We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

The American Hotel

49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963-3012
Contact accommodation for availability.
There are similar hotels available.
View all
Traveler (21)
Dining (14)
Room & Suite (2)


#3 of 5 hotels in Sag Harbor

Everyone needs a place to lay their weary head. For travelers visiting Sag Harbor, The American Hotel is an excellent choice for rest and rejuvenation. Well-known for its luxury environment and proximity to great restaurants and attractions, The American Hotel makes it easy to enjoy the best of Sag Harbor.

The rooms offer a minibar, air conditioning, and a refrigerator, and getting online is possible, as free wifi is available, allowing you to rest and refresh with ease.

The American Hotel features a concierge. In addition, as a valued The American Hotel guest, you can enjoy free breakfast that is available on-site.

Given the close proximity to First Presbyterian/Old Whaler's Church (0.3 mi), guests of The American Hotel can easily experience one of Sag Harbor's most popular landmarks.

If you like Mediterranean restaurants, The American Hotel is conveniently located near Wölffer Kitchen Sag Harbor.

There is no shortage of things to do in the area: explore popular art galleries such as Monika Olko Gallery.

Whether you’re traveling for business, pleasure or both, The American Hotel is sure to make your visit to Sag Harbor one worth remembering.

Read more
Property amenities
Electric vehicle charging station
Free public parking nearby
Free High Speed Internet (WiFi)
Free breakfast
Laundry service
Bar / lounge
Breakfast available
Breakfast buffet
Happy hour
Outdoor dining area
Special diet menus
Wine / champagne
Non-smoking hotel
Show more
Room features
Air conditioning
Whirlpool bathtub
Private bathrooms
Show more
Room types
Non-smoking rooms
Good to know
Historic Hotel
Languages Spoken
English, Russian, Spanish
138Reviews2Q+A20Room tips
Traveler rating
  • 71
  • 37
  • 13
  • 10
  • 7
Time of year
Traveler type
  • More
Selected filters
  • Filter
  • English
24coffee2017 wrote a review Sep 2021
Hedgesville, West Virginia26 contributions25 helpful votes
The lunch was outstanding and exceeded our expectations. The patio atmosphere was delightful. All the Staff was friendly and professional. We felt they really appreciated our business. We would highly recommend this establishment to everyone.
Read more
Date of stay: September 2021
yourtrainer wrote a review Jun 2021
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania25 contributions24 helpful votes
I visited this restaurant years ago. We sat outside and enjoyed nice cocktails along with apps so I wanted to come back. This time around we got seated in a back dark room, the room was dingy. The table had a large bottle of sanitizer on it which just doesn’t set the mood for fine dining. I ordered the Organic Chicken Paillard Grillé. It was average at best with literally one small potato cut in half with very few green beans. A $36 entree with one mini potato! I wouldn’t recommend this dish, the seafood that was coming out looked a bit better value. After eating at the Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant the night before- which was a spectacular experience (staff, atmosphere, food and drinks) I guess nothing could compare.
Read more
Date of stay: June 2021Trip type: Traveled with friends
ocrabbit wrote a review Mar 2020
Cherry Hill, New Jersey23 contributions12 helpful votes
We had dinner at the American Hotel on February 10 for a birthday visit. It could not have been better. The wine list is amazing, our dinners were wonderful, and the staff was great. We were planning to choose another restaurant, but instead we did our 2nd night dinner at the American Hotel. We were just as happy with our 2nd dinner, the dinner and wine was great. We will be back!
Read more
Date of stay: February 2020Trip type: Traveled as a couple
Robert C wrote a review Sep 2019
Edinburg, Texas814 contributions203 helpful votes
No complaint with the food. The Duck was a large portion cooked just right. The Cesar Salad could have had more anchovies. The bread was to die for. Crispy crusty and just right. Great desert as well. I know we were fine dining, but I still think the restaurant is pricy.
Read more
Date of stay: September 2019
Room Tip: We were here for dinner only. The ambience is fantastic.
See more room tips
DnRtravel wrote a review Sep 2019
8 contributions10 helpful votes
Mmm The Scottish Salmons were perfection and we were indulged with a special vegetarian risotto & a few sides. Our waitress Chloe was a sweetheart. We ate early enough to choose the glass-roofed Atrium with foliage & christmas lights. Ah, don't miss the bar scene & piano man during Autumn! Or the Ladies Room with ancient pull-flush!
Read more
Date of stay: August 2019
1 Helpful vote
american hotel sag harbor
United StatesNew YorkLong IslandHamptonsSag Harbor
Is This Your Tripadvisor Listing?

Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.

Claim Your Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about The American Hotel
Which popular attractions are close to The American Hotel?
Nearby attractions include Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum (0.2 miles), Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts (0.10 miles), and Sag Harbor Marine Park (0.3 miles).
What are some of the property amenities at The American Hotel?
Some of the more popular amenities offered include free wifi, free breakfast, and an on-site restaurant.
Which room amenities are available at The American Hotel?
Top room amenities include a minibar, air conditioning, and a refrigerator.
What food & drink options are available at The American Hotel?
Guests can enjoy free breakfast, an on-site restaurant, and a lounge during their stay.
Is parking available at The American Hotel?
Yes, free public parking nearby is available to guests.
What are some restaurants close to The American Hotel?
Conveniently located restaurants include The American Hotel, Page at 63 Main, and Il Capuccino Ristorante.
Is The American Hotel located near the city center?
Yes, it is 0.01 miles away from the center of Sag Harbor.
Which languages are spoken by the staff at The American Hotel?
The staff speaks multiple languages, including English, Spanish, and Russian.
Are there any historical sites close to The American Hotel?
Many travelers enjoy visiting Shelter Island Historical Society (4.7 miles).