THE 10 BEST Hotels in Garden City 2023

"Enjoyed a great meal at Red Salt. The bar and lounge is a comfortable spot to have a lunch and drinks. Rooms were spotless and bed was very comfortable. We would stay again and recommend this hotel highly."

#1 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Garden City

By Tom C

2. Hyatt Place Garden City

Enter dates to see prices

Go-OSUBucks

@Go-OSUBucks

Reviewed on Sep 25, 2022

Great Location

"While hotel is older and could use a bit of a refresh the staff was friendly, room clean, free breakfast, good water pressure and beds comfy."

"The king bed was comfortable and we got two good nights of sleep. The HVAC and Wi-Fi Internet worked well in the room. We particularly enjoyed the breakfast area and the excellent complimentary breakfast."

#2 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Garden City

By JJLJOregon

This is one of the most booked hotels in Garden City over the last 60 days.

3. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Garden City

Enter dates to see prices

pringgold7

@pringgold7

Reviewed on Oct 27, 2020

Our Anniversary at LaQuinta

"The room was spacious, clean, quaint, and quiet."

"The whole room was clean and comfortable. The air conditioner worked well . They had free parking and free WiFi. They also had very nice free breakfast. I really loved their scrambled eggs and orange juice ."

#3 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Garden City

By RoChau

4. Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island

Enter dates to see prices

Mike Sandven

@msandven

Reviewed on Apr 21, 2021

nice comfortable Hotel. Even nicer staff

"Comfortable large room, King size bed, great water pressure in the shower even though I was on the top floor."

"It’s clean, comfortable with an efficient and friendly staff. There’s shopping, restaurants and a new Whole Foods right beside. Rahul, at the front desk, will greet you with a warm welcome!"

#4 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Garden City

By Virginia A

5. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Garden City

Enter dates to see prices

Luvsviolet

@Emmy C

Reviewed on Mar 8, 2022

My first Residence Inn

"The hotel room was comfortable, with a full kitchen, big bathroom with a walk in shower and hot breakfast every day."

"Clean and modern hotel, near Roosevelt Field mall, restaurants, kids museum, drive to beach, etc. Hotel is relatively new, clean and well maintained. Nice decor in reception and breakfast areas."

#5 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Garden City

By Lala P

No other properties are available in Garden City. View nearby results below.

Anastasia's Bed & Breakfast

Enter dates to see prices

Guest house

1 review

#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Hempstead

SpringHill Suites by Marriott Carle Place Garden City

Enter dates to see prices

JB J

@816jbj

Reviewed on Apr 18, 2023

A Gem!

"The room was large, comfortable, and well appointed."

"Upon arriving, we were happy to come across a beautiful building with flawless grounds and a welcoming atmosphere. Upon walking into the lobby, we were blown away by the contemporary, warm, and elegant decor."

#3 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Carle Place

By Thomas Peter Carlon

This is one of the highest rated properties in Carle Place

Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place - Garden City, NY

Enter dates to see prices

Nicole S

@nicoleU1015JV

Reviewed on Aug 30, 2021

Very comfortable hotel in great location

"The room was very clean and comfortable."

"Awesome location with great service, Sheryl is this best! The rooms are spacious and well equipped. Good hot breakfast topped off with the relaxing pool. Perfect for your family vacation i will recommend any day."

#1 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Carle Place

By Journey67034617156

This is one of the most booked hotels in Westbury over the last 60 days.

Red Roof PLUS+ Long Island - Garden City

Enter dates to see prices

Fred J

@852fredj

Reviewed on Sep 16, 2020

Great Stay

"The room was spacious, clean and comfortable.My wife always requires coffee first thing in the morning: The coffee was good and the coffemaker was simple to use."

"Red Roof in Garden City has it all! Not only is in a good location but the room where we stayed was in very good conditions. Everything was working good and they provided us with everything we needed for the day."

#2 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Westbury

By Julian G

The Vanderbilt Hotel Suites

Enter dates to see prices

Condominium

Gina R

@ginarL182QQ

Reviewed on Jan 1, 2023

Great experience!!

