We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

New Horizon Creamery

5 Reviews
Sorry, there are no tours or activities available to book online for the date(s) you selected. Please choose a different date.

New Horizon Creamery

5 Reviews
Sorry, there are no tours or activities available to book online for the date(s) you selected. Please choose a different date.
Full view
Location
Contact
45 State Route 244, Coudersport, PA 16915-7908
Best nearby
0Restaurantswithin 5 miles
1Other Attractionwithin 5 miles
5Reviews0Q&A
Traveler rating
  • 4
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 1
Traveler type
Time of year
Language
Selected filters
  • Filter
  • English
Popular mentions
Heidi B wrote a review Dec 2020
2 contributions
The Thursday night buffet is spot on. All types of pizza to try- my favorite is the taco pizza and buffalo chicken and of course the ice cream:) Lots of flavors to choose from and try. After eating, they have a small farm with chickens, donkeys and Alpaca's to pet or look at. Great family friendly place!
Read more
Date of experience: February 2020
Helpful
Share
Jack Miller wrote a review Aug 2020
Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania3 contributions1 helpful vote
Went for some Ice Cream with my family, expecting mandatory masking as they stated they were requiring masks on their Facebook, was not amused to find the place was unsanitary by normal standards. Lady serving the Ice Cream had no mask, gloves, or hairnet. Didn't even bother to cover her mouth when she coughed. No other customers had masks and the only sort of COVID warning was a feeble 6-foot social distancing sign out front, that was not enforced or clarified in any way. (ie: Markers spaced 6ft apart.) The Ice Cream was amazing, but not worth the horrible precautions. I felt uncomfortable during the entire visit. If you are expecting good COVID precautions, do not come here.
Read more
Date of experience: August 2020
Helpful
Share
Pierre19666 wrote a review Aug 2017
29 contributions23 helpful votes
Just north of Coudersport, this is a nice little ice cream shop where they hand make all of their ice cream. If your lucky the owner can give you a tour of his process and you can visit the animals in the barn too. Overall a great experience. Did I mention they make the icre cream from the milk of their own cows? you they sure do. Go visit.
Read more
Date of experience: July 2017
Helpful
Share
geribrabham wrote a review Feb 2017
smethport23 contributions4 helpful votes
Fresh homemade dairy products. I love their ice cream and milk shakes. I have never had bad cheese or ice cream from New Horizon. They also have a nice pizza buffet every other Thursday, great value for $10!
Read more
Date of experience: August 2016
Helpful
Share
Helen M wrote a review Aug 2016
1 contribution2 helpful votes
Great place to eat , My whole family just love going to eat there, and to be able to see the cows. And rent there cabin's .we love their homemade ice cream .and Pizzas and everything else that they sale, they are a wonderful family Business. And their employees are so wonderful and helping in any way they can.I gave them 5 star's .
Read more
Date of experience: August 2016
Helpful
Share
Frequently Asked Questions about New Horizon Creamery