We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows:
Internet Explorer
,
Mozilla Firefox
,
Google Chrome
. Mac:
Safari
.
Flights
Vacation Rentals
Restaurants
Things to do
Fire Island Tourism
Fire Island Hotels
Fire Island Bed and Breakfast
Fire Island Vacation Rentals
Fire Island Vacation Packages
Flights to Fire Island
Fire Island Restaurants
Things to Do in Fire Island
Fire Island Travel Forum
Fire Island Photos
Fire Island Map
Fire Island Travel Guide
All Fire Island Hotels
Fire Island Hotel Deals
By Hotel Type
Fire Island Resorts
Romantic Hotels in Fire Island
Fire Island Luxury Hotels
Fire Island Beach Hotels
Fire Island Family Hotels
By Hotel Class
3-stars Hotels in Fire Island
Popular Amenities
Fire Island Hotels with Pools
Pet Friendly Hotels in Fire Island
Popular Fire Island Categories
Fire Island Cheap Hotels
Suite Hotels in Fire Island
Family Resorts in Fire Island
Quiet Resorts in Fire Island
Design Hotels in Fire Island
Fire Island Hotels with Hot Tubs
Fire Island Hotels with Kitchenette
Fire Island Clean Hotels
Quiet Hotels in Fire Island
Oceanfront Hotels in Fire Island
Near Landmarks
Hotels near Robert Moses State Park
Hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse
Hotels near The Sunken Forest
Hotels near Ocean Beach
Hotels near Kismet Beach
Near Airports
Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport
Hotels near (LGA) La Guardia Airport
Hotels near (ISP) Long Island MacArthur Airport
Near Colleges
Hotels near Dowling College
Hotels near Branford Hall Career Institute Bohemia NY campus
Travel Guides
Apps
Cruises
GreenLeaders
Road Trips
Skip to main content
Post
Alerts
Trips
Sign in
Inbox
See all
Log in
to get trip updates and message other travelers.
Fire Island
Hotels
Things to do
Restaurants
Flights
Vacation Rentals
Shopping
Vacation Packages
Cruises
Rental Cars
Add a Place
Travel Forum
Airlines
Best of 2020
Road Trips
Help Center
Best Lodging in Fire Island, NY (with Prices)
United States
New York (NY)
Long Island
Fire Island
Fire Island Hotels
View map
Fire Island Hotels
and Places to Stay
Check In
— / — / —
Check Out
— / — / —
Guests
1 room
,
2 adults
,
0 children
Search
Reset
Filters
Deals
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
Properties with special offers
Property types
Resorts
1
View Vacation Rentals
Price
$0 - $234 +
Price per night
Popular
& up
1
Breakfast included
1
Resorts
1
Amenities
Free Wifi
1
Breakfast included
1
Restaurant
1
Air conditioning
1
Show more
Distance from
25 mi
The Sunken Forest
Fire Island Lighthouse
Robert Moses State Park
Traveler rating
& up
1
& up
1
Style
Budget
1
Show 20 results
5 of 20
properties are available in Fire Island
Sort
Filter
Map
5 of 20
properties are available in Fire Island
Sort by:
Best Value
Updating list...
Breakfast included
Clegg's Hotel
$234
Hotels.com
View Deal
Booking.com
$234
Expedia.com
$234
Priceline
$234
View all 11 deals from $234
95 reviews
#1 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
“
Terrible furniture, loud even off season, and
terrible uncomfortable beds. The bathrooms are communal but clean. The owners are nice but they need to spruce this place up. The location is great. It’s literally…
”
Free Wifi
Restaurant
The Madison Fire Island Pines
Booking.com
View Deal
ZenHotels.com
Ranch
140 reviews
#2 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
“
Our weekend at The Madison was absolutely
delightful. Our room was right off the pool which was a HUGE delight. Just sliding open our door and sliding into the pool-amazing. You are literally STEPS from the…
”
Free Wifi
Pool
Fire Island Beach House
StayForLong
View Deal
Expedia.com
Hotels.com
Travelocity
View all 8 deals
199 reviews
#3 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
“
The bed was a full size so not the greatest when you're
used to a queen or king, but the
room was clean
.
”
Pool
Beach
Houser Hotel on the Bay
ZenHotels.com
View Deal
StayForLong
11 reviews
#4 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
“
No directions to the hotel are ever provided -
nothing on the website and nothing in the confirmation email. This is an issue because when you look up directions on Google Maps, it indicates that you can drive to...
”
Beach
Restaurant
The Lodge - Deluxe King Bed 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom Hotel Room
Expedia.com
View Deal
Hotels.com
Orbitz.com
CheapTickets
View all 5 deals
Small Hotel
0 reviews
#5 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
No other properties are available in Fire Island. View nearby results below.
Price Match Guarantee
Breakfast included
Sponsored
Hampton Inn Long Island - Brookhaven
$159
Hampton.com
View Deal
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
Hotel info
Visit hotel website
1 (855) 605-0317
Special offer
Special Offer
Price Match Guarantee
830 reviews
“
room clean and fresh
.Breakfast the same.They have
water wiyh lemon (nice)Stay there a couple of times,so yes definitely will go back!
