We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Reset
Filters
Deals
Price
$0 - $194 +
Price per night
Popular
Amenities
Show all
Traveler rating
Hotel class
Style
Tripadvisor Plus
Pro tip: Enter your dates to see qualifying Tripadvisor Plus savings and perks
9 of 14 properties are available in Shelter Island
Sort by:
Best Value
    Updating list...
    No other properties are available in Shelter Island. View nearby results below.
    Prices are the average nightly price provided by our partners and may not include all taxes and fees. Taxes and fees that are shown are estimates only. Please see our partners for more details.
    Frequently Asked Questions about Shelter Island hotels
    • What are the best hotels near Mashomack Preserve?
      Harborfront Inn at Greenport, Baron's Cove, and Silver Sands Motel & Beach Cottages are some of the most popular hotels for travelers looking to stay near Mashomack Preserve. See the full list: Hotels near Mashomack Preserve.
    • What are the best hotels near Sylvester Manor Educational Farm?
      Popular hotels close to Sylvester Manor Educational Farm include Shelter Island House, Dering Harbor Inn, and The Pridwin Hotel. See the full list: Hotels near Sylvester Manor Educational Farm.
    • Which hotels are closest to New Haven Airport?
      Popular hotels close to New Haven Airport include The Study at Yale, The Blake Hotel, and New Haven Hotel. See the full list: Hotels near (HVN) New Haven Airport.
    • What are the best hotels near Shelter Island Historical Society?
      A few of the most popular hotels near Shelter Island Historical Society are Shelter Island House, Dering Harbor Inn, and Sunset Beach. See the full list: Hotels near Shelter Island Historical Society.
    • What are the best pet-friendly hotels in Shelter Island?
      Some of the most popular pet-friendly hotels in Shelter Island are Shelter Island House, Ram's Head Inn, and Sunset Beach. See the full list: Pet Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island.
    • What are the best cheap hotels in Shelter Island?
      Popular cheap hotels in Shelter Island include Shelter Island House, Dering Harbor Inn, and The Pridwin Hotel. See the full list: Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island.
    • What are the best hotels on the beach in Shelter Island?
      Popular hotels by the beach in Shelter Island include The Pridwin Hotel, Ram's Head Inn, and Sunset Beach. See the full list: Shelter Island Beach Hotels.
    • What are the best romantic hotels in Shelter Island?
      Shelter Island House, Dering Harbor Inn, and The Pridwin Hotel received great reviews from travelers looking for a romantic hotel in Shelter Island. See the full list: Romantic Hotels in Shelter Island.
    • What are the best hotels with a pool in Shelter Island?
      Some of the most popular hotels with a pool in Shelter Island include Shelter Island House, Dering Harbor Inn, and The Pridwin Hotel. See the full list: Shelter Island Hotels with a Pool.