THE 10 CLOSEST Hotels to Fort Fincastle, Nassau - Tripadvisor

125 properties in Nassau

Sort by:

Best Value

Resorts
Hotels
All-inclusives
50 mi from Fort Fincastle

Like saving money? We search up to 200 sites to help you save up to 30%

Updating list...

Highest-rated hotel within 1.4 miles of Fort Fincastle

Based on availability on Tripadvisor for Dec 12 - Dec 13

Comfort Suites Paradise Island

$274

$147

Tripadvisor

View Deal

Agoda.com

$147

Orbitz.com

$226

Trip.com

$274

View all 14 deals from $147

3,098 reviews

Paradise Island Dr, SS 6202, New Providence Island

1.4 miles from Fort Fincastle

#1 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“Was here for my wife's side of the family reunion. We enjoyed this hotel. Rooms and facility was clean and staff was friendly. The breakfast was pretty plain American style and just okay. They offered a nice...”

Special offer

Special OfferKids Stay, Play & Eat Free

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 14 websites

Towne Hotel

$115

$106

Tripadvisor

View Deal

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Booking.com

$106

Agoda.com

$106

Orbitz.com

$115

View all 9 deals from $106

296 reviews

40 George Street | P.O. Box N-4808, Nassau, New Providence Island

0.5 miles from Fort Fincastle

#2 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“Why this hotel hasn't been closed down is a mystery. The rooms are full of cheap/ broken furniture, tv doesn't work. Air conditioning is too noisy to have on for long. Management is aggressive. Breakfast is…”

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Nassau

$189

HIExpress.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Agoda.com

$189

Orbitz.com

$161

Trip.com

$216

View all 12 deals from $161

118 reviews

West Bay Street at Nassau Street, Nassau, New Providence Island

0.8 miles from Fort Fincastle

#3 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“The hotel is a perfect location to fish fry, downtown and directly across the street from the beach. Our room was updated w/fridge. We traveled during covid & the hotel pratice safety precautions. Hotel staff...”

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Melia Nassau Beach - All Inclusive

$319

Booking.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Agoda.com

$270

Orbitz.com

$321

Prestigia.com

$400

View all 13 deals from $270

8,844 reviews

West Bay Street, Nassau, New Providence Island

3.9 miles from Fort Fincastle

#4 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“Keith our driver/guide took us to the ‘queens steps’ that was a deep pathway carved by slave laborers out of a monolithic rock and with steps on one end leading upto the Fort Fincastle.”

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites

Warwick Paradise Island Bahamas - All Inclusive

$299

Expedia.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Orbitz.com

$299

Snaptravel

$275

Prestigia.com

$589

View all 13 deals from $275

1,550 reviews

Harbour Drive, New Providence Island

1.4 miles from Fort Fincastle

#5 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We felt incredibly safe as we went to: Fort Fincastle, Pirates of Nassau, John Watling's Distillery, and Pirate Republic Brewing.”

We compared the lowest prices from 13 websites

Hotel Riu Palace Paradise Island

$378

Expedia.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Pay up to 12X

Agoda.com

$310

ZenHotels.com

$236

Riu.com

$312

View all 11 deals from $236

1,295 reviews

6307 Casino Drive | Paradise Island - Bahamas, 6307, New Providence Island

1.6 miles from Fort Fincastle

#6 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We booked the "best of nassau" tour which includes a tour of the: atlantis grounds, market under the bridge, rum cake factory, queens staircase with the straw market and fort fincastle ($3 pp to enter), john watli...”

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 11 websites

Bay View Suites Paradise Island

$275

$104

Tripadvisor

View Deal

Trip.com

$275

Agoda.com

$110

Booking.com

$110

View all 12 deals from $104

224 reviews

Bay View Dr/Harbour Ridge Road, New Providence Island

1.5 miles from Fort Fincastle

#7 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“Having to stay in Nassau for 1 night due to a business trip, I decided to stay at this hotel. After the short registration I was positively surprised about the size of the room which is most likely like an...”

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Graycliff Hotel

$300

Booking.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Trip.com

$380

Snaptravel

$279

Hurb

$388

View all 12 deals from $279

258 reviews

West Hill Street, Nassau 10246, New Providence Island

0.5 miles from Fort Fincastle

#8 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We were wandering around Nassau in the morning and dropped in for coffee and orange juice. The main sitting/dining rooms are quite lovely, with lots of light. Very historical theme in main rooms. Grounds are...”

