#1 Best Value of 4 Fire Island Beach Hotels
Reset
FiltersProperty types
Deals
Price
$0 - $311 +
Popular
Amenities
Show more
Distance from
25 mi
Traveler rating
Style
Pro tip: Enter your dates to see qualifying Tripadvisor Plus savings and perks
4 of 20 properties are available and match your filters. Clear all filters
4 of 20 properties are available in Fire Island
Sort by:
Best Value
Updating list...
#2 Best Value of 4 Fire Island Beach Hotels
There are no more properties that match all of your filters. Clear all filters or view Tripadvisor's suggestions. They may be in Fire Island or nearby.
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$95
$88
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $88
7.2 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bay Shore
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$279
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $279
8.5 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$197
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $197
8.6 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$99
Booking.comView all 13 deals from $89
9.0 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Bay Shore
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$132
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $119
9.5 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bohemia
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$90
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $90
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$160
$139
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $139
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$169
Booking.comView all 13 deals from $162
9.8 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$102
$99
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $99
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$95
Booking.comTripadvisor
$95
10.6 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 1 hotel in North Babylon
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$179
$175
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $175
11.3 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Islandia
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$161
Booking.comView all 12 deals from $161
11.3 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Islandia
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$229
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $215
11.6 miles from Fire Island
#3 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
Special offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$170
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $170
11.7 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$222
$199
Booking.comView all 20 deals from $199
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$169
Booking.comView all 13 deals from $149
11.8 miles from Fire Island
#3 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Taking safety measuresMissing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$379
Residence InnView all 14 deals from $379
12.3 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandBeachfront
$149
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $118
12.6 miles from Fire Island
#4 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Special offer
- Visit hotel website