Fire Island Hotels

THE 10 BEST Hotels in Fire Island 2023

Fire Island Hotels

and Places to Stay
Enter dates to find the best prices

Popular


Property types


Amenities


Distance from

25 mi

Traveler rating


Hotel class


Style

20 properties in Fire Island
Sort by:
  • Best Value
    Properties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveler ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
  • Traveler Ranked
    Highest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveler reviews.
  • Distance to city center
    See properties located closest to the center first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners
Enter dates to see prices
#1 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
#2 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
Guest house
Enter dates to see prices
Guest house
Enter dates to see prices
Guest house
No other properties are available in Fire Island. View nearby results below.
Enter dates to see prices
Robert C
Robert C
@robertcX2631LB
Reviewed on Jul 6, 2023
Excellent Customer Service
"The room was super clean and perfect for what we needed."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Sayville
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
MikeDN
MikeDN
@T1995OMmichaeln
Reviewed on Aug 8, 2022
The perfect suburban hotel!
"My room was spacious and everything you would have expect from a Marriott."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Central Islip
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bohemia
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.

Fire Island Hotels Information

Hotels in Fire Island

19

Hotels Prices From

$300

Hotels Reviews

1,833

Hotels Photos

1,558
Not sure when to visit?
Price trends, weather and things to do can help you make a decision.
Season
Avg. price/night
Avg. temperature
Avg. precipitation
Dec - Feb
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
36ºF
COLDEST
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
41in
WETTEST
32 in50 in
Mar - May
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
49ºF
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
39in
32 in50 in
Jun - Aug
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
73ºF
WARMEST
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
36in
DRIEST
32 in50 in
Sep - Nov
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
57ºF
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
38in
32 in50 in
Price trend information excludes taxes and fees and is based on base rates for a nightly stay for 2 adults found in the last 7 days on our site and averaged for commonly viewed hotels in Fire Island. Select dates and complete search for nightly totals inclusive of taxes and fees.

Hotels near the sights

Frequently Asked Questions about Fire Island hotels

The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, and Fire Island Beach House are some of the most popular hotels for travelers looking to stay near Robert Moses State Park. See the full list: Hotels near Robert Moses State Park.

The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Dune Point, and Fire Island Beach House are all popular resorts for travelers staying in Fire Island. See the full list: Fire Island Resorts.

Popular hotels close to Fire Island Lighthouse include The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Belvedere Hotel, and Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. See the full list: Hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse.

Popular hotels close to John F. Kennedy Intl Airport include Courtyard New York JFK Airport, Radisson Hotel JFK Airport, and Fairfield Inn New York JFK Airport. See the full list: Hotels near John F. Kennedy Intl Airport.

A few of the most popular hotels near The Sunken Forest are Belvedere Hotel, Dune Point, and Grove Hotel. See the full list: Hotels near The Sunken Forest.

Popular cheap hotels in Fire Island include Belvedere Hotel, Dune Point, and Fire Island Beach House. See the full list: Cheap Hotels in Fire Island.

Popular hotels by the beach in Fire Island include Dune Point, Fire Island Beach House, and Houser Hotel on the Bay. See the full list: Fire Island Beach Hotels.

The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Belvedere Hotel, and Dune Point received great reviews from travelers looking for a romantic hotel in Fire Island. See the full list: Romantic Hotels in Fire Island.

Some of the most popular hotels with a pool in Fire Island include Belvedere Hotel, Fire Island Beach House, and Grove Hotel. See the full list: Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island.

The above hotel descriptions were created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for any of the above hotel descriptions. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in one of these AI-generated descriptions is inaccurate, please share your feedback.