United States
New York (NY)
Long Island
North Fork
New Suffolk
New Suffolk Hotels

THE BEST Hotels in New Suffolk 2023

New Suffolk Hotels

and Places to Stay
Enter dates to find the best prices

Popular

Property types

Distance from

25 mi

Traveler rating

1 property in New Suffolk
Sort by:
  • Best Value
    Properties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveler ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
  • Traveler Ranked
    Highest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveler reviews.
  • Distance to city center
    See properties located closest to the center first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners
1. White Cap
Enter dates to see prices
No other properties are available in New Suffolk. View nearby results below.
  • Sunny days at Sunny Side Up
Breakfast included
Sunny Side Up Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
JanineB
JanineB
@Neanie24
Reviewed on Aug 18, 2021
Charming country B&B
"Had a wonderful stay at the charming Sunnyside Up B&B. The owners were gracious and made our stay a welcome one. Breakfasts were phenomenal, we especially loved the homemade polenta, pancake with fresh blueberry..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Cutchogue
JanineB
By JanineB
"The owners were gracious and made our stay a welcome one. Breakfasts were phenomenal, we especially loved the homemade polenta, pancake with fresh blueberry compote, and farm fresh eggs cooked to our liking."
  • ~ Garden ~
Breakfast included
Sweet Dreams Bed & Breakfast Cutchogue
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
BCRDH
BCRDH
@BCRDH
Reviewed on Jul 17, 2019
Quick and relaxing get away
"Where to begin? This was my first time at a bed-and-breakfast and everything about it was perfect, and beyond my expectations. Our host Patricia was so lovely and made us feel at home immediately. The house was so..."
Read all reviews
#6 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Cutchogue
BCRDH
By BCRDH
"Where to begin? This was my first time at a bed-and-breakfast and everything about it was perfect, and beyond my expectations. Our host Patricia was so lovely and made us feel at home immediately. The house was so..."
Breakfast included
The Farmhouse Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Shanneebear
Shanneebear
@Shanneebear
Reviewed on Dec 7, 2021
Another wonderful stay!
"Our room was clean, cozy and comfortable."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Cutchogue
LCTV
By LCTV
"Anne and Bruce are wonderful hosts, even before we got there, with recommendations for places to visit and eat. The house is beautiful and the room was perfect with a super-comfortable bed, a fireplace!"
Blue Heron's Nest Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
  • Blue Iris Bed & Breakfast
Breakfast included
Blue Iris Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Nicholas H
Nicholas H
@P3832ALnicholash
Reviewed on Sep 9, 2023
Wonderful time at the Blue Iris
"Lorry and Jerry were wonderful hosts and cooked a delicious breakfast. We enjoyed their company in the mornings. Our room was comfortable, clean, and well-appointed and the property gardens were stunning. We had a..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Cutchogue
Nicole M
By Nicole M
"We stayed in the hydrangea room which was spotless! We were also welcomed by a bottle of wine personally addressed to us with yummy chocolates to go along, which is easily the way to my heart!"
  • Welcome
Fig and Olive Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
gldchmr
gldchmr
@gldchmr
Reviewed on Oct 21, 2018
Great Getaway!!
"This was the perfect place to get away to. The owners have done everything to make this a comfortable and relaxing stay. Our room was beautifully decorated and well appointed. Would love to get back here again..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Cutchogue
gldchmr
By gldchmr
"This was the perfect place to get away to. The owners have done everything to make this a comfortable and relaxing stay. Our room was beautifully decorated and well appointed. Would love to get back here again..."
Breakfast included
Sannino Vineyard B and B
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Joe T
Joe T
@U2376VSjoet
Reviewed on Jan 11, 2022
Amazing Place for a Romantic Getaway
"Beautiful room, great views, wonderful breakfast and exceedingly refreshing."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Cutchogue
lynaugh638
By lynaugh638
"The outside deck is adorable, stone work makes it. Then, you walk through the vines and go to the brand-new winery. It has beautiful outside areas to sit. The cheese platter was delicious that came with the room."
Breakfast included
The Harvest Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Ruth J
Ruth J
@LoveSpringLake
Reviewed on Sep 24, 2023
A relaxing getaway
"The Harvest Inn is the perfect place to unwind and enjoy the North Fork of Long Island. We felt right at home in this lovely B&B. Stacey and Steve, the innkeepers are friendly and knowledgeable about the sights to..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Peconic
David S
By David S
"The owners are so nice and welcoming and provide super breakfast. Beautiful rooms great beds and they provide great bedding and pillows. Highly recommend the Harverst Inn and its location is perfect..."
Breakfast included
Rose Hill Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Guest house
BostonJulia
BostonJulia
@BostonJulia
Reviewed on Sep 10, 2022
Nice Inn, but needs some improving...
"Lovely setting, vineyard and guesthouse. That being said, the inn is expensive and for the $$$ they are charging they are lacking in customer service. They are really more about the vineyard and that is where you..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Mattituck
