#1 Best Value of 5 Fire Island Hotels with a Pool
Reset
FiltersProperty types
Deals
Price
$0 - $311 +
Popular
Amenities
Show more
Distance from
25 mi
Traveler rating
Style
Pro tip: Enter your dates to see qualifying Tripadvisor Plus savings and perks
5 of 20 properties are available and match your filters. Clear all filters
5 of 20 properties are available in Fire Island
Sort by:
Best Value
Updating list...
#2 Best Value of 5 Fire Island Hotels with a Pool
Small Hotel
#3 Best Value of 5 Fire Island Hotels with a Pool
There are no more properties that match all of your filters. Clear all filters or view Tripadvisor's suggestions. They may be in Fire Island or nearby.
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$95
$88
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $88
7.2 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bay Shore
Missing:In Fire Island
$279
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $279
8.5 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire Island
$197
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $197
8.6 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$99
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $89
9.0 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Bay Shore
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$132
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $119
9.5 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bohemia
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$90
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $90
Missing:In Fire Island
$155
$139
Booking.comView all 16 deals from $139
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$189
$169
Booking.comView all 14 deals from $169
9.8 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$115
$99
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $99
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$95
Booking.comTripadvisor
$95
10.6 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 1 hotel in North Babylon
Missing:In Fire Island
$179
$175
Hampton.comView all 16 deals from $175
11.3 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Islandia
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$161
Expedia.comView all 12 deals from $161
11.3 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Islandia
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$229
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $215
11.6 miles from Fire Island
#3 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
Special offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire Island
$170
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $170
11.7 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire Island
$235
$199
Booking.comView all 20 deals from $199
11.7 miles from Fire Island
#2 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Missing:In Fire IslandPool
$169
Booking.comView all 13 deals from $149
11.8 miles from Fire Island
#3 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Taking safety measuresMissing:In Fire Island
$379
Expedia.comView all 14 deals from $379
12.3 miles from Fire Island
#1 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Taking safety measuresSpecial offer
- Visit hotel website
Missing:In Fire Island
$149
Booking.comView all 15 deals from $118
12.6 miles from Fire Island
#4 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
Special offer
- Visit hotel website