THE 10 BEST Hotels in Fire Island 2023

Fire Island Hotels
and Places to StayEnter dates to find the best prices
Popular
Property types
Amenities
Distance from
25 mi
Traveler rating
Hotel class
Style
Popular hotels in Fire Island right now
20 properties in Fire Island
Sort by:
- Best ValueProperties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveler ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
- Traveler RankedHighest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveler reviews.
- Distance to city centerSee properties located closest to the center first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners
Enter dates to see prices

Colleen
@colleensQ9835WV
Reviewed on Jun 28, 2023
Amazing!
"Room was super clean and we had service/ touch ups twice a day!!"
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices

James M
@James M
Reviewed on Oct 3, 2021
Enjoyable stay
"The room was clean and they let us check in very early, which was fantastic."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
Ranch

Graham L
@487grahaml
Reviewed on Jul 2, 2021
Excellent weekend getaway.
"The room was clean and comfortable and the atmosphere was so clam and pleasant that I really felt far away from home."
Read all reviews
#3 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Condominium

Richard R
@R5341SRrichardr
Reviewed on Sep 15, 2023
Nice 2 Night Gettaway 12B
"If your looking for a cozy place to relax at the end of the day, this is it. The room is small but if going with a group just rent more rooms, or a beach house. We enjoyed having a view of the bay every day and a..."
Read all reviews
#4 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices

Nimotae
@Nimotae
Reviewed on Sep 7, 2017
Convenient but noisy location
"Great location, very convenient and right in town. Close to all shops & restaurants. Noisy at night with people waiting for ferry and noise from the bars. Wonderful staff but room was disappointing.
Went there with..."
Read all reviews
#5 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
#6 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Villa
#7 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Resort

Jennifer C
@jennifercK5387VT
Reviewed on Sep 20, 2023
Below average
"For the price per night, one would expect better quality and service. The front desk staff was not very friendly, and at times seemed put off that you bothered them with a question. The room itself had stained..."
Read all reviews
#8 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices

nic60763
@nic60763
Reviewed on Jul 17, 2019
Excellent place to getaway for the weekend
"We stayed here last weekend and had a great time. We stayed here a few years ago and knew we’d be back as the location is very convenient, right at the ferry, everyone is super nice and their upper deck patio is..."
Read all reviews
#9 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Specialty B&B

Neale W
@nwest_mail
Reviewed on Jun 26, 2023
A great option for The Pines
"A great and easy place to stay when visiting Fire Island. Less than a 10 minute walk from the ferry terminal the guesthouse sits amongst some of the best houses on the island. We had one of the smaller rooms (room..."
Read all reviews
#10 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Limited Service Property

Christopher T
@Z1828YUchristophert
Reviewed on Aug 15, 2023
Romantic Fire Island Getaway
"Our stay at the Boatel was the perfect Anniversary and the perfect getaway. If you sunrises, bike rides to quaint and charming fire island towns, a day at the ocean, perfect sunsets, lunch or dinner around friendly..."
Read all reviews
#11 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices

PVJB
@Paul B
Reviewed on Sep 8, 2023
A happy time in Cherry Grove.
"Nice renovation rooms are a lot nicer than the previous old hotel.
Pool was open and lots of people seemed to ge having a great time.
Ice Palace nightclub was fun and frolic as usual.
Only drawback for me is the..."
Read all reviews
#12 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Guest house
#13 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast

VictoriaPlanet
@VictoriaPlanet
Reviewed on Sep 2, 2019
Great place
"We had a pleasant stay. The rooms are basic and clean. Sharing the bathroom wasn’t bad at all. It was clean and they give you soap and shampoo. You can also borrow chairs, beach blankets and they have an ice..."
Read all reviews
#14 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Specialty B&B

dsm_h
@dsm_hNYC
Reviewed on Jul 4, 2019
Please, these reviews aren’t right
"I was very skeptical about booking due to certain reviews on here. My husband, friend and I love a luxury experience and knowing fire island had our expectations low (pine 70s chic). Joe, since before our booking..."
Read all reviews
#15 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices

Jamie B
@Jamie B
Reviewed on Aug 17, 2019
If you're here for the night life...
"The rate was better than other Fire Island options I explored (at least midweek). So I figured a couple days at the beach would be worth "noisy" in the reviews. I've stayed in Ocean Beach before and it was fine but..."
Read all reviews
#16 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
Enter dates to see prices
Small Hotel

Trey J
@Trey J
Reviewed on Jun 29, 2016
Avoid unless there is nothing else available
"Didn't have the background or history to know that this place is well known to be avoided. Apparently they changed the name and renovated the year before, but in the kick-off weekend of their second year (Memorial..."
Read all reviews
#17 Best Value of 20 places to stay in Fire Island
No other properties are available in Fire Island. View nearby results below.
Enter dates to see prices

Robert C
@robertcX2631LB
Reviewed on Jul 6, 2023
Excellent Customer Service
"The room was super clean and perfect for what we needed."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Sayville
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast

