We have been going here two to three times a year for a dozen years. It offers everything we want: a pool, beach on a private lagoon, boat ramp and marina basin, fishing pier, deck overlooking Florida Bay/Gulf of Mexico/Everglades National Park with awesome sunsets, a tiki hut and BBQ grills. The rooms seem to be in a constant upgrade with memory foam mattresses the latest addition. Randy and Sarah and their crew are always nearby to help in any way. We just came back from a week with old friends on their first trip and they fell in love immediately and have booked for another week in the fall. We will join them. This place is truly magical.
We couldn’t say enough great things about the resort. There was lots of space for the kids to run and roam safely. The pool was large and always clean as well as beach access to the bay for extra fun. We loved all the places to post up and lounge with a cocktail or good book. The staff and owners were hospitable and involved in making your stay comfortable and enjoyable. We’ve already booked next year!
Coral Bay is a little piece of paradise in the Keys. The quiet, private beach is a perfect place to let your kids run and play. The dock and tiki hut provide the best spot to watch the perfect sunsets!! 10/10 would recommend this place! We come back year after year for the last 30 years and I guarantee you won’t find another gem like this place in the keys. The managers are some of the sweetest and hard working people around. Book your stay ASAP, you won’t regret it!
We stayed in #15. 1 bedroom. First night exhausted after a day of traveling and get ready for bed and pull down blanket and there are live and dead bugs everywhere on sheets and under sheets. ALIVE and crawling!!!!!! on bed, under mattress behind bed on floor. Couldn't get a hold of property manager as I didn't see emergency number on a plastic card and kept calling and emailing main number. My husband had to sleep on a single blow up mattress with our 9 yr old son and I slept on the pull out with my 23 yr. daughter. The manager Randy gave us a refund of 2 nights. Ok well let me tell you what we had to go through on that first night not even that refund was worth it. Felt like bugs were crawling on us everywhere. ugh :( They come next day to clean and well still didn't feel ok with it. NO other rooms available. Entire next day exhausted as none of us slept good. Fast forward to a couple days later we come in after dinner out and again exhausted after a day in the sun and pool and go back to the room and it is COMPLETELY FLOODED in the bathroom about 1/4 inch of water and seeped into the bedroom. Now it is 11 p.m. my son is tired and falls asleep and property manager comes ar 11:30 and tells us cannot be an easy fix we have to move to another room for the night. We have to wake up our son and move across the street to #5 while all our stuff is still in #15. It is now midnight and the TV in #5 goes off and on ALL night long. When is this nightmare going to stop is all we thought to ourselves. Our son is a Type 1 Diabetic and at 3 am I had to walk back to #15 because his sugar went low to get him juice. The next day we went back to #15 because that is where all our stuff was and had to walk back and forth to #5 to use the bathroom until after noon the next day. Talk about a complete and utter inconvenience. We were told we would receive a refund for this night ALSO and nope he called me and told me we would receive nothing for this night which is so unacceptable I cannot even put into words. There are small holes at both the front and back door and assuming that is how the lizards are getting into the place. Florida has them I get that alot of them but when you keep seeing them in the your place after you caught them and threw them out just another terrible inconvenience. One was behind the toaster and literally jumped out and almost gave me a heart attack. There are window air conditioners and at night place is comfortable but during the day they cannot keep up and place cannot get below 75 and sometimes even higher. It is with a heavy heart writing this review I don't usually do this but I felt I need to warn people and I would want to read the same if I were looking to stay here. Our trip was literally ruined too many sleepless nights and when you spend the money we did all you want is peace quiet and relaxation which didn't happen here this time for our stay. We will never go back again.…
Quiet and low key vibe. Near all you could need in Islamorada. Great place to stay n not have to leave, pool and lagoon beach, also dock and ramp for boaters. Plenty of room to enjoy without being on top of other guests if you want quiet. Did not want to leave. Highly recommend if looking for peaceful and all accommodating old school Florida Keys vibe. I will be back! ☀️🦎🌅