Reset
FiltersProperty types
Deals
Price
$0 - $311 +
Popular
Amenities
Show more
Distance from
25 mi
Traveler rating
Style
- Hotels & Motels
- Cheap
Pro tip: Enter your dates to see qualifying Tripadvisor Plus savings and perks
4 of 20 properties are available and match your filters. Clear all filters
4 of 20 properties are available in Fire Island
Sort by:
Best Value
- Hotels & Motels
- Cheap
Updating list...
#2 Best Value of 4 Fire Island Cheap Beach Hotels
“The upholstered headboard was torn and filthy. There were long black hairs on the sheets. The “balcony” is a tiny Juliet one; barely large enough to stand on. No phone.
Although the front desk people were...”
“Stayed at the Grove Hotel for an overnight with a friend who had never visited Fire Island and we both had an awesome time . Our second floor room had amazing views of tranquil Cherry Grove from ocean to bay...”
“Stayed at the Grove Hotel for an overnight with a friend who had never visited Fire Island and we both had an awesome time . Our second floor room had amazing views of tranquil Cherry Grove from ocean to bay...”
#3 Best Value of 4 Fire Island Cheap Beach Hotels
#4 Best Value of 4 Fire Island Cheap Beach Hotels
“No directions to the hotel are ever provided - nothing on the website and nothing in the confirmation email. This is an issue because when you look up directions on Google Maps, it indicates that you can drive to...”
“The rate was better than other Fire Island options I explored (at least midweek). So I figured a couple days at the beach would be worth "noisy" in the reviews. I've stayed in Ocean Beach before and it was fine…”
“The rate was better than other Fire Island options I explored (at least midweek). So I figured a couple days at the beach would be worth "noisy" in the reviews. I've stayed in Ocean Beach before and it was fine…”
There are no more properties that match all of your filters. Clear all filters or view Tripadvisor's suggestions. They may be in Fire Island or nearby.
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$222
$199
Booking.comView all 21 deals from $199
11.7 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
“Staff was very friendly and helpful. The room was clean and spacious The location was convenient. The selection of meals were a wide range from beef, chicken fish and all of it was very well prepared. In...”
“The hotel was beautiful and clean. Satff was helpful and courteous. The pool area was also clean and the room temperature was very pleasant. I was a bit disappointed that the room didn't have a safe nor a…”
“The hotel was beautiful and clean. Satff was helpful and courteous. The pool area was also clean and the room temperature was very pleasant. I was a bit disappointed that the room didn't have a safe nor a…”
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$132
Booking.comView all 19 deals from $119
9.5 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bohemia
“I will never stay in another Wyndham property! I would rather sleep in my car!! Rude staff dirty rooms and too many problems. Nothing resolved, even when calling corporate. Absolutely horrible experience.”
“Smelly room. Refrigerator and fridge broken. Needed replacement which was done next day. Two towels in a room booked for three people. Incorrect info given when I made the reservation. Was told there is airport...”
“Smelly room. Refrigerator and fridge broken. Needed replacement which was done next day. Two towels in a room booked for three people. Incorrect info given when I made the reservation. Was told there is airport...”
Missing:CheapBeachfront
$1,715
Hotels.comView all 10 deals from $1,715
#1 of 8 hotels in Fire Island
“The Palms Hotel offers many amenities for free (bikes, beach chairs, wagon, daily breakfast) to help make your vacation as convenient and care free as possible. The Palms Bay which you are free to visit even if u...”
“So happy to be back at Fire Island and the Palms Hotel. Great time of year to visit before the crowds! Even though it was opening weekend and busy the customer service was excellent! Can’t wait to go back!”
“So happy to be back at Fire Island and the Palms Hotel. Great time of year to visit before the crowds! Even though it was opening weekend and busy the customer service was excellent! Can’t wait to go back!”
