The 5 Best Last Minute Hotels in Garden City 2023

5 of 5 properties are available in Garden City

Sort by:

Best Value

Hotels

Updating list...

The Garden City Hotel

$369

Booking.com

Trip.com

$330

Algotels

$266

Priceline

$369

View all deals from $266

1,241 reviews

#1 Best Value of 5 hotels in Garden City

“I stayed here last minute to be near the hospital due to my father in laws unexpected declining health.”
“My wife and I went back to Garden City for her high school reunion and we decided to treat ourselves to a stay at the GC Hotel. The service from front desk to dining was superb. The dining room was able to...”

Special offer

Special OfferRest & Relax SPA Package

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 20 websites

La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Garden City

$151

Booking.com

Wyndham

$151

Vio.com

$141

ZenHotels.com

$164

View all deals from $130

609 reviews

#2 Best Value of 5 hotels in Garden City

“All was great except for the breakfast we don’t have to many varieties we went out for eat was our only issues and also the area wasn’t cleaned we don’t no choice no fruits no oatmeal when we asked one of the…”
“Room clean/ house keeping excellent. Breakfast/internet ok . Parking conjusted and tyne space. Other than very quiet area .. near don't have good restaurants. Key service bad and if you ask help they are not happy...”

We compared the lowest prices from 17 websites

Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island

$239

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$239

Hampton

$239

Hotels.com

$239

View all deals from $239

892 reviews

#3 Best Value of 5 hotels in Garden City

“Stayed here with multiple family members as part of a wedding room block. Hotel was at capacity and could not handle the onslaught of people checking in. Rooms were not available in time, people were annoyed…”
“Visited for a friend's wedding. All front desk was awesome, especially Victoria. She helped us Buffalonians with the railroad schedules and gave us great trips for things to do in the area. Hotel room was clean…”

Special offer

Special OfferPrice Match Guarantee

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 19 websites

Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Garden City

$319

Residence Inn

No prepayment needed

StayForLong

Expedia.com

Booking.com

View all deals from $319

45 reviews

#4 Best Value of 5 hotels in Garden City

“Tom, the front desk manager, was a real Godsend for my family back in July finding us a room (at the very last minute!)”
“Very nice hotel, clean and professional. Decent breakfast options. Staff was outstanding. Friendly and very hospitable. We were stuck after our airline canceled our flight and we had to stick around for hours...”

Special offer

Special OfferUnlock Member Rates!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 15 websites

Hyatt Place Garden City

StayForLong

Algotels

Expedia.com

Booking.com

View all 14 deals

953 reviews

#5 Best Value of 5 hotels in Garden City

“Carol was able to get a room last minute for the grooms mom.”
“I usually stay at Hiltons but I made a last minute trip and wasn't able to book with Hilton.”

Other places to stay near Garden City (25)

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

SpringHill Suites by Marriott Carle Place Garden City

$259

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$259

Algotels

$238

Destinia.com

$272

View all deals from $238

272 reviews

1.7 miles from Garden City

#3 of 4 hotels in Carle Place

“This was our second stay at this property. We came back because we knew that it was a consistently clean and comfortable place to stay. Upon checking out, the shift manager Jessica went above and beyond the call…”
“Came for quick night for soccer game. Chose this over other similar hotel Of same brand bc reviews were better. Saw the noise reviews. Expressed concern when checked in and the friendly women knew exactly what I...”

Special offer

Special OfferUnlock Member Rates!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 15 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place - Garden City, NY

$249

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$249

Skyscanner.com

$244

Algotels

$264

View all deals from $244

950 reviews

1.8 miles from Garden City

#1 of 4 hotels in Carle Place

“She answered all of our questions and made sure we got a room at the very last minute.”
“Sheryl check us in in seconds. She was warm and welcoming. Very hospitable. Like a breath of fresh air. Thanks Sheryl for making our stay. We will visit again soon.. see you soon n the next trip around. Rooms are...”

