We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
I had already been to this tiny place in Montefiridolfi, close to San Casciano nella val di Pesa, a couple of years ago, for lunch. I was very positively impressed by the friendly atmosphere (like eating with the family), the tiny but cozy place, with...very few tables, simple and warm furnishings. The manager is a courteous person, without appearing intrusive or pedantic. The cuisine with traditional dishes, and some creative excursions, for example with a spicy first course and garlic…. In August this year I went there for dinner, and we found some tables set up in the adjacent square. Here too the same taste, the same sincere courtesy, the same cuisine with a menu that is not very long but all of excellent workmanship that to define only home-made is almost an understatement.
The very generous appetizer is excellent, the first courses are wonderful, the meat is cooked to perfection, and all the side dishes are delicious. Personally I would have liked more choices of vegetables, but the desserts have calmed me down. Coffee in moka, which I really like.
The choice of wines could be enriched with a few bottles from other regions, especially for the combination with certain first courses.More
For the 2nd time I have tried to order from A Casa Mia only to be cold that they are unable to deliver to me “because you didn’t have a driver” despite being on Just East as a delivery option.
My order was for over...£50, what you couldn’t put this in a taxi and deliver it to me on my birthday. I will NEVER try your restaurant again. Shameful service.
Thanks for nothing and goodbye.More
We booked the restaurant by cooncidence, was closest to our stay. After reading TA reviews have some expectations, but were well overachieved. Ordered fantastic antipasti plate, then superb pasta, even get small portion of the really hot pasta we want to just try...was not a problem for Maurizio. Finishing with sliced steak was like desert!
Worth to visit!More
A Casa Mia is a small local restaurant tucked away in a quaint little village.
We ordered the three pastas and the caprese salad. Every dish was outstanding - the rabbit ragu was a highlight. This is a must order dish!!! We all pride ourselves...on knowing good Italian food. This has to be one of, if not the best pasta we’ve had in Italy. Another notable touch was the bottle of Chianti waiting for you at the table.
We finished our meal with coffee and dessert which were also great!
The service at this restaurant is also good - the waiter was warm and inviting! I would recommend making a reservation as the restaurant only has six tables, and is usually full of locals.More
This is certainly the local's best kept secret! With only 26 seats it's a small restaurant and must normally cater to the residents of Montefiridolfi but they welcomed us in for a lunchtime feast.
We started with antipasti for the table and were pleasantly surprised...to see such a wide selection land on our table. Everything was fresh and delicious.
We followed up with primi pasta - I opted for Rabbit ragu penne - which was also well flavoured and plentiful.
We would have had dessert but we're too full to muster another bite.
We would recommend this place as an authentic Italian restaurant, focusing on local, fresh ingredients cooked simply but very well.More