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Pool
Fitness center
Breakfast included
Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island
$92
Wyndham
View Deal
Booking.com
$92
FindHotel
$85
Agoda.com
$92
View all 17 deals from $85
85 reviews
7.2 miles
from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bay Shore
“
Checked in and was asked, get this... our rooms
are a "min of two hours"... huh???? I had a reservation, which by the way was impossible to find. Went to dinner, and two people were having sex in my room when…
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Unlock Member Rates!
Breakfast included
Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
$197
Residence Inn
View Deal
Booking.com
$197
Agoda.com
$197
eDreams
$197
View all 17 deals from $197
173 reviews
8.5 miles
from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
“
The service was
awesome our
room was clean
and the breakfast
was good as well.
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Taking safety measures
Special offer
Special Offer
Unlock Member Rates!
Visit hotel website
Unlock Member Rates!
Courtyard Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
$189
$161
Courtyard
View Deal
Booking.com
$189
Hotels.com
$161
eDreams
$189
View all 18 deals from $161
47 reviews
8.6 miles
from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Central Islip
“
Room spacious
Bathroom designed well Pool and
outside area excellent for family/friend gathering.
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Taking safety measures
Special offer
Special Offer
Unlock Member Rates!
Visit hotel website
Breakfast included
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
$132
Booking.com
View Deal
Wyndham
$132
Snaptravel
$120
Trip.com
$151
View all 15 deals from $120
866 reviews
9.5 miles
from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Bohemia
“
Our experience was
great--room
was spotless and
very comfortable; staff helpful, and the hotel decor looks new.
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
$94
Clarion
View Deal
Agoda.com
$94
Snaptravel
$90
Hotels.com
$104
View all 14 deals from $90
321 reviews
9.7 miles
from Fire Island
#5 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“
The front desk staff was nice and accommodating.
The owners however, were the rudest I have met. Every time the owner was behind the counter, she was yelling at someone. She was condescending, poorly organized...
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Price Match Guarantee
Top Rated
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
$169
Booking.com
View Deal
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
GardenInn.com
$169
Snaptravel
$145
Trip.com
$190
View all 16 deals from $145
1,283 reviews
9.8 miles
from Fire Island
#1 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“
Room was super clean
and the bar/restaurant staff
was fun and really worked hard as a team to provide excellent service.
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Taking safety measures
Special offer
Special Offer
Price Match Guarantee
Visit hotel website
Breakfast included
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport
$99
$84
Rodeway
View Deal
Booking.com
$84
Hotels.com
$99
eDreams
$84
View all 15 deals from $84
73 reviews
9.8 miles
from Fire Island
#4 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“
The room where ok and clean. The people stying
there were nasty. I ask for an non smoking room. It was nothing but smoked smell. Bath dirty. My kid was hard to sleep because because the cigarettes smell. And I’m...
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Price Match Guarantee
Breakfast included
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
$159
Booking.com
View Deal
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
Hampton.com
$159
Snaptravel
$154
StayForLong
$176
View all 16 deals from $154
805 reviews
11.3 miles
from Fire Island
#1 of 2 hotels in Islandia
“
Wifi was great streaming Pandora
and the
room was spacious
for mixed families
travelling for the competition.
”
Free Wifi
Pool
Taking safety measures
Special offer
Special Offer
Price Match Guarantee
Visit hotel website
Jake's 58 Casino Hotel
$144
Booking.com
View Deal
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
Hotels.com
$122
eDreams
$144
Snaptravel
$134
View all 13 deals from $122
931 reviews
11.3 miles
from Fire Island
#2 of 2 hotels in Islandia
“
Stayed overnight
and the
hotel room was clean
with a view of
the casino.
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Price Match Guarantee
Breakfast included
Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma
$179
Homewood
View Deal
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
Booking.com
$179
Snaptravel
$153
StayForLong
$184
View all 14 deals from $153
41 reviews
11.6 miles
from Fire Island
#3 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“
Check in was a breeze. The hotel is clean, the
staff is courteous, the rooms are a great size and are well appointed. The bedding was clean and crisp, the beds were comfortable. The kitchen and bathroom areas…
”
Free Wifi
Fitness center
Special offer
Special Offer
Price Match Guarantee
Visit hotel website
Unlock Member Rates!
Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport - Ronkonkoma
$199
Courtyard
View Deal
Free cancellation
Booking.com
$199
Trip.com
$178
Hotels.com
$199
View all 14 deals from $178
311 reviews
11.7 miles
from Fire Island
#2 of 6 hotels in Ronkonkoma
“
Clean spacious room
, friendly staff, shuttle
service to wedding venue.
”
Free Wifi
Pool
Taking safety measures
Special offer
Special Offer
Unlock Member Rates!
Visit hotel website
Hyatt Regency Long Island
$217
Booking.com
View Deal
Snaptravel
$201
Lol.travel
$195
Trip.com
$243
View all 17 deals from $195
1,328 reviews
11.7 miles
from Fire Island
#2 of 4 hotels in Hauppauge
“
Great room
, comfortable bed, great room service,
great food and drinks in restaurant, fabulous indoor pool, jacuzzi and gym.
”
Free Wifi
Free parking
Breakfast included
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge
$149
HIExpress.com
View Deal
Free cancellation
Reserve now, pay at stay
Booking.com
$149
Trip.com
$124
Agoda.com
$149
View all 15 deals from $124