Special offer

Special OfferPrice Match Guarantee

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 18 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Red Roof PLUS+ Long Island - Garden City

$147

Booking.com

Priceline

$159

Algotels

$131

Expedia.com

$159

View all deals from $131

598 reviews

1.9 miles from Garden City

#2 of 4 hotels in Westbury

“A convenient, efficient property that could easily be a 4-star but is still a good value staffed by competent and friendly people. The room was spacious and the bed most comfortable. The front desk and…”

We compared the lowest prices from 17 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Holiday Inn Westbury-Long Island, an IHG Hotel

HolidayInn.com

Booking.com

$199

Algotels

$128

Expedia.com

$199

View all deals from $128

420 reviews

2.2 miles from Garden City

#2 of 4 hotels in Carle Place

“Good place for last minute stays”
“We have stayed at this hotel three years in a row in June for a lacrosse tournament and it just keeps getting better. Bonus: If you like good Indian food, this is your place. The rooms are clean and large enough…”

Special offer

Special OfferBook Direct & Save with IHG One Rewards

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 19 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Long Island Marriott

$259

Booking.com

Marriott Hotels

$259

Algotels

$209

Destinia.com

$272

View all deals from $209

894 reviews

2.5 miles from Garden City

#1 of 1 hotel in Uniondale

“I decided to take a last minute trip to New York and decided on the Long Island Marriott.”
“A tried & true Hotel. It has been here for a long time. We were recognized as Elite Bonvoy Members and the Assistant Front Office Manager,Shireen Nelson, upgraded us to a Family Suite. Like in Europe, breakfast…”

Special offer

Special OfferUnlock Member Rates!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 19 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island

$239

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$239

Algotels

$219

Hotels.com

$299

View all deals from $219

219 reviews

2.8 miles from Garden City

#3 of 4 hotels in Westbury

“My daughter, grandchildren and I booked a night at this hotel last-minute.”
“This is the second time our soccer team stayed at this property. Matt in the sales department was very helpful and efficient in setting up our room block. The hotel was clean and staff was very friendly. The...”

Special offer

Special OfferEarn Marriott Bonvoy bonus points on each stay

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 15 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

$229

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$229

Vio.com

$213

Destinia.com

$230

View all deals from $213

957 reviews

2.8 miles from Garden City

#4 of 4 hotels in Westbury

“Came into town for a concert and was pleasantly surprised by the convenience and accommodations of this hotel, especially ring last minute.”
“Decent quick stay at this property. Convenient Long Island location to many things nearby. Much more affordable option than Brooklyn or queens. Bed was decent. Bathroom little outdated. Did not stay for breakfast...”

Special offer

Special OfferPrice Match Guarantee

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 18 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Best Western Mill River Manor

$235

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$235

Algotels

$204

BestWestern.com

$235

View all deals from $204

926 reviews

4.8 miles from Garden City

#2 of 3 hotels in Rockville Centre

“Stayed 3 nights for family funeral so had no expectations. Just needed convenience. But, the entire staff here was very attentive, very hard-working, helpful and excellent at their jobs. Starting with Sean who...”

Special offer

Special OfferClick Here to Book Direct. Lowest Rate Guarantee!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 18 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Hampton Inn & Suites Rockville Centre

$354

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$354

Skyscanner.com

$335

Hampton

$354

View all deals from $335

818 reviews

4.8 miles from Garden City

#1 of 3 hotels in Rockville Centre

“We have stayed at this Hampton Inn several times and always found the staff work very hard to please. Even the breakfast cooking staff spend the time to interact with the guess. I recently left a small item…”
“The staff weee friendly and responsive. The room was quiet and clean and the coffee in the morning was SO GOOD I will Be back that’s for sure My family also enjoyed their stay as well. You can’t beat the...”

Special offer

Special OfferPrice Match Guarantee

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 17 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Ramada by Wyndham Rockville Centre

$152

Booking.com

Wyndham

$152

Algotels

$119

Expedia.com

$152

View all deals from $119

954 reviews

4.9 miles from Garden City

#3 of 3 hotels in Rockville Centre

“If you are looking for romance or beauty pass on this property. Location was great, appearance was not. Breakfast was typical for Ramada. The only real complaint is the front desk agent said the incidental credit...”

We compared the lowest prices from 17 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Econo Lodge Hicksville

$119

Booking.com

Choice Hotels

$119

Vio.com

$99

ZenHotels.com

$128

View all deals from $99

179 reviews

5.0 miles from Garden City

#1 of 2 hotels in Hicksville

“The front desk people were very friendly, accommodating, and helpful. The room was clean and comfortable but definitely no frills. And the hotel seemed to be in a quiet area. At least we couldn't hear much outside...”

Special offer

Special OfferBook Direct For Lowest Price!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 19 websites

Missing:In Garden CityB&Bs & Inns

Casa Azul Hotel Blu

$189

Booking.com

No prepayment needed

Expedia.com

$180

Best Last Minute Hotel Deals in Garden City, NY

Last Minute Hotels in Garden City

Deals

Property types

Popular

Amenities

Hotel class

Style

Brands