Missing:Beachfront
$311
Booking.comView all 11 deals from $311
#8 of 8 hotels in Fire Island
“Terrible furniture, loud even off season, and terrible uncomfortable beds. The bathrooms are communal but clean. The owners are nice but they need to spruce this place up. The location is great. It’s literally…”
“Let me start by agreeing with most people under these reviews that this hotel is overpriced for what you’re getting. This hotel is not only very old and run down, the filthy carpets, uncomfortable beds, and smell…”
“Let me start by agreeing with most people under these reviews that this hotel is overpriced for what you’re getting. This hotel is not only very old and run down, the filthy carpets, uncomfortable beds, and smell…”
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$161
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $161
11.3 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Islandia
“Our check in process was smooth, or so I thought. She knew we were only staying two nights, but didn't say they would not clean our room during our stay. We used towels and left them in a pile as we normally do…”
“Stayed overnight May 10. We’ve visited Jake’s Casino Hotel many times in the past. We were very unpleasantly surprised during this hotel stay, the first since the COVID restrictions were implemented. Our room had…”
“Stayed overnight May 10. We’ve visited Jake’s Casino Hotel many times in the past. We were very unpleasantly surprised during this hotel stay, the first since the COVID restrictions were implemented. Our room had…”
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$186
$175
Booking.comView all 18 deals from $175
11.3 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Islandia
“The Hampton has always been one of my favorite places to stay!! The hotel is nice and very cleaned check in was a breeze, the person who check me in was very nice!! The only room complaint is the microwave plate...”
“Our stay was shortly after the lift of Covid-19 restrictions. This is a very challenging time for all and you did the best you could under these circumstances. You do need to invest in new sheets. They were worn...”
“Our stay was shortly after the lift of Covid-19 restrictions. This is a very challenging time for all and you did the best you could under these circumstances. You do need to invest in new sheets. They were worn...”
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$188
$169
Booking.comView all 18 deals from $169
9.8 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“This hotel got it right!
Clean up to date rooms, wonderful restaurant and an outgoing and friendly staff add up to a hotel I will return to again. Great for business or family travel good time
The bed was...”
“Staff was friendly, rooms were clean and beds were comfy. They were very accommodating as the after-wedding party was brought to their lobby/bar area. We even brought in large amounts of food for our guests and…”
“Staff was friendly, rooms were clean and beds were comfy. They were very accommodating as the after-wedding party was brought to their lobby/bar area. We even brought in large amounts of food for our guests and…”
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$197
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $197
8.6 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
“I had the pleasure of staying here for 5 nights and it was an extremely relaxing experience. Every staff member I encountered was friendly and helpful. Special thanks to General Manager Brian and Alana at the...”
“Jeremy at the front desk is awesome !!!! He went above and beyond to accommodate me and my family. Extremely polite, funny and respectful. Truly an asset to the Marriot Team, Will definitely recommend this hotel ”
“Jeremy at the front desk is awesome !!!! He went above and beyond to accommodate me and my family. Extremely polite, funny and respectful. Truly an asset to the Marriot Team, Will definitely recommend this hotel ”
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$169
Booking.comView all 17 deals from $149
11.8 miles from Fire Island
#3 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
“Staff at this hotel are fantastic. From our reservation through every interaction. Pleasant, anticipatory, thoughtful and professional. It’s a well run hotel fueled by the excellent customer service. Definitely…”
“From the minute I made my reservations online the hotel contacted me concerning my request for a very early check in. Requested for 11AM check in, was contacted immediately they can have my room ready by noon...”
“From the minute I made my reservations online the hotel contacted me concerning my request for a very early check in. Requested for 11AM check in, was contacted immediately they can have my room ready by noon...”
Taking safety measuresMissing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$155
$134
Hampton.comView all 18 deals from $134
13.9 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 1 hotel in Farmingville
“ Additional parking fee ($10) for stays over the weekends. Bath tube needed scrubbing. Vent in bathroom was ridiculously loud. Wished the pool had open earlier in the morning, Not only from 1pm-9pm...”
“It was nice and clean. I wished the windows were operable as oppose to being fixed. It was stuffy in the rooms and kind of hard to sleep. I did not like the fact that the bathroom had a sensor. Every time I...”
