We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
  • Sort by:
  • Ranking
  • Book Online
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results in neighboring cities.
Limit search to Shelter Island.
Antique Carousel Greenport, NY 3.3 mi away
#1 of 26 things to do in Greenport
#1 of 2 things to do in Shelter Island Heights
Greenport Harbor Brewing Co. Greenport, NY 3.4 mi away
#4 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Lavender By The Bay East Marion, NY 4.3 mi away
#1 of 2 things to do in East Marion
Kontokosta Winery Greenport, NY 4.2 mi away
#3 of 26 things to do in Greenport
The Old Field Vineyards Southold, NY 4.4 mi away
#2 of 25 things to do in Southold
Sparkling Pointe Southold, NY 6.2 mi away
#1 of 25 things to do in Southold
North Haven Village Park Sag Harbor 2.3 mi away
#9 of 23 things to do in Sag Harbor
Fireboat Firefighter Museum Greenport, NY 3.4 mi away
#7 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Bay Street Theatre Sag Harbor 4.4 mi away
#2 of 23 things to do in Sag Harbor
Sannino Vineyard Peconic, NY 7.0 mi away
#1 of 11 things to do in Peconic
East End Seaport Maritime Museum Greenport, NY 3.6 mi away
#6 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Foster Memorial Beach Sag Harbor 4.4 mi away
#3 of 23 things to do in Sag Harbor
Railroad Museum of Long Island Greenport, NY 3.3 mi away
#9 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Nova Constellatio Gallery Greenport, NY 3.4 mi away
#10 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Congregation Tifereth Israel Greenport, NY 3.4 mi away
#11 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Greenport Farmers' Market, Inc. Greenport, NY 3.9 mi away
#8 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Camera Obscura Greenport, NY 3.4 mi away
#12 of 26 things to do in Greenport
Southold Bay Oysters Southold, NY 3.9 mi away
#8 of 25 things to do in Southold
1 Way to experience it
#4 of 23 things to do in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor Marine Park Sag Harbor 4.6 mi away
#5 of 23 things to do in Sag Harbor
1 Way to experience it