Imajean
By Imajean
"Perfect location, close to many wineries, and the Shinn Estate hospitality was superb. Wine tasting included and the outdoor covered patio overlooking the vineyard was a perfect spot."
Mattituck Motel
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
John B
John B
@John B
Reviewed on Nov 15, 2016
Great pit stop on our way to a wedding
"Simple, clean and friendly. it was like entering a time warp to the 70's. In a nice way. It was a 10 minute walk to the Mattituck public beach. We were on our way to a wedding on Shelter island and this was a great..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Mattituck
Jonathan Z
By Jonathan Z
"Provided beach chairs, beach passes and umbrella along with whatever was needed to enjoy the stay. Close to restaurants (great recommendations from owners) and to the Peconic Bay beaches."
Breakfast included
South Harbor Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Limited Service Property
Rosalia
Rosalia
@rosaliapena
Reviewed on Sep 3, 2020
A Great Place!
"My husband and I went to the South Harbor Inn to celebrate our anniversary and we had a great time. It is a cozy, beautiful remodeled home with so much charm. It’s located close to everything; all the wineries..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Southold
Barry E
By Barry E
"Alex and Dan make you feel at home from the moment you arrive. Both the room and the common areas were comfortable, luxurious, and beautifully decorated. Breakfasts were great with fresh baked treats every morning."
Breakfast included
Ellis House Bed & Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
lkatzmark
lkatzmark
@lkatzmark
Reviewed on Sep 8, 2018
All the comforts of home
"My husband and I stayed in a lovely room with a beautiful and immaculately clean bathroom with thick fluffy towels. There is none of the ackward feeling that some B & B's have when you are in just a bedroom in..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Southold
lkatzmark
By lkatzmark
"My husband and I stayed in a lovely room with a beautiful and immaculately clean bathroom with thick fluffy towels. There is none of the ackward feeling that some B & B's have when you are in just a bedroom in..."
Goose Creek Guest House
Enter dates to see prices
Guest house
Willow Hill House Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
kim k
kim k
@kim k
Reviewed on Jul 9, 2013
great find
"My husband and I, along with another couple had a great time here. Gayle and her husband makes you feel like family. They are full of wonderful stories. Unlike all the other B&B's in this area, they do not have a..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Southold
kim k
By kim k
"My husband and I, along with another couple had a great time here. Gayle and her husband makes you feel like family. They are full of wonderful stories. Unlike all the other B&B's in this area, they do not have a..."
Breakfast included
Bayview Farm Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Ranch
Barry_in_WPB
Barry_in_WPB
@BBragger
Reviewed on Sep 11, 2015
Charming, quiet, couldn't be more wonderful
"I don't know that I could possibly be more effusive in my praise of Vicki and Bill's splendid hospitality. They are warm, inviting, caring - the perfect hosts. Their home/B&B is spacious, immaculately maintained..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Southold
Barry_in_WPB
By Barry_in_WPB
"I don't know that I could possibly be more effusive in my praise of Vicki and Bill's splendid hospitality. They are warm, inviting, caring - the perfect hosts. Their home/B&B is spacious, immaculately maintained..."
Historic White Blossom House
Enter dates to see prices
Condominium
Mymilesandsmiles
Mymilesandsmiles
@mymilesandsmiles
Reviewed on Jul 1, 2019
Good Location
"Historic home ( circa 1830) in the heart of the north fork wine and beach venues. Offering BEACH PARKING PASS good at all Southold Town Beaches, bathroom has free toiletries, free bike for guest use and free WiFi..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Southold
Mymilesandsmiles
By Mymilesandsmiles
"Historic home ( circa 1830) in the heart of the north fork wine and beach venues. Offering BEACH PARKING PASS good at all Southold Town Beaches, bathroom has free toiletries, free bike for guest use and free WiFi..."
This is one of the highest rated properties in Mattituck
Breakfast included
Cedar House on Sound B&B
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Mary Ann B
Mary Ann B
@Mary Ann B
Reviewed on May 23, 2021
Cedar House on Sound
"Absolutely wonderful all around!! Hosts, food, accommodations, lounge, outdoor fire pit, and Great room with large TV and great pool table!"
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Mattituck
Joanie C
By Joanie C
"Cedar House is a friendly and welcoming place. The rooms are extremely clean and quite pretty. There is a large space to play pool or hang out and a bar area with a large table to socialize."
The Tern Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Tulip Tree Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Jo F
Jo F
@jof918
Reviewed on Aug 19, 2023
A gem in Southhold
"We had a wedding in Southhold and wanted to stay in a B&B. So happy to have found this gem. Beautiful, quaint home off the beaten path. So charming, so comfortable. Flo was a wonderful host who built this..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Southold
cupcake6627
By cupcake6627
"The White Room was on the second floor and walking the grand staircase was like transporting you back to an earlier time. We were impressed that the steps and banisters were always clean and polished on every trip."
Romantic Hamptons
Enter dates to see prices
Limited Service Property
Breakfast included