“It was nice and clean. I wished the windows were operable as oppose to being fixed. It was stuffy in the rooms and kind of hard to sleep. I did not like the fact that the bathroom had a sensor. Every time I...”
Special offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$118
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $113
13.7 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Holtsville
“I don’t know about everyone else but booking a hotel and paying for it for another person is a pain in the ass!!! I booked my dad a room, changed the dates and called multiple time with concerns and that’s just...”
“While our visit was short- we checked in at 8 and left by 7, the front desk staff we meet were helpful, the room was clean, and there was no problem with parking. Front desk staff were helpful with helping us...”
“While our visit was short- we checked in at 8 and left by 7, the front desk staff we meet were helpful, the room was clean, and there was no problem with parking. Front desk staff were helpful with helping us...”
Taking safety measuresMissing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$149
Booking.comView all 18 deals from $118
12.6 miles from Fire Island
#4 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
“Our stay in April was quite decent. The bar and restaurant was closed due to pandemic. The rooms were spacious and very clean. I was in and out for medical reasons and Mark who works front desk was extremely…”
“Mark is splendid!!! & bountiful helpful. Went to the upmost to make sure we were well. Courteous and highly polite. Room was decent, and had a great smell on the floor we were stationed on. Plan to visit...”
“Mark is splendid!!! & bountiful helpful. Went to the upmost to make sure we were well. Courteous and highly polite. Room was decent, and had a great smell on the floor we were stationed on. Plan to visit...”
Special offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$229
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $215
11.6 miles from Fire Island
#3 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“This Homewood is centrally located and has a lot to offer. I was thrilled to see that they served breakfast, and the gym was open. The rooms were clean and the staff was very friendly. I will definitely be back…”
“Didn’t meet expectations so not worth the money paid for that room. Missing towels in the room and shampoo. Blanket was old and breakfast was pathetic. So I definitely will not recommend this hotel at those prices.”
“Didn’t meet expectations so not worth the money paid for that room. Missing towels in the room and shampoo. Blanket was old and breakfast was pathetic. So I definitely will not recommend this hotel at those prices.”
Special offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$174
$169
Booking.comView all 17 deals from $169
13.4 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 1 hotel in Commack
“I had a great night at the Hampton Inn Long Island Commack back in early May 2021. The hotel did a good job with their cleaning, COVID protocols, and social distancing. The room was clean and comfortable. Good...”
“Trip was good and I felt hotel was cleaned thoroughly. I would not hesitate to stay there again or recommend this hotel to others who are starting to travel on business and pleasure again in the near future. ”
“Trip was good and I felt hotel was cleaned thoroughly. I would not hesitate to stay there again or recommend this hotel to others who are starting to travel on business and pleasure again in the near future. ”
Special offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$279
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $279
8.5 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
“This property has a wonderful staff. We began our stay when my mom became very ill. During the stay we extended twice, which during the stay my mom passed away. The staff provided me a condolences card. Nick, at...”
“I arrived a few minutes before actually check in and was greeted by a very friendly and courteous concierge. She was very helpful in printing out information for my next day Fire Island trip. While waiting for…”
“I arrived a few minutes before actually check in and was greeted by a very friendly and courteous concierge. She was very helpful in printing out information for my next day Fire Island trip. While waiting for…”
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$165
$139
Booking.comView all 19 deals from $139
9.7 miles from Fire Island
#5 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“The front desk staff was nice and accommodating. The owners however, were the rudest I have met.
Every time the owner was behind the counter, she was yelling at someone. She was condescending, poorly organized...”
“-The Front Desk Staff was rude and check in took forever -The Hotel smells and is badly in need of repairs -The room was full of disgusting, dirty and broken items. -The security chain on the door is coming…”
“-The Front Desk Staff was rude and check in took forever -The Hotel smells and is badly in need of repairs -The room was full of disgusting, dirty and broken items. -The security chain on the door is coming…”
Missing:In Fire IslandCheapBeachfront
$179
$170
Booking.comView all 19 deals from $170
12.7 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Holtsville