Daniel M
@danielmJ4924YG
Reviewed on Aug 27, 2023
Perfect bed and breakfast
"This place is perfect! Cozy, spotless, well-appointed, up-to-date. Hosts Ari and Mark are gracious, thoughtful, welcoming. The continental breakfast is astoundingly good, everything homemade: bread, popovers, even..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Sayville
Enter dates to see prices
Specialty B&B

NorthStar614517
@NorthStar614517
Reviewed on Jul 19, 2021
Simply amazing!
"The breakfasts were amazing and served in the beautiful dining room or on the patio; our room was spacious and cozy and well appointed."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Bay Shore
Enter dates to see prices
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bay Shore
Enter dates to see prices

Brooke H
@brookehR4013CR
Reviewed on Sep 24, 2023
Nice room! Might be haunted?
"Stayed here for 2 nights for a friend’s wedding in LI. Nice room, if a bit outdated decor. Was very spacious and had a full-size fridge, and a stove, which I’ve rarely see in hotels. It was clean, well-stocked, and..."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Central Islip
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices

MikeDN
@T1995OMmichaeln
Reviewed on Aug 8, 2022
The perfect suburban hotel!
"My room was spacious and everything you would have expect from a Marriott."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Central Islip
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices
Cabin/Campground
#1 Best Value of 1 place to stay in Patchogue
Enter dates to see prices
#2 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bay Shore
Enter dates to see prices

thesuperiors2259
@thesuperiors2259
Reviewed on Mar 6, 2022
Good location
"Good location, clean room, friendly attentive staff… you will just have to eat out, breakfast is not appealing."
Read all reviews
#1 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bohemia
This hotel description was created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for this description. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in this AI-generated description is inaccurate, please share your feedback.
Enter dates to see prices

Brianna L
@Brianna L
Reviewed on Jul 29, 2017
Rude Front Desk Agent.
"I tend to book rooms here for my Fiance who gets in off the train at 4am. The very rude nasty lady who has a serious attitude and no hospitality skills granted 12pm c/o. I called and asked at 11:40 to be transfered..."
Read all reviews
#2 Best Value of 2 places to stay in Bohemia
Fire Island Hotels Information
Hotels in Fire Island | 19 |
---|---|
Hotels Prices From | $300 |
Hotels Reviews | 1,833 |
Hotels Photos | 1,558 |
Not sure when to visit?
Price trends, weather and things to do can help you make a decision.
Season
Avg. price/night
Avg. temperature
Avg. precipitation
Dec - Feb
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
36ºF
COLDEST
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
41in
WETTEST
32 in50 in
Mar - May
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
49ºF
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
39in
32 in50 in
Jun - Aug
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
73ºF
WARMEST
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
36in
DRIEST
32 in50 in
Sep - Nov
Avg. price/night
-
Avg. temperature
57ºF
9ºF91ºF
Avg. precipitation
38in
32 in50 in
Price trend information excludes taxes and fees and is based on base rates for a nightly stay for 2 adults found in the last 7 days on our site and averaged for commonly viewed hotels in Fire Island. Select dates and complete search for nightly totals inclusive of taxes and fees.
Hotels near the sights
- Fire Island LighthouseRead more
- Robert Moses State ParkRead more
- Kismet BeachRead more
- The Sunken ForestRead more
- Sailors HavenRead more
- Ocean BeachRead more
- Davis Park MarinaRead more
Frequently Asked Questions about Fire Island hotels
- The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, and Fire Island Beach House are some of the most popular hotels for travelers looking to stay near Robert Moses State Park. See the full list: Hotels near Robert Moses State Park.
- The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Dune Point, and Fire Island Beach House are all popular resorts for travelers staying in Fire Island. See the full list: Fire Island Resorts.
- Popular hotels close to Fire Island Lighthouse include The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Belvedere Hotel, and Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. See the full list: Hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse.
- Popular hotels close to John F. Kennedy Intl Airport include Courtyard New York JFK Airport, Radisson Hotel JFK Airport, and Fairfield Inn New York JFK Airport. See the full list: Hotels near John F. Kennedy Intl Airport.
- A few of the most popular hotels near The Sunken Forest are Belvedere Hotel, Dune Point, and Grove Hotel. See the full list: Hotels near The Sunken Forest.
- Popular cheap hotels in Fire Island include Belvedere Hotel, Dune Point, and Fire Island Beach House. See the full list: Cheap Hotels in Fire Island.
- Popular hotels by the beach in Fire Island include Dune Point, Fire Island Beach House, and Houser Hotel on the Bay. See the full list: Fire Island Beach Hotels.
- The Palms Hotel Fire Island, Belvedere Hotel, and Dune Point received great reviews from travelers looking for a romantic hotel in Fire Island. See the full list: Romantic Hotels in Fire Island.
- Some of the most popular hotels with a pool in Fire Island include Belvedere Hotel, Fire Island Beach House, and Grove Hotel. See the full list: Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island.
The above hotel descriptions were created by AI, using information and phrases commonly found in reviews users submitted to Tripadvisor. Tripadvisor did not create and is not responsible for any of the above hotel descriptions. Please read full traveler reviews for more details and information. If you believe something in one of these AI-generated descriptions is inaccurate, please share your feedback.