If you are growing wary of the Plaka and the repeat of cheap tourist items, Amorgos is an oasis. From the outside it is both intriguing and imposing. My cousin and I were worried it would be too pricey, but we each bought very meaningful and reasonably priced unique gifts for friends there. I particularly enjoyed the hand-painted puppets and punched tin good luck trinkets. You cannot take photos inside though. (They wouldn’t do the shop justice anyway!)