Went there for a Pre-wedding party. There were about 200 people there. The horderves ranged from shrimp to mushrooms stuffed with crabmeat. They were awesome. I had beef for dinner. It was tender, nicely spiced. Mashed potatoes that this Irishman loved. My wife had a Cod fish plate. Cook to perfection and it was fresh. Would go back there in... More 

The inn is situated on 7 acres of land overlooking the fishing village of Menemsha - a glorious view. The free range chickens supply the eggs for the morning breakfast which is wonderful. The turkeys roaming the property are subtle reminders that Ben Franklin wished them to be our national bird. You could not ask for a more lovely setting... More 

The wedding I attended at Beach Plum was probably one of the best I've ever had the pleasure of being present at. The weather, the ambiance, the views, the decor, the service/staff, THE FOOD and the drinks...in short, AMAZING. I felt like I was living in the pages of a bridal magazine! Everything about this place was charming and perfect.... More 

I had the pleasure of spending the 4th of July having dinner in this great restaurant. I remember having ordered lamb and it was delicious! my partner had something different but it was super tasty as well. The view is stunning due to a great window facing the sea and they also offer outdoor seating, it was a bit expensive... More 

We are twice at the Beach Plum this August once with a group of friends and again with our son (who works in hospitality in New York City) and his girlfriend. It was fantastic both times. Interesting menu with what I believe is a new chef this year. If you want a special night out then come to the Beach... More 

My husband and I had a wonderful dinner together on Friday, August 7. Everything about our experience was great--from the table on the deck overlooking the water to the rustic but elegant decor to the beautifully presented food to the excellent (and friendly!) service. We started our meal with raw oysters and tuna crudo and both were top-notch. I had... More 

My wife and I stayed at the Beach plum Inn last summer for two nights. Over the years we had dinner at the restaurant and enjoyed the food and the atmosphere. However, the restaurant was under new management and it was a terrible disappointment. The views as always were spectacular but the service was terrible. The young waitress had such... More 

If you are familiar with the Inn there is something critical that you should know: Car passes to LVB and Squibnocket are no longer included in the rate. LVB is up to $85 and I think Squib is $65. The receptionist explained that the Town of Chilmark asked to take the passes away. This is an incredible shame as most... More 

I have eaten at the Beach Plum many times over the years. It has always been pricey but the ambiance has consistently been good. Over the last couple of years the food has been highly variable in quality. But a meal a week or so ago was spectacularly good. A visiting friend and I both had a main course of... More