Replay Restaurant & Bar

Someone from this business manages this listing.

#1 of 5 Bars & Pubs in Simpson BayAmerican, Brew Pub, $$ - $$$

What is Travelers’ Choice?

Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.

Replay Restaurant & Bar

Review

At a glance

+ Add hours

Website

+1 721-544-2503Improve this listing

About

Replay Restaurant & Bar offers food selections on the menu for every level of appetite, wings, pizza and assorted snacks to share. Whether you choose to class up the action with “craft cocktails” or stick with an ice cold brew, we’re eager to treat you to a unique bar experience on site at Simpson Bay Resort & Marina.

Features

CUISINES

American, Brew Pub, Bar, Pizza, Pub

Meal types

Lunch, Dinner

PRICE

$$ - $$$

FEATURES

Full Bar

Outdoor Seating

Reservations

Seating

Serves Alcohol

Table Service

Takeout

Television

Location

Billy Folly Road 37 Simpson Bay Resort Marina Plaza, Simpson Bay St Martin / St Maarten

Does this restaurant offer outdoor seating?

Yes

Unsure

Save this restaurant

Hours

Add hours

No hours available

Contribute

Write a review

Upload a photo

Ask a question

4.5

197 reviews

Excellent

138

Very good

Average

Poor

Terrible

Bernard B

2 contributions

Couples Vacation Dinner

Sep 2023 • couples

The atmosphere of the restaurant was Great! The management and servers were even better! Our server, Naomi, was Excellent! You can really tell she cares for her customers through her engaging conversation and knowledge of the business’s tasty menu. My wife and our friends had a wonderful time.

Written September 13, 2023

This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for choosing Replay Restaurant & Bar and for taking the time to share your experience with us. We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed the great atmosphere and that our management and servers made your visit even more memorable. Naomi is indeed an invaluable member of our team, and we're delighted to read about her excellent service, engaging conversations, and knowledge of our menu. It's wonderful to hear that you and your wife, along with your friends, had a wonderful time dining with us. We look forward to serving you all again soon, and thank you for your kind words.

Written September 15, 2023

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

Louis C

1 contribution

Nov 2023 • solo

Have visited Replay several times during my week stay at Simpson Bay resort. Each time was greeted nicely by the staff. This time my server was Natasha. Very pleasant and attentive. Definitely recommend Replay for a nice meal and experience. I complemented the executive chef when he came by my table on this meal and prior meals

Written November 17, 2023

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your positive experiences at Replay Restaurant & Bar during your stay at Simpson Bay Resort. We are delighted to hear that you visited us multiple times and consistently received a warm welcome from our staff. It's wonderful that Natasha, your server, provided pleasant and attentive service, contributing to a memorable dining experience. We appreciate your recommendation and are thrilled that you enjoyed the meals prepared by our executive chef. Your compliments have been shared with the team, and we look forward to welcoming you back to Replay for more delicious meals and exceptional service in the future.

Written November 21, 2023

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

Edwina S

4 contributions

GREAT FOOD, DRINKS, & SERVICE

Sep 2023 • couples

This was the first restaurant we tried when we arrived. My husband had the burger and fries, and I had the Fish & Chips (It was red snapper with steak fries). We also got to enjoy Happy Hour. Beer was 2/$7, and my frozen daiquiri was buy one get one free! EVERYTHING was good, including the service!! We will definitely go back. Thanks Kanna for being a great waitress and everyone else there who was so nice to us.

Written September 24, 2023

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for choosing Replay Restaurant & Bar as your first dining destination upon your arrival, and for sharing your wonderful experience with us! We're delighted to hear that you both enjoyed your meals, from the burger and fries to the red snapper Fish & Chips, along with the Happy Hour offerings. It's fantastic to know that everything met your expectations, including the service provided by Kanna and our friendly team. Your kind words are greatly appreciated, and we're thrilled to hear that you plan to return. We can't wait to welcome you back for another memorable dining experience!

Written September 25, 2023

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

jampet

Edmond248 contributions

Pizza and wing night

Sep 2024 • couples

We went here 09/20 for dinner. The restaurant doesn’t show open but it is. This was our first night on the island and we knew we would have left over pizza for lunch the next day. Pizza, wings & drinks good. We ask to sit outside & no server came to take our order. After sitting there for a bit a guy came out & checked on us & after he realized no one took our order he was quick to put our order in. We have dined here before but never had anything like this happen. Great casual place to dine with water front view.