"The hotel was clean, room was spacious and quiet."

"The location is proximate to shopping and fine dining. There is also a new restaurant in the Hotel which offer poolside dining. Rooms were very luxurious, well-kept and more comfortable than most hotels."

#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Westbury

By Maury H

This is one of the most booked hotels in Carle Place over the last 60 days.

Holiday Inn Westbury-Long Island, an IHG Hotel

Enter dates to see prices

Jiann L

@jiannl2023

Reviewed on Jan 2, 2023

Great experience!

"Clean room, great ambiance, delicious breakfast and amazing warm staff!"

"This hotel went above and beyond with everything! From the breakfast, to the room , to the front desk , everything was 10/10 . I would definitely recommend this hotel to anyone ."

#2 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Carle Place

By Kathie J

"the room was clean and all amenities were available."

Holiday Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Ali C

@Z1275ZGalic

Reviewed on Jul 25, 2022

Accommodating

"They availed me a room with a king size and the option to move to a double bed the next day. When getting ready to o to the king size room. We were able to get our double queen size room."

#4 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Carle Place

By Ali C

This is one of the most booked hotels in Uniondale over the last 60 days.

Long Island Marriott

Enter dates to see prices

Ian s

@Biffothebeard

Reviewed on Oct 26, 2022

Good stop over

"Beautiful large room was very clean."

"I stayed at the Long Island Marriott over the Valentine's Day weekend. I loved how clean and comfortable my room was. When I checked in, the front desk staff was very helpful, courteous and professional."

#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Uniondale

By ShawnS007

Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island

Enter dates to see prices

eastporter

@eastporter

Reviewed on Aug 31, 2021

Good choice for Nassau County, Long Island

"Efficient and friendly staff, very clean room and nice surroundings."

"We stayed at this hotel for almost 2 weeks in a Junior Suite. The room provided ample work space and free higher speed internet to Gold or higher Bonvoy members. Any extra amenities we needed were provided quickly."

#3 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Westbury

By NewYorkJM

Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

Enter dates to see prices

Norm444

@Norm444

Reviewed on Jan 8, 2022

GREAT Stay

"Clean, huge room, microwave, min fridge and most importantly in-room coffee (Keurig)."

"The front desk was extremely accommodating. My room was very quiet, so I was able to get a good night sleep. Clean, huge room, microwave, min fridge and most importantly in-room coffee (Keurig)."

#4 Best Value of 4 places to stay in Westbury

By Norm444

Coliseum Inn & Suites - Garden City Long Island

Enter dates to see prices

"The hotel is good in terms of pricing however the cleanliness can improve. The carpeting in the hallways need deep cleaning not just vacuuming. The drapes are torn in some of the rooms which need replacement. The..."

Paramount Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Overnight traveler

@Womanwithopinion

Reviewed on Oct 13, 2019

Womenwithopinion

This is one of the most booked hotels in Floral Park over the last 60 days.

#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Floral Park

By Overnight traveler

"Our room was clean and comfortable, wifi worked well although not perfectly."

Floral Park Motor Lodge

Enter dates to see prices

Motel

Ed M

@478edm

Reviewed on Jun 30, 2023

Decent place to stay and near LIRR

"There is plenty of parking and the highway to the city, airports very close. There are a ton of great restaurants nearby too! The room was spacious and the bed very comfortable… we slept great!!"

#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Floral Park

By marirosa21

"Small room but perfectly adequate and it only took us about 15 minutes to drive to JFK airport. Late checkout was not a problem and staff were very helpful. Despite other reviews stating that it is noisy I did not..."

Bellerose Inn

Enter dates to see prices

MelbournePam

@MelbournePam

Reviewed on Jun 4, 2018

Excellent for price

#2 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Floral Park

By MelbournePam

Best Western Mill River Manor

Enter dates to see prices

Gene K

@genek70

Reviewed on Apr 11, 2023

Best Western Great Hotel !

"Great Hotel , Great Room , Employees are polite and Friendly."