Wickham-Prince Bed & Breakfast
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Amanda
Amanda
@amandasH7616YV
Reviewed on Sep 1, 2020
Fantastic Stay
"This was our second time staying at Wickham Prince and we had the most wonderful time again. Sue and Doug are amazing hosts and take care of their guests. The breakfast is so beyond delicious and our stay was just..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 9 places to stay in Southold
Amanda
By Amanda
"Sue and Doug are amazing hosts and take care of their guests. The breakfast is so beyond delicious and our stay was just wonderful. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a weekend getaway!"
Bed and Breakfast the Hedges
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
Breakfast included
The North Fork Table & Inn
Enter dates to see prices
John L
John L
@johnlH8739NU
Reviewed on Sep 19, 2023
All Class
"All class. Good service and clean facility. Go here for special occasion as it is pricey, but they can back it up. Food was good with many options. Main dining room was quite with no kitchen clatter or loud table..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Southold
isamettina
By isamettina
"We’ll certainly be coming back on a more regular basis. Don’t miss a chance to enjoy a wonderful meal, great cocktails and five star service. Definitely North Fork’s star eatery!"
Breakfast included
Jedediah Hawkins Inn & Restaurant
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
ajmineola
ajmineola
@ajmineola
Reviewed on Apr 17, 2023
Historical Inn w/ Gourmet Cuisine
"Found this interesting historical Inn just off a side road in Jamesport. The place was intriguing with its past and present stories. The atmosphere was comfortable and inviting -as were the staff - especially..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Jamesport
On Edge R
By On Edge R
"The room was beautifully done and warm and inviting. The back lawn area has a fire pit and plenty of Adirondack chairs to sit, relax with a bottle of wine. The staff are also what makes this place so terrific."
This is one of the most booked hotels in Southold over the last 60 days.
The Shoals
Enter dates to see prices
Andrew Z
Andrew Z
@andrewz2023
Reviewed on Jan 2, 2023
Must Visit
"The room was large, beautifully decorated and pristine."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Southold
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Jamesport Bay Suites
Enter dates to see prices
Motel
RebeccaDash
RebeccaDash
@RebeccaDash
Reviewed on Dec 16, 2021
Lovely!
"Beautifully located right on our favorite beach in a sweet, old-fashioned village that we love. Susan, the manager, was wonderful and generous in helping us have a great time. Watching the sunset from the shared..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in South Jamesport
RebeccaDash
By RebeccaDash
"Beautifully located right on our favorite beach in a sweet, old-fashioned village that we love. Susan, the manager, was wonderful and generous in helping us have a great time."
Bay Breeze Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Rachel H
Rachel H
@L5713GRrachelh
Reviewed on Oct 15, 2021
Couples getaway
"... was a separate hike apprised of 2 units - our huge suite was equipped with a full kitchen/ Dining room/ free standing tub / shower, separate bedroom This unit is definitely equipped for more than 2 people With..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in South Jamesport
WendySolon_OH
By WendySolon_OH
"The room was very comfortable with very nice bedding, pillow, a small frig and excellent WiFi. They supply beach towels and chairs which is very nice. The rooms were well furnished and quiet."
This is one of the most booked hotels in Jamesport over the last 60 days.
Shorewood Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
Tova L
Tova L
@Tkut1836
Reviewed on Jul 29, 2021
Okay for a one night stay
"I stayed here with my husband for one night after spending a day in the Hamptons. The inn is extremely basic. It is basically a room with a bed, tiny bathroom and closet. The room does include an electric kettle..."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Jamesport
Divasongs
By Divasongs
"We had a nice breakfast at the Cutchogue Diner. The area is lovely and we'd love to come and spend more time but I would definitely research airbnbs because the hotel situation seems like a bit of a rip-off."
Not sure when to visit?
Price trends, weather and things to do can help you make a decision.
Season
Avg. price/night
Avg. temperature
Avg. precipitation
Dec - Feb
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
34ºF
COLDEST
6ºF94ºF
Avg. precipitation
42in
WETTEST
28 in51 in
Mar - May
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
48ºF
6ºF94ºF
Avg. precipitation
37in
28 in51 in
Jun - Aug
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
72ºF
WARMEST
6ºF94ºF
Avg. precipitation
33in
DRIEST
28 in51 in
Sep - Nov
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
56ºF
6ºF94ºF
Avg. precipitation
39in
28 in51 in
Price trend information excludes taxes and fees and is based on base rates for a nightly stay for 2 adults found in the last 7 days on our site and averaged for commonly viewed hotels in New Suffolk. Select dates and complete search for nightly totals inclusive of taxes and fees.
Frequently Asked Questions about New Suffolk hotels
Popular hotels close to New Haven Airport include The Blake Hotel, The Study at Yale, and Graduate New Haven. See the full list: Hotels near New Haven Airport.
The above hotel descriptions were created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for any of the above hotel descriptions. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in one of these AI-generated descriptions is inaccurate, please share your feedback.