We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

White Fences Inn

Check In— / — / —
Check Out— / — / —
Guests1 room, 2 adults, 0 children
Traveler (64)
Dining (35)
Videos (3)
Certificate of Excellence


#1 of 3 B&Bs / Inns in Water Mill
Certificate of Excellence
Newly renovated B&B with all new modern & high touch decor and amenities await you at this relaxing respite. A three course daily gourmet breakfast is included. Lounge by the pool or take a short drive to the beach - you decide. Amenities include Frette & Matouk linens, robes, & slippers, Malin & Goetz toiletries, Tea Forte and Coffee by Design. Complimentary WiFi and free on site parking
Read more
Property amenities
Free parking
Free High Speed Internet (WiFi)
Free internet
Outdoor pool
Free breakfast
Non-smoking hotel
Shared lounge / TV area
Show more
Room features
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
iPod docking station
Bath / shower
Family rooms
Wake-up service / alarm clock
Complimentary toiletries
Hair dryer
Show more
Good to know
Hotel links
Visit hotel website
Hotel packages


Full view
38Car recommended
Grade: 38 out of 100
90Restaurantswithin 5 miles
44Attractionswithin 5 miles
16Room tips
Traveler rating
  • 120
  • 5
  • 1
  • 0
  • 1
Time of year
Traveler type
Selected filters
  • Filter
  • English
Popular mentions
Thank you for a lovely stay! I literally had the best one night stay at @whitefencesinnwatermill It was so relaxing and nice. The air is golden, the hosts Liz and Eric are the most welcoming and warm people I’ve ever met. We had a blast at the Hamptons. Can’t wait to return. 😍 If in the NY area you should go too! #hamptons #whitefenceswatermill #nyclife
Read more
Response from lb121, Owner at White Fences Inn
Responded Jun 4, 2019
Dear Lili, We wish you could have stayed longer to explore the Hamptons more but 24 hours was enough for you to fall in love with White Fences Inn. I know you will be back. Until then safe travels and we look forward to your next visit. Best, Liz & Eric
Read more
Property's Favorite Review
I like to surprise my wife every year for her birthday, by booking a weekend getaway. She has been talking about going to Long Island to visit some wineries, so I did my homework, and searched. I believe this was an A+ !!! From the beginning, Liz was extremely hospitable !!! She recommended a larger room for us, which was a perfect choice !!! Both Liz and Eric prepared and served 3 course breakfasts that were amazing !!! The room was so cozy and comfortable. We really loved the fireplace !! But, the thing that was OVER the TOP for me, Liz and Eric were sponsoring a wine and food tasting, and invited us. Who does that ?? We have been to many bed and breakfasts, and this one is now on top !!!! Great location too ! Liz set us up for live music Friday night at the Wolffer Estate Winery, as well as at the American Hotel for what was a top 10 dinner !!! I HIGHLY recommend it. She also recommended Zuki Sushi which was excellent as well, and one of the few restaurants open late ! It was a great location for visiting wineries as well, which I understand there are about 50 !!! We will just have to return to visit some more wineries !!!! We plan to return next year for another birthday weekend, or even sooner !!! You will NOT be disappointed when you stay here !!!! And I almost forgot ......... the Nespresso machine in our room was another amazing touch ! The coffee was so good, we bought a Nespresso machine for our home !!! Thanks Liz and Eric for such an amazing stay !!!!! Give a pet to Bailey for us !!! This bed and breakfast deserves a 6 on Tripadvisor !!!
Read more
Response from lb121, Owner at White Fences Inn
Responded Apr 9, 2019
I am so happy that the surprise birthday weekend was such a success! Nothing makes me happier than to have guests enjoy their time in the Hamptons and at our inn. It was perfect timing that we could have you attend Two Forks and a Cork at the Parrish Art Museum as our guests. This will be coming a bi-annual food & event hopefully you can join us for the next one! People don't always think of visiting in the winter but you certainly kept busy. Our guests really enjoy having the Nespresso machines in their rooms so they can have coffee or espresso anytime they want. I love that you went home and purchased one! We look forward to welcoming you back in the (near) future! Thank you very much for taking the time to write a review and share your experience with others. Best, Liz, Eric and Bailey
Read more
my husband and i totaly enjoyed the service, breakfast and the privacy of the pool area. Eric and Liz the inn keepers/owners, go above and beyond to make your star as amazing as posible, freshly baked cookies and rose every day at the pool, yummy!
Read more
This is the second year we spent Memorial Day Weekend at White Fences Inn in Watermill. The Inn is simply wonderful - a sophisticated and contemporary environment offering spacious and beautiful rooms with luxury linens, Malin & Goetz bath products, a soaking tub, and even a small gas fireplace. A delicious and huge breakfast is served each morning in the stunning and comfy dining room or, in the nice weather, outside on the patio overlooking the 1 acre property and beautiful pool. Liz, the owner, is a fabulous cook and each morning we delighted in her treats - homemade baked goods, artfully presented fruit and yogurt, and her egg dishes - one morning a Kale Frittata, another - eggs on a home baked croissant with bacon and cheese. Every afternoon waiting in your room are also her home baked cookies! Rather than feeling like you are staying at an Inn or hotel, you really feel more like you are a guest in the beautiful home of owners, Liz and Eric. They are both very gracious, hospitable and attentive to service. The property is well located a short distance from beaches, wineries, shops and restaurants in Southhampton, Bridgehampton and Sag Harbor. We will be back!!
Read more
Response from lb121, Owner at White Fences Inn
Responded May 28, 2019
Dear Diane, I was so excited when I saw you make your reservation for Memorial Day weekend this year! We love welcoming back guests, in fact we look forward to it! The weather this year certainly helped make for a perfect weekend. It was nice to see you and Todd relaxing by the pool. It's so nice to hear that you feel so comfortable here. That is how we want you to feel. As you know I love to cook/bake, food is a passion for me and thankfully for our guests too! We look forward to your next visit and hope you have a wonderful summer! Many thanks for sharing your experience with others. Best, Liz & Eric
Read more
We stayed at the White Fences Inn in April 2019 and everything was absolutely amazing! The house, the room, the breakfast offerings, the turn-down service, the location, the welcoming nature of the owners and their dog...there are not enough words to express how much we enjoyed our stay and we cannot wait to visit the White Fences Inn again in the future!
Read more
Review collected in partnership with this hotel
Response from lb121, Owner at White Fences Inn
Responded May 28, 2019
Dear Paulettee, Nothing makes me happier than to see reviews like this! There are not enough words to say how much we appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with others. We look forward to welcoming you back to our inn. Very best, Liz, Eric and Bailey
Read more
$397 - $1,096 (Based on Average Rates for a Standard Room)
United StatesNew YorkLong IslandHamptonsSouthamptonWater Mill
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?

Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.

Claim Your Listing