Beautiful location, simple but comfortable rooms, fantastic food and friendly folks -- the owners of this cozy spot will make you feel right at home. There's nothing like having a glass of wine and apple crisp on the deck at sundown while the kids try to coax a hummingbird into landing on their fingers. I hope to make it back soon.
Homey inn at a beautiful setting. Owners are very friendly, feels like you're visiting family. Tasty food, and very relaxed atmosphere. Popular with locals and out of town visitors too. Everything you need for a restful stay.
The place is just beautiful!!! Joe and Marian are your hosts, and they immediately make you feel like family!!! The food in the restaurant is to die for, soooo good!!! The hotel is nice and quaint, nice beds and good atmosphere. So take yourself there and have a great time!!!
My boyfriend and I came to Old Forge for what we thought was going to be a snowmobiling adventure. For years he had been telling me about the Stillwater Hotel and how much fun it is from the amazing views to how awesome it is to just ride the reservoir to get there. We couldn't wait but guess what...NO SNOW!! At first we were disappointed but he was determined to take me here. So we braved the windy dirt road to get there by car. Due to the lack of snow there was also a lack of other guests but that didn't matter one bit. Literally from the moment we arrived we were greeted with the warmth and charm he remembered. Marian and Joe, the owners took amazing care of us. The dinner was delicious right down to the homemade pickled beets! We talked and laughed with them like we…
I stayed at stillwater with my father, and I couldnt ask for a better time! The hospitality was about phenomenal! Its one of those few places on the earth where everyone is absolutely kind and wonderful! Its a great place to have a beer at the bar or enjoy a great piece of prime rib in front of the window looking out at the reservoir! Marian and Joe are wonderful people and make you really feel welcomed along with all of they great employees!