We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
$25 Amazon.com Gift Card Get yours when you book a hotel on TripAdvisor and review your stay!

The American Hotel

Show Prices
Book on TripAdvisor
Trusted partner. We work with to make your booking as easy as possible.
Secure payments. We use industry-leading practices to keep your information secure.
Enter dates for best prices
powered by PriceFinder
Prices from our online travel partners are not available
We can't find prices for this hotel
Our online travel partners don't provide prices for this accommodation, but we can search other options in Sag Harbor
Check In Check Out
Show Prices
Management photos
The American Hotel
View Map
{"widget":{"name":"ibex_photo_carousel","template":"ibex_photo_carousel__widget","dust":{"nav_controls":"ibex_photo_carousel__nav_controls"},"divClasses":"prw_rup prw_ibex_photo_carousel","moduleList":["handlers","shims"],"js":{"handlers":"(ta.prwidgets.getjs(this,'handlers'))","shims":"(ta.prwidgets.getjs(this,'shims'))"}},"containerClass":null}
Add Photo Write a Review

89 Reviews from our TripAdvisor Community

Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Language
  • More
Showing 86: English reviews
lisboa
Level Contributor
20 reviews
8 hotel reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 15 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed 1 week ago

After a rather disappointing stay at a Shelter Island hotel, we arrived with mixed feelings at the American. Similar in style to the hotel we had just left, 'American dream of a bygone yesterday' I might call it, I was now worried about another night on a bygone mattress. Little did I have to worry. We arrived in a dream.... More 

Helpful?
Thank Butterfly-lane
United States
Level Contributor
163 reviews
17 hotel reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 25 helpful votes
3 of 5 stars Reviewed 3 weeks ago

If you are here, you are somebody, but that may mean somebody who settle for want to be fab food. The lobster served out of the shell takes away all my fun, sorry! Love the atmosphere though and the backgammon table, so cerebral!

Helpful?
Thank AliceMA007
Staten Island
Level Contributor
3 reviews
3 hotel reviews
5 of 5 stars Reviewed 4 weeks ago via mobile

This was an amazing place to stay !! The proximity to everyhing you want to do in sag harbor is unparalleled. The room is so sweet. Everything is kept in non modern times -- if you're looking for top of the line clean lines this is not the place. But if you're up for a great bathroom jacuzzi and a... More 

Helpful?
Thank 94nadezhdam
Long Grove, Illinois
Level Contributor
12 reviews
4 hotel reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 5 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed 4 weeks ago

Although we felt it was charming on the first floor and the restaurant had upscale sterling silver and china, the room was worn out and we were disappointed for $350 a night we didn't have coffee or a TV in the room.

Helpful?
Thank Sexson
Level Contributor
7 reviews
5 of 5 stars Reviewed August 16, 2016 via mobile

I truly love this place! Yes, the prices are high but what do you expect when you get impeccable service and an amazing dining experience! I love the old world feel. They serve breakfast and dinner, which I've had many times and have never been disappointed. We have been coming for years and the Maitre'D, servers, hostess and bartenders always... More 

Helpful?
Thank LindaB1368
A TripAdvisor Member
1 of 5 stars Reviewed August 14, 2016 via mobile

What a TERRIBLE experience!! Had a wonderful day the Hamptons, decided to try a different restaurant, BIG MISTAKE. We should have left right after being seated. The food not fresh with no flavor, especially the salad, how can you serve brown mixed greens? The bread was 2 days old, and I suspect our rosé was from a box, server was... More 

Helpful?
Thank A TripAdvisor Member
Warwick, Rhode Island
Level Contributor
24 reviews
6 hotel reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 15 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed August 8, 2016

We always come here for dinner when in Sag Harbor. We have never been disappointed. The duck and the diver sole are our favorites. The deserts to die for. Lots of interesting people to talk to. Everyone is do very friendly, especially the maitre'd. .

Helpful?
Thank Babboobabs
Lake Grove, New York
Level Contributor
27 reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 4 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed July 29, 2016

Food and service are outstanding, but be prepared to pay for it. Their oysters on the half shell are local and are outstanding. The rest of the the meal was truly way above average. The duck was one of the best I have ever had.

Helpful?
1 Thank MICHAEL B
Chertsey, United Kingdom
Level Contributor
409 reviews
55 hotel reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 131 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed July 2, 2016 via mobile

This is a classic hotel with a lot of history and almost in a time warp. Service was very good and attentive. Food was of good quality and a high standard. The outside seating is good for people watching although a little cramped. The toilets were clean.

Helpful?
Thank Alan M
Wantagh, New York
Level Contributor
28 reviews
common_n_hotel_reviews_1bd8 8 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed June 29, 2016 via mobile

The American Hotel is consistently good for dinner! They update the menu so locals enjoy the change. The service and quality are great. The setting is colonial so you enjoy a bit of history with your meal. The bar is vibrant and friendly and a hot night spot. This great place never disappoints!

Helpful?
Thank Roslyn28wantagh
Questions? Get answers from hotel staff and past guests. Ask a question

17 photos of this hotel

Traveler photos: See what travelers like you saw

Viewed
All Traveler Photos (7)
Viewed
Hotel & Grounds (3)
Viewed
Room/Suite (2)
Viewed
Other (2)

Management photos: Courtesy of the property manager

Viewed
All Management Photos (10)
Viewed
Dining (10)
Check In Check Out
Hotels you might also like...
Also consider these accommodations in or near Sag Harbor
0.3 mi away
Baron's Cove
Baron's Cove
#1 of 5 in Sag Harbor
4.5 of 5 stars 165 reviews
15.8 mi away
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
6.3 mi away
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin Hotel
#2 of 5 in Shelter Island
3.5 of 5 stars 218 reviews
Show Prices
Show Prices
Show Prices
4.4 mi away
Topping Rose House
Topping Rose House
#1 of 1 in Bridgehampton
4.5 of 5 stars 78 reviews
6.0 mi away
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island House
#1 of 5 in Shelter Island
4.5 of 5 stars 57 reviews
19.7 mi away
Hyatt Place Long Island East End
Show Prices
Show Prices
Show Prices
Questions? Get answers from hotel staff and past guests. Ask a question

Amenities

Highlights
  • Free High Speed Internet ( WiFi )
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Beachfront
  • Spa
  • Free Breakfast
About the property
  • Beachfront
Things to do
  • Restaurant
  • Bar/Lounge
  • Spa
Room types
  • Suites
  • Non-Smoking Rooms
In your room
  • Air Conditioning
  • Refrigerator in room
  • Minibar
Internet
  • Free Internet
  • Free High Speed Internet ( WiFi )
  • Public Wifi
Services
  • Free Breakfast
  • Concierge

Additional Information about The American Hotel

Address: 49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963-3012
Location: United States > New York > Long Island > Hamptons > Sag Harbor
Price Range: $169 - $395 (Based on Average Rates for a Standard Room)
Number of rooms: 12
Also Known As:
American Hotel Sag Harbor
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Listing