We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
  • Sorted by: Ranking
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results in neighboring cities.
Limit search to Shelter Island.
Sailacat Boat Charters Sag Harbor 4.5 mi away
#1 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
We loved the entire tour and made our bride to be extremely happy, rested and sun-kissed.
They were well equipped with water sports, music, and tour-guide info for the whole trip.
Shelter Island Kayak
#1 of 3 Tours in Shelter Island
We were able to make a same-day reservation on a spectacular day and Jay led an amazing tour of the local area (Coecles Inlet) pointing out nesting Osprey, turtles, jelly fish and local landmarks/lore.
My Wife and I enjoyed a beautiful and energetic tour with Jay today.
Venture Out Shelter Island Paddle Board Rentals Shelter Island Heights
#1 of 1 Tours in Shelter Island Heights
Vintage Tours Greenport, NY 7.7 mi away
#1 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Vineyards: The four vineyards selected were perfect based on the feedback provided to Jo-Ann from our small group of 4. Unlike other tours that simply drop you off and pick you up, Jo-Ann provided the history and...
If you want to feel like you are touring the North Fork's wine country with an extremely knowledgeable, warm and caring family member, then take Jo-Ann Perry's Vintage Tours!
Fish North Fork Southold, NY 4.6 mi away
#1 of 4 Tours in Southold
GLORY Greenport, NY 3.2 mi away
#2 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Glory and her captain have been running these solar powered tours for over 20 years and I am glad that I have had the opportunity to head out for the past 5 years.
Really enjoyed our ride around the bay, we had 3 children with us, Captain Dave was excellent with the kids, gave them a little treat and certificates at the end of tour.
Sag Harbor Charters Sag Harbor 4.4 mi away
#2 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
My husband and I had the pleasure of taking our children and grandson on a tour of Sag Harbor Bay and Around Shelter Island with Captain Hagen recently.
But even I learned some interesting new facts with Captain Hagen on our three hour tour around Sag Harbor and Shelter Island.
Peconic Water Sports Southold, NY 3.9 mi away
#2 of 4 Tours in Southold
Shelter Island Tours & Transportation
#3 of 3 Tours in Shelter Island
Loved Jim and our tour he set up for a bachelorette party!
Jim was recommended as the “go to” guy for a top-notch wine tour...
North Fork Wine Tours Greenport, NY 3.8 mi away
#3 of 12 Tours in Greenport
We decided to do a wine tour day with North Fork Wine Tours and everything worked out great.
Michael was great at helping me plan my birthday wine tour.
American Beauty Cruises & Charters Sag Harbor 4.4 mi away
#3 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
I highly recommend taking a tour during your time in Sag Harbor!
The whole ninety minute tour was a nature lover's delight.
North Fork Adventures Charters Southold, NY 3.9 mi away
#3 of 4 Tours in Southold
Peconic Cruise Line Greenport, NY 3.3 mi away
#4 of 12 Tours in Greenport
One of the few water tours that are actually affordable.
Wonderful time the boat was comfortable and the tour guide/captain was great .
Sail-Works Branford, CT 4.3 mi away
#4 of 5 Tours in Branford
Our over night in Sag Harber was spent at a local Pub followed by a tour of the town.
Dove Sailing Charters Sag Harbor 4.5 mi away
#4 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Eagle's Neck Paddling Company Southold, NY 4.2 mi away
#4 of 4 Tours in Southold
East End Charters Llc Greenport, NY 3.7 mi away
#5 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Sag Harbor Sailing Sag Harbor 4.6 mi away
#5 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Virgin Star Sailing Adventures Greenport, NY 3.2 mi away
#6 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Sea Escapes Sag Harbor Sag Harbor 4.3 mi away
#6 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
I am a big believer in private tours and trips when we travel and my boys will tell you that i have been "mostly" successful with a few minor misses over the years.
We enjoyed an amazing afternoon tour with him on his beautiful sailboat.
Wine Tour New York Greenport, NY 4.0 mi away
#7 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Tammy's tour has everything included (tastings, visits, wineries tours, lunch, tips...) -- where other companies don't.
If you're looking for a wine tour on Eastern Long Island, I highly recommend Wine Tours NY with Tammy Natalia!
Starlight Sailing Charters - Day Cruise Sag Harbor 4.4 mi away
#7 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Peconic Star Fleet Greenport, NY 3.3 mi away
#8 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Valkyrie Sailing Charters Sag Harbor 4.3 mi away
#9 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Shaka Flyboarding Greenport, NY 3.3 mi away
#9 of 12 Tours in Greenport
Peconic Water Sports Sag Harbor 4.8 mi away
#10 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor
Hamptons Boat Rental Sag Harbor 4.5 mi away
#11 of 14 Tours in Sag Harbor