THE NEW YORKER A WYNDHAM HOTEL $151 ($̶2̶9̶9̶) - Updated 2019 Prices & Reviews - New York City

Great hotel

My first time staying in New York! Very good hotel. My room was standard but nice. Bed very comfortable but a few concerns:::damp on closet floor and light toilet noise first night. After a long day of touring and on second evening toilet wouldn't stop flushing..just aweful....called front desk and every number on room phone but no answer. I called 1-800 fir reservation who was kind enough after hearing my story to transfer me to local hotel reservation who was able to get someone to the phone. While out of room it was fixed. I did not find too many bellman friendly. They could smile and greet guest whether helping with luggage or not! Bed very comfortable and hotel directly across street from Penn Station and Madison Square Gardens...I came in on the Amtrak train so PERFECT location. Macy's and Empire state building about 4 blocks away...easy walking to many restaurants, shops, bus tour stops, etc! Plan to return next year and stay there again! Tic Toc Diner ok and was more of a convenience for me. Their NY Cheesecake was soooo delicious! After day one and a half, I ate at other places near hotel. Staff friendly. I was given an upgrade on 8th floor since I was not comfortable with heights. The hotel is very clean and fresh smelled ng and an Icon in NYC.…

Date of stay: September 2019Trip type: Traveled solo

Old and tired.

If you’re a tourist and want to experience old NY and stay in one of the noisiest, busiest, dirtiest parts of the city this is for you. The building is historic and you can see how it would have been in its heyday in the 1950s. But it’s now dirty, old, walls are water damaged and plaster is peeling. It’s noisy (I was on the 29th floor) and I wish I could have seen it “way back then”....because the heavy doors, marble trim on the walls, Art Deco artifacts by the elevators all look charming. But I’d never spend the $ i did here again. It needs a major overhaul. Convenient to the train stations though!…

Date of stay: September 2019Trip type: Traveled on business

Dated historic hotel

My wife and I recently stayed at this hotel in September. The hotel location is very good (if you want to stay in mid-town), close to Madison Square Garden, Penn Station and the theater district. We found the hotel staff to be professional, but not the friendliest. We had issues checking in as there was error in the computer system related to the confirmation. Also, at the time of checking in we were told that the room wasn't ready and we would get a call when it's ready. Unfortunately, we never got a call. What I found annoying is that the hotel has a $5/bag hold fee, even for overnight guests. This is the first time I've encountered this in NYC, and there was only 1 person, at that time working the bag-check, so we had to wait 10-15 minutes, because the line was long. The room itself is comfortable, but very small and looks dated. The bed is supposed to be a queen, but honestly felt like a double/full. I probably wouldn't stay at this hotel again, as there are many options in the area.…

Date of stay: September 2019

Location

Cleanliness

Service

Very disappointing

Standard double room was very small with very old en-suite. Customer service is shocking in this hotel, rude, abrupt and arrogant. Definitely not worth its stars and it’s not cheap. Having said all that the location is perfect, but that’s all this hotel has going for it and lives off that as the hotel is very antiquated and shabby in parts. Would not stay here again.…

Date of stay: September 2019Trip type: Traveled as a couple

Super stay

In town to see "Hamilton" for the second time and this was the prefect location. Easy walk to the theater district and many attractions. Beautiful lobby with very helpful staff. Spacious comfortable room. Close to Penn Station. Only minor negative the water temp in the shower bounced around a bit but it's an old hotel and you have to expect some minor quirks. Bonus, they were shooting "Blue Bloods" in the hotel one of the days we were there.…

Review collected in partnership with this hotel

Date of stay: September 2019

Value

Rooms

Location

Cleanliness

Service

Sleep Quality

Trip type: Traveled with friends

Dear Joanna H; Thank you for choosing to stay with us during your recent visit to New York City. Our service culture is to meet or exceed our guests expectations and based on your review "our very helpful staff" succeed. We appreciate you taking the time to share your review with us and look forward to welcoming you back to The New Yorker Hotel in the near future.

PreviousNext

12 3 4 5 6…2273

The New Yorker a Wyndham Hotel, New York City

The New Yorker a Wyndham Hotel

About

Location

Reviews