The hotel is beautiful. Clean and newly renovated. I recommend the ocean front suite. Well worth the extra money to truly enjoy your stay to the max. The staff is great and the front office manager was in the lobby talking to guests with the general manager. Ensuring that all were enjoying my their stay

We just stayed here for a one night getaway and we had an amazing time. The room was beautiful and the view simply spectacular. The service was excellent from each person we encountered. Special thanks to Anette for helping us out on our departure day! Highly recommend this place!!

The Keys are always a great place to visit and this hotel has a great location in and around several good places to eat and play. Enjoyed the staff's attention to detail and overall hospitality. Will return!

Lovely, clean, sleak and beach-ey renovation and great location. A good choice if you don't want the crowds of Key West or big hotels and want something a little quieter- but still with all the trimmings and modernity.

Beautiful rooms , comfy beds , great pillows and the service was awesome. The general manager Cara was extremely generous. Dave the concierge was friendly and helpful. If your looking for a place to kick back and relax stay here.

Stayed in a king size room which is small but looks just like the pictures. If you're in the Keys it's likely you'll be out on the water most of the day and will welcome the laid back vibe of the resort when you return. We enjoyed the in room robes, Keurig and mini fridge in the room. There is... More 

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at Amara Cay. From the moment that we entered the building, we felt welcomed and felt like the staff at the hotel really wanted us to be staying there. I stay in around 50 different hotels a year and the staff really made us feel special from having our keys ready upon check-in, acknowledging our... More 

Just to be clear we never stayed here only had a meeting room but the resort looks very nice almost brand new. We rented a meeting room and I must say the chairs provided to us are simply not good enough, you can see the photo. Almost like a baby chair. Otherwise service was good and that goes for the... More 

My husband and I decided to celebrate our anniversary in the Florida Keys. I found Amara Cay on the internet. I liked what I read on their site, and the photos were the "hook" that reeled me in. We spent four very lovely, relaxing days there. The full hot breakfasts on-site were fantastic, and they were complimentary. Amenities: Swimming pool... More