We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Find the best flight to Shelter Island

Find flights

Compare prices (in new window)
    Select all
Cheap flights to Shelter Island, NYrecently found by travelers *
Washington DC
WAS
New Haven
HVN
$106
United Airlines
Sat, 8/25 - Mon, 8/27
$106
Myrtle Beach
MYR
New Haven
HVN
$114
Spirit Airlines
Tue, 7/24 - Wed, 8/8
$114
Orlando
ORL
New Haven
HVN
$114
Spirit Airlines
Thu, 7/5 - Thu, 7/12
$114
Chicago
CHI
New Haven
HVN
$126
Frontier Airlines
Mon, 8/20 - Wed, 8/29
$126
Fort Lauderdale
FLL
New Haven
HVN
$132
Spirit Airlines
Thu, 8/23 - Sun, 8/26
$132
San Juan
SJU
New Haven
HVN
$145
Frontier Airlines
Fri, 7/20 - Thu, 7/26
$145
Atlanta
ATL
New Haven
HVN
$166
Frontier Airlines
Fri, 7/27 - Mon, 7/30
$166
Raleigh
RDU
New Haven
HVN
$180
American Airlines
Tue, 7/24 - Wed, 7/25
$180
Detroit
DTT
New Haven
HVN
$213
United Airlines
Thu, 10/25 - Sat, 10/27
$213
Cincinnati
CVG
New Haven
HVN
$215
United Airlines
Sat, 8/11 - Tue, 8/14
$215
* Prices are based on round trip travel with returns between 1-21 days after departure. These are the best fares found by travelers who searched TripAdvisor and a select group of our fare search partners in the past 72 hours. Ticket prices and seat availability change rapidly and cannot be guaranteed.
Hotels with great views in Shelter Island
The Stirling House
The Stirling House
266 Reviews
Greenport, NY
from
Harborfront Inn at Greenport
Harborfront Inn at Greenport
309 Reviews
Greenport, NY
from
House on Chase Creek
House on Chase Creek
122 Reviews
Shelter Island, NY
from
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin Hotel
242 Reviews
Shelter Island, NY
from
Flight stats for Shelter Island - did you know?
  • Shelter Island is 32 mi from New Haven Airport (New Haven, CT).
  • New Haven Airport (New Haven, CT)
    • Every week, at least 11 domestic flights and 0 international flights depart from New Haven Airport.
Show more