurant. The owner is always present on busy morning keeping things moving and making sure everyone is happy. It is a great feeling knowing you are taken care of. This place is always hopping in the morning because the food...is so great. I would highly suggest their pancakes, absolutely delicious. This cafe is mostly tourists with no serious island feel. All in all, great place for families.More

The food is good. The coffee is good as well as the sandwiches and wraps. More importantly the friendliness of the owner. He is there all the time or at least when I was there and he remembers who you are.

Great lil breakfast with terrific customer service. We liked it so much we went back twice. We had the same server both days and she was delightful. It was funny to find out, when we complemented her, that we have the same last name, Benjamin....She was a delight. My daughter could not get enough of the pastries or the chocolate chip pancakes. Well done, Shay Cafe!More