Written September 29, 2024

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We’re glad you enjoyed the pizza, wings, and drinks, and we appreciate your feedback about the service. We strive for timely and attentive service, and we apologize for the oversight during your visit. It's great to hear that you enjoyed the waterfront view, and we’re grateful for your loyalty as a returning guest. We hope to welcome you back soon.

Written September 30, 2024

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

ttkaiser

Albany111 contributions

Excellent food and fun

Nov 2023 • family

Had dinner at the bar with my Husband and brother tonight. The service from Anja the bartender was excellent! My husband enjoyed the chicken sandwich which Anja recommended…I had the cob salad and my Brother had a sushi roll. We all loved our meal and highly recommend the sports bar for a fun and layed back atmosphere.

Written November 3, 2023

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for choosing Replay Restaurant & Bar and for taking the time to share your wonderful dining experience with us. We are glad to hear that you enjoyed the excellent service provided by Anja and that her recommendations were spot on. It's fantastic to know that your husband's chicken sandwich, your cob salad, and your brother's sushi roll were all to your satisfaction. We take pride in creating a fun and laid-back atmosphere for our guests, and your high recommendation truly means the world to us. We look forward to welcoming you, your husband, and your brother back for another memorable visit to our sports bar in the near future. Cheers to good times and great food!

Written November 6, 2023

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

whippetguy

Little Rock131 contributions

Bland food in a nice location

Dec 2021 • solo

Decided to eat here while staying at the Simpson Bay Resort and Marina. It’s located over the bay beach with dining inside or outside, very nice location. It wasn’t too busy so I was seated promptly outside. Service was average which says a lot on an island where everywhere else you go, you’re treated like royalty. I had cheesy fries to start which was basically a lot of fries completely smothered in a lake of ?american cheese. You had to eat it with a fork/spoon since there were no fries with areas to pick up without having soupy cheese all over your hands. There was no taste to the dish, not even a cheesy taste, completely weird. Main course was a pepperoni pizza which again had absolutely no flavor. Also a sports bar with continuous tracks of Celine Dion playing, really?? I would not recommend this place to anyone. If not for the location and the average service, I would’ve given it a 1 out of five.

Written December 28, 2021

Lorne P

122 contributions

Good place to watch a game

Nov 2024 • couples

My wife and I shared an appetizer platter. It came with Chicken wings, Poppers, Mozzarella sticks, and Onion rings, celery and carrot sticks. The food was average at best. The view was nice and the service was good.

Written November 28, 2024

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We’re happy to hear you enjoyed the lovely view and attentive service during your visit. At Replay Restaurant & Bar, we’re always looking for ways to enhance the quality of our dishes and ensure every guest leaves satisfied. We hope you’ll visit us again soon and give us another chance to impress you.

Written November 29, 2024

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

Edward G

15 contributions

Great bar food.

Aug 2024 • couples

We were the only customers, at prime dinner time. The staff was nice. The view of the ocean was outside. The food was bar food, onion rings, chicken nubs, mozzarella sticks, etc. Two highlights: the marinara and blue cheese were homemade and were ON POINT. We wanted beer and bar food, and we got it. Great place to eat when you're drunk.

Written September 6, 2024

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We're glad to hear that you enjoyed the homemade marinara and blue cheese—it's always great to know our house-made items hit the mark. While we aim to provide a relaxed atmosphere with tasty bar food and a great ocean view, your comments will help us continue to improve our service and offerings. We appreciate your visit and hope to welcome you back for another enjoyable experience in the future.

Written September 9, 2024

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

Dgem

New Jersey130 contributions

Great Burger!

Mar 2023 • couples

We did not experience any of the negative issues other reviewers did. I was really craving a burger, so we stopped in about 1:30 on a Monday afternoon for lunch outside. There was nobody else outside but us and the friendly server came over right away and took our orders. The burger was FANTASTIC - hot & juicy and hit the spot! Fries were good too. My husband enjoyed his fish & chips as well.

Written March 31, 2023

Gerardo G.

Hello, Thank you for your review and for choosing us. We are happy that you enjoyed your meal and we are looking forward to having you again as a guest .

