THE 10 BEST Historic Hotels in New York City - Aug 2022 (with Prices) - Tripadvisor

We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

27 of 891 properties are available in New York City

Sort by:

Best Value

Heritage
Hotels & Motels

Updating list...

1. The Knickerbocker

$379

$349

Expedia.com

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Booking.com

$350

Knickerbocker

$350

travelup.com

$379

View all 21 deals from $349

#1 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“My daughter and I stayed at the Knickerbocker to celebrate her college graduation enjoying Broadway shows, lots of shopping for a wardrobe to begin her new career and do some sightseeing. The Knickerbocker is a...”
“Enjoyed our stay at the Knick. Pros: location, staff, room size and service. Cons: no view, limited amenities (no in room coffee maker), no lobby to grab quick items (water, snacks, coffee etc) Overall we...”

Special offer

Special OfferUnlock loyalty benefits

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 21 websites

2. The Lucerne Hotel

$209

Booking.com

Free cancellation

Expedia.com

$209

FindHotel

$177

ZenHotels.com

$220

View all 19 deals from $177

#2 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Very clean, professionally run, perfectly located. The Lucerne has it all. The red line subway is one block away and runs to many of the attractions you come to New York for. The area around the hotel has…”
“The hotel was close to many restaurants, Central Park, had a wonderful restaurant Nice Matin attached to it, and had been upgraded with many new amenities. The only drawback is that it was a bit of a distance to…”

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 19 websites

3. The Plaza New York

$806

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$806

Fairmont

$698

ZenHotels.com

$943

View all 20 deals from $698

#3 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Steeped in a rich heritage for more than a century, it brings the old and new together over a party of food, conversation, and amazing service.”
“I had the best tine celebrating my birthday. The staff amd the workers were all very professional amd kind in their job and speaking to you. They are all always ready to help you in any way shape or form. The...”

Special offer

Special RateIt's ALL Possible - Save Up to 25%

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 20 websites

4. Refinery Hotel

$254

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$215

Trip.com

$181

ZenHotels.com

$287

View all 20 deals from $181

#4 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“We have just got back from the Refinery, I can highly recommend it. The staff were all so helpful especially at the front desk. The room was big and airy and very clean.The bars and restaurants were all good...”
“I can’t say enough about how much I enjoyed my stay at the refinery! Gabriel and the entire staff provided such a positive experience. Professional, positive and so kind! Highly recommend staying there not only…”

Special offer

Special OfferPicnic Tale

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 20 websites

5. The Bryant Park Hotel

$245

Booking.com

Free cancellation

Expedia.com

$245

FindHotel

$195

Hotels.com

$245

View all 18 deals from $194

#5 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Perfect location adjacent to Bryant Park and walking distance from pretty much everything midtown- Empire State Building , Rockefeller Center, theaters, time square, etc. The hotel was modern and clean- free...”
“Veronica and Ray went above and beyond during my family’s stay at the hotel. We had three different rooms for the family and everyone was so impressed. The entire stay was pleasant, rooms were clean, service was...”

Special offer

Special OfferBook Direct, and We'll Waive the Facility Fee!! Save $30 Per Night!!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 18 websites

6. Lotte New York Palace

$600

Expedia.com

Free cancellation

Pay up to 12X

Booking.com

$600

Agoda.com

$513

travelup.com

$666

View all 16 deals from $513

#6 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“While I made my own reservation for Lotte New York Palace online, Marie of the Reservations Department had emailed me a few days prior to my arrival to learn more about my brief trip with my daughter to see some...”
“From the beginning of our stay, the staff was extremely friendly and helpful. My wife and I were travelling with our 6yo. Without asking, Michael upgraded us to a corner room with a great view of St Patricks and…”

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 16 websites

7. The New Yorker, A Wyndham Hotel

$169

Booking.com

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

New Yorker Hotel

$169

FindHotel

$129

Trip.com

$184

View all 20 deals from $129

#7 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Nice Hotel, rooms are very outdated need some painting and fixing here and there… Perfect location, beautiful lobby, staff is friendly, super nice and helpful! Food is good too , our family room didn’t have coffee...”
“Firstly the hotel was very clean and well kept including the rooms. The front desk staff were very helpful in giving us tips for getting around the city and also getting us a transfer back to the airport. The...”

Special offer

Special OfferStay Twice & Earn a Free Night

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 20 websites

8. The Beekman A Thompson Hotel

$350

Expedia.com

Free cancellation

Reserve now, pay at stay

Booking.com

$350

Hotels.com

$350

Priceline

$350

View all 20 deals from $350

#8 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Great stay! Loved it. Very comfortable and vibe for days. The convenient bar and restaurants had wonderful food. Location was good for getting anywhere in mid-lower Manhattan. There’s is construction going on next...”
“The Beekman hotel and staff experience was one of the best experiences we have had. This is our third time staying there and this go round was the best by far. They understand that they are in the hospitality...”

Special offer

Special OfferNeed a Little Bit More Time to Relax

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 20 websites

9. Hotel Belleclaire

$174

Booking.com

Free cancellation

Expedia.com

$174

Traveluro

$142

travelup.com

$229

View all 17 deals from $142

#9 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Spent a fabulous week in Manhattan at the Hotel Belleclaire. The hotel is located in the Upper west side, walking distance from some fantastic restaurants. I called the hotel the night before we got there and…”
“We usually stay at 8th and 51st in a name brand hotel but had to commute by cab to my daughters apt on W 72nd. Found this hotel on TripAdvisor. Great location for our purposes since it was a short walk to 72nd...”

Special offer

Special RateExclusive direct offer includes a discount and free breakfast!

Visit hotel website

We compared the lowest prices from 17 websites

10. Washington Square Hotel

$278

Booking.com

Expedia.com

$258

Trip.com

$238

Priceline

$288

View all 18 deals from $238

#10 Best Value of 27 New York City Heritage Hotels

“Very helpful staff and did a great job of keeping our room clean. Cannot beat the location in the West Village, wonderful area for walking around and excellent restaurants all within walking distance. Love…”
“Good location- q