We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Anegada is beautiful.... this place is not. You must order food at lunchtime for the dinner service (with “service” being an overstatement). Arrive at 7:30, meal comes out in pieces. The freshly caught lobster has been destroyed by a massive “bbq” of driftwood (yuck) and...More
We had no reservations which are required. Fortunately they were able to squeeze in our party of two. The dinner of anegada lobster was amazing! The staff was cordial, friendly and efficient. truly a spectacular experience.
Had not planned on going to Potters but did get swayed to go by Sam's morning serenade at out boat. Reservations are definitely needed. We were a party of 6 and between us we had the Mahi, Lobsters, Steak and Ribs. Everyone enjoyed their food...More
We've been coming to the BVI for 35 years and to Anegada since 2004. Potters has been a tradition for us. This year we were extremely disappointed. Food was mediocre at best. Ordered whole lobsters and received halves, when questioned, we were told it was...More
We recently made our first trip to Anegada while sailing the BVI’s. The entire experience was nothing but great. If you like Lobster, this is the place for you. Fresh lobster is the best. I ordered the Lobster Fetticini. The serving was huge and I...More
Stopped here for some of the biggest and freshest lobster I've ever had, only to find out that they smoked it over what amounted to driftwood. It was terrible. Even so I was looking forward to hanging out with friends on our vacation of a...More
Consider making reservations AND making your dinner order early in the day (we did so when we arrived at Anegada) at Potters. We asked locals and were told "Potters is the best lobster, but service is slow." However, we had excellent, fast service; and the...More
Best dinner of the week at Potters By the Sea!! It was a perfect evening low humidity, slightly cool, sitting on a dock watching the sunset. And the food was outstanding!
Reservations and orders are required by 4pm because the seafood is sourced locally and...More