"You enter your rooms from the outside here like a motel. Ample parking, clean rooms, friendly and knowledgeable staff. Train station and restaurants short walking distance. The rooms are a little bit tight."

#2 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Rockville Centre

By John G

Hampton Inn & Suites Rockville Centre

Enter dates to see prices

Batya Swift Y

@Batya Swift Y

Reviewed on Dec 25, 2020

Spotlessly Clean, Great Staff, Comfortable Room

"Spotlessly Clean, Great Staff, Comfortable Room"

"Staff are excellent and accommodating, breakfast is wonderful, rooms are clean and well stocked. Great location in walking distance to the LIRR, and wonderful restaurants and shopping."

#1 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Rockville Centre

By AnnS11118

This is one of the most booked hotels in Rockville Centre over the last 60 days.

Ramada by Wyndham Rockville Centre

Enter dates to see prices

Chris Twanya S

@christwanyas

Reviewed on Dec 5, 2020

My second visit to this room .. I will use it again too...

"Clean, quiet and comfortable room ...Wonderful bed and linens...handicapped bathroom safe, easy to use , very clean ."

"Location to LIRR station was good. More than adequate car parking space. The only shortcoming was very tepid hot water for shower. Room was clean despite age. Could hear the LIRR train, but didn’t disrupt sleep."

#3 Best Value of 3 places to stay in Rockville Centre

By John J

Rockville Centre Inn

Enter dates to see prices

This is one of the most booked hotels in Lynbrook over the last 60 days.

"The room was spacious, with a microwave and fridge plus a keurig which is always a + for us."

Rockville Centre Hotel

Enter dates to see prices

Inn

turbotravelers

@turbotravelers

Reviewed on May 24, 2021

So convenient

"The lobby and dining area are spacious. The dining area is for breakfast, which comes with your daily rate, They have an excellent continental breakfast, and each guest can get scrambled eggs (not runny!)"

#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Lynbrook

By Phil-Yardley

This is one of the most booked hotels in Hicksville over the last 60 days.

"Didnt look like much from the outside but the room was spacious, clean and well-appointed."

Econo Lodge Hicksville

Enter dates to see prices

philandcarolyn

@philandcarolyn

Reviewed on Jun 14, 2021

Diamond in the rough

"Very nice job on the renovation since we’ve been here last. Clean & Comfortable rooms with updates throughout. Staff is friendly and great location what more could you ask for."

#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Hicksville

By Justin S

"When I called they stated they had rooms and that they DID accept us having our baby with us. When I arrived not only were they extremely rude they told me that they did not accept having kids there when they saw me..."

Jericho Motel

Enter dates to see prices

Motel

Csosa04

@Csosa04

Reviewed on Nov 26, 2013

Rude!

"Its $45 For a short stay PERIOD. Not the best BUT, this place has been around for a LONG time. And, I have never experienced rude employees. They clean the carpets a lot and I personally have not seen bugs. I..."

#4 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Jericho

By Csosa04

Intimate Stay

Enter dates to see prices

Limited Service Property

Belmont Motel Inn

Enter dates to see prices

Small Hotel

ginny762

@ginny762

Reviewed on Nov 3, 2019

It is what it is

"The overall stay was ok but the room was way to crowded my husband and I had to walk sideways to get to the bathroom or to even to get on the right side of the bed I think they need to get rid of the oversized..."

#2 Best Value of 7 places to stay in Jamaica

By ginny762

Edgewood Motel

Enter dates to see prices

orginalqueenbee

@orginalqueenbee

Reviewed on Nov 18, 2007

Room Much To Over Crowded!!!!

Red Carpet Inn Queens Village

#5 Best Value of 5 places to stay in Jericho

By orginalqueenbee

Enter dates to see prices

hamzadeltamat

Reviewed on Dec 5, 2017

An OK stay

"Nothing great, and nothing bad. Or maybe just the loud neighbors. I stayed for one night to catch up another flight from JFK. Everything is just normal about this property. The one thing that may be nice would the..."