Written April 4, 2023

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

GCK

Kemmerer34 contributions

Nice hideaway at Simpson Bay Resort

Dec 2023 • family

Easy, laid back atmosphere to catch a game and food. Next to the bay and beach. Quickly became our go to spot while staying at Simpson Bay Resort. Our waitress, Nikaury, was amazing, remembered all of our favorite drinks, and had lots of ideas for great excursions on the island. She always has a great attitude and makes you feel at home.

Written December 21, 2023

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for taking the time to share your positive experience at Replay Restaurant & Bar. We're delighted to hear that our easy and laid-back atmosphere, coupled with a prime location next to the bay and beach, made us your go-to spot during your stay at Simpson Bay Resort. We're especially thrilled to receive such commendations for Nikaury, who went above and beyond to enhance your dining experience. It's heartening to know that she not only remembered your favorite drinks but also shared valuable insights into exciting excursions on the island. We take pride in providing exceptional service, and it's great to hear that Nikaury's warm attitude made you feel at home. We appreciate your patronage and look forward to welcoming you back to Replay Restaurant & Bar for more enjoyable moments.

Written December 22, 2023

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

NisaThai

New Jersey1746 contributions

PIZZA!!!!!!!!!!!!

Apr 2024 • family

My third time staying at the Simpson Bay Resort but my very first time eating here. My mom and I decided to ordered pizza and their rum punch! Great! Great! Great!! The pizza was soooooo freaking delicious and yummy. The rum punch was good not as strong but if you drink 3-4 glasses you will feel it lol. I will definitely eat here again on one of those nights when you don’t feel like going off the resort. Just grab a table watch the sunset and enjoy!

Written April 18, 2024

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you for choosing Replay Restaurant & Bar. We're very glad to hear that you and your mom enjoyed our delicious pizza and refreshing rum punch. It's fantastic to know that you found our pizza to be "soooooo freaking delicious and yummy" and that our rum punch provided the perfect accompaniment to your meal. We appreciate your kind words and are delighted that you plan to dine with us again in the future. Our picturesque setting overlooking the sunset is indeed the perfect backdrop for a relaxing evening. We look forward to welcoming you back for another memorable dining experience at Replay Restaurant & Bar.

Written April 19, 2024

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

SantasFavorite

Williamsburg31 contributions

Fantastic food and service!!

Dec 2024 • family

Great food and service. Our waitress Sandra was fantastic. Everything was delicious. We had the fish and chips, coconut shrimp, shrimp pesto pizza and multiple sushi rolls. It was honestly perfect and delicious. Especially after a long day of travel!! Highly recommend!

Written December 3, 2024

Gerardo González

Hello, Thank you so much for your review. We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed your meal and the service provided by Sandra. It's great to know that our delicious dishes hit the spot after your long day of travel. We truly appreciate your recommendation, and we're so happy that we could make your experience memorable. We hope to welcome you back soon for another delicious meal.

Written December 5, 2024

This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.

Matt D

2 contributions

Not worth the time

Jun 2022 • couples

The low quality of food and indifferent staff defeated any notion of going back. Our food tasted like it was pre-made days prior and then microwaved. The chocolate cake was ice cold and seemed like it sat in the fridge for a month too long. We also felt like hostages just waiting to pay our bill.

Written June 20, 2022

Lilsuz G

New York City45 contributions

Great after boat ride hangout

Jul 2021 • friends

Was hungry after the sunset sail where we got rained on and just rescued a runaway flip flop. Soccer was playing but friend wanted to watch Olympics gymnastics qualifiers and bartender kindly put it on a screen. Warning there is a larger than life sized patriots clad Tom Brady revving up to throw by the unisex bathroom. Pepperoni pizza was on point and altho we thought having Japanese on the menu was strange, we ordered the la patrona special roll (it was only special roll without cream cheese) and it did not disappoint. Definitely recommend as welcome part of Simpson bay resort property.

Written July 19, 2021

Norman L

385 contributions

Great 4th of July evening

Jul 2021 • couples

The Replay Pub hosted an an evening for Independence Day with a generous buffet and grilled hamburgers and hot dogs. The hamburgers were perfect! The buffet include delicious chicken and fabulous ribs,and corn on the cob and cole slaw, my favorites. Of course, I'm not sure about daily fare and service, but July 4th was great,

Written July 7, 2021