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Courtyard Nassau Downtown Junkanoo Beach

$149

Courtyard

View Deal

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Expedia.com

$149

Agoda.com

$127

Trip.com

$163

View all 12 deals from $127

260 reviews

West Bay Street, Nassau, New Providence Island

0.9 miles from Fort Fincastle

#9 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“Very good hotel. Front desk service was great . Kitchen was too slow for what i ordered. Good location across from beach, fish fry, and not far from straw market (although i didn't get an opportunity to go). the...”

Special offer

Special OfferUnlock Member Rates!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

El Greco Hotel

$120

Expedia.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Pay up to 12X

Orbitz.com

$120

Snaptravel

$97

Trip.com

$112

View all 9 deals from $97

213 reviews

Augusta and West Bay Street | At Augusta St, P.O. Box N-4187, Nassau, New Providence Island

0.8 miles from Fort Fincastle

#10 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“The only pleasing thing about this hotel was its location, its about 15 mins walk either was the the overrated "fish fry" and the cruise ship complex and across the street from the "popular" tiki hut. I brought…”

We compared the lowest prices from 9 websites

Breezes Resort & Spa Bahamas - All-Inclusive

$776

$201

Tripadvisor

View Deal

Free cancellation

Orbitz.com

$201

Agoda.com

$695

Trip.com

$776

View all 12 deals from $201

9,724 reviews

West Bay Street, Nassau, New Providence Island

3.4 miles from Fort Fincastle

#11 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We saw British Colonial Hotel, the ports, Senor Frogs, Straw Market, had lunch and shopped, then went up to Queen's Staircase, water tower, Fort Fincastle, Princess Margaret Hospital, Graycliff hotel, Chocolatier,...”

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Sandyport Beach Resort

$316

Trip.com

View Deal

Tripadvisor

$235

Agoda.com

$235

Orbitz.com

$235

View all 12 deals from $235

1,315 reviews

Sandyport Drive, Nassau, New Providence Island

5.7 miles from Fort Fincastle

#12 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We stayed at Sandyport in the early stages of the Corona Virus epidemic. It is a charming place. The staff were always most helpful & informative. They have visits to a range of places throughout the island. The...”

Special offer

Special Price40% off room rate

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Marley Resort & Spa

$199

Orbitz.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Expedia.com

$199

Snaptravel

$168

Travelocity

$199

View all 11 deals from $168

191 reviews

West Bay St | Cable Beach, Nassau, New Providence Island

5.2 miles from Fort Fincastle

#13 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“Stayed here for 11 days in March and loved the location, beach, work staff and uniqueness! Yes it’s a bit run down, the water pressure needs some help and they could sweep the floors better but the people were so...”

We compared the lowest prices from 11 websites

Orange Hill Beach Inn

$162

Booking.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Tripadvisor

$137

eDreams

$162

Agoda.com

$162

View all 12 deals from $137

451 reviews

West Bay St, Nassau, New Providence Island

7.4 miles from Fort Fincastle

#14 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We stayed here overnight to catch an early morning flight to another island, and while I was a bit apprehensive based on some reviews, I found the place delightful and the staff very pleasant. I would definitely...”

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Sun Fun Resort

$83

Booking.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Agoda.com

$83

eDreams

$83

Tripadvisor

$83

View all 10 deals from $83

48 reviews

West Bay Street, Nassau, New Providence Island

8.3 miles from Fort Fincastle

#15 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“This place is awful the rooms are dirty, the bathroom don’t even get me started on that. They need to learn how to clean properly and do it right because that place is a dump. Do not spend your money here, go to...”

We compared the lowest prices from 10 websites

The Island House

$395

Agoda.com

View Deal

Free cancellation

Orbitz.com

$395

Snaptravel

$332

Booking.com

$395

View all 12 deals from $332

115 reviews

Mahogany Hill, Nassau, New Providence Island

11.3 miles from Fort Fincastle

#16 Best Value of 125 places to stay in Nassau

“We had a relaxing and wonderful time at the Island House. The manager James and the staff were very accommodating and kind with a smile. So nice to have a view of the ocean, restaurants on premises, and relaxing…”

We compared the lowest prices from 12 websites

Coral Harbour Beach House and Villas

$237

Orbitz.com

View Deal

Expedia.com

$237

Snaptravel

$211

Travelocity

$237

Best Hotels Near Fort Fincastle, Nassau, Bahamas

Hotels near Fort Fincastle