Bannerman Castle
Bannerman Castle
4.5
Full view
What is Travelers’ Choice?
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
Top ways to experience nearby attractions
The area
Address
Reach out directly
Best nearby
Restaurants
192 within 3 miles
Attractions
113 within 6 miles
See what travelers are saying
- Cam C1 contributionperfect sunday afternoonthis experience exceeded our expectations — the lovely boat ride leads into a tour that is the perfect length to be informative, but not to get boring. however to set your expectations, most of the ruins are off limits. the free time to roam the island is a lovely walk through gardens and lush greenery (bring a snack and wear your hiking shoes!) accompanied by gorgeous river views. the staff are friendly and knowledgable, and it's clear they have a passion for what they do. I hope to return soon!Visited September 2023Traveled as a coupleWritten September 11, 2023
- Victoria WGranville, New York15 contributionsPerfect dayMy friend and I went on the 3:30pm cruise to the island. It was a beautiful day, couldn’t have been more perfect. We had a wonderful tour guide on the island, Elizabeth. If you have ever been curious about the “castle” in the Hudson River, this is a great way to see it.Visited September 2023Traveled with friendsWritten September 19, 2023
- Robert MSchenectady, New York120 contributionsMedical Times on the HudsonWonderful experience. Clean boat with good guide and captain. Tour on the island was perfect - lots of history and just the right time “on your own”. A unique history of the Hudson Valley that was well worth the trip.Visited September 2023Traveled as a coupleWritten September 19, 2023
- 4ad2017Denver, Colorado32 contributionsYou should go!Really enjoyed this day trip from New Jersey! I can’t really say anything new or different than the other reviews in here: nice people, nice overview, nice amount of time, beautiful everything! And I went on a rainy Sunday afternoon! Would do again! Would take friends! You should go!Visited September 2023Traveled soloWritten September 27, 2023
- bridget b16 contributionsWhat a great day!I’ve been wanting to visit Bannerman Castle, since I passed it heading upstate on Amtrak. What a very cool place! The castle, the gardens, the views. The men on the ferry ride were very informative and what’s not to like about a ferry ride. I do have to give kudos to them. Before we were getting on the ferry, there was a 911 boating emergency a few hundred yards off the dock. They zipped out there and helped rescue a little sailboat that was sinking. Good guys. Our tour guide, Mary, was also wonderful. Very informative and knew all of the history of the castle and the area. It was a great day!Visited October 2023Traveled with friendsWritten October 2, 2023
- tilefish6 contributionslife long dream to visit.nice boat ride, great narrative on the way to the island, friendly staff, great narrative from Mary, wonderful views, great paths. wish we had packed a lunch, great place to have one. little disappointed that you can not get close to the ruins, but did understand why. Great short day trip.Visited October 2023Traveled with friendsWritten October 10, 2023
- Helen PGoshen, New York52 contributionsPerfect day tripGreat trip , the boat dock is directly across from the Beacon train station , parking and access was fine . The boat trip is short but nice , includes a bit of information about places passed in Newburgh and surrounding areas. The island was small and easy to travel , yes, there are steps but they are regular steps with rails nothing to worry about. The tour guide Mary was really informative and interesting and clearly loves her job. The tour was well done, time was available for some self exploration and then the ride back . I did not know what to expect but was more then happily surprised with the day - hoping to see more of the castle preserved in the future - it’s a gem .Visited October 2023Traveled with familyWritten October 29, 2023
- Lisa M7 contributionsBannerman Island Boat Tour a great addition to any day in Beacon.Highly recommend this excursion when in the Beacon area. The boat ride was lovely and the staff on board were not only knowledgeable but also fun! The staff giving the tour of Bannerman Castle were equally knowledgeable and gave an excellent tour. The amount of time to explore the island after the talk was perfect too!Visited October 2023Traveled with friendsWritten October 29, 2023
- Linda D1 contributionExploring Bannerman IslandTour guide Mark was highly knowledgeable and friendly. The castle ruins and the story behind them were fascinating. The best part is, they give you about 45 minutes to explore the island along its trails.Visited May 2024Traveled with familyWritten May 4, 2024
- Steven HCarmel, New York10 contributionsWell worth the visit!Looking for something different to do? Go see Bannerman's Castle, you won't regret it. Once you get over the 72 steps it's smooth sailing. Most probably going to make the trip again since we took the tour and would like to explore on our own next time. Great job by the volunteers.Visited May 2024Traveled with familyWritten May 14, 2024
These reviews are the subjective opinion of Tripadvisor members and not of TripAdvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Contribute
Most Recent: Reviews ordered by most recent publish date in descending order.
Detailed Reviews: Reviews ordered by recency and descriptiveness of user-identified themes such as wait time, length of visit, general tips, and location information.
Popular mentions
4.5
280 reviews
Excellent
212
Very good
46
Average
9
Poor
9
Terrible
5
David Pasteelnick
10 contributions
Jul 2023
While the real culprit was the weather, it was still a great disappointment that our scheduled tour was canceled at the last minute due to potential inclement conditions. My party of 9 family members was very much looking forward to this. Even though we had booked the tour for a Sunday and were in Beacon for the entire following week, they could not accommodate us for another daytime tour, which is what we had paid for. We received a voucher but there is really no way that I can get all my family members (who live in various places across the East Coast) back again to make use of this voucher so we've essentially lost $400+ as there are no refunds. And again, while I can't directly blame the staff, the feared inclement weather never actually materialized and we probably could have had the tour after all. Just a real disappointment.
Written July 24, 2023
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Lauren V
45 contributions
Jul 2022 • Family
I wouldn’t call this a tour. More so a lecture. The boat ride was on time and smooth. When we got to the island they separated the group into 2 groups. Our group walked to a secluded area and the tour guide just spoke to us for about 30 mins straight about the history of the island. The history was interesting but we got conflicting “facts”. She told us that the kids had to be taken to school on sleds over the frozen river in the winter but then at another point told us the people only used the island in the summer time. After the lecture you have about 30 mins to explore the island which isn’t very big. No access near the ruins.
Written July 17, 2022
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Clare-Marie Panno
South Salem, NY22 contributions
Oct 2020
Enjoyed this half day excursion from Beacon to Bannerman Island. Gorgeous views, recommend doing this trip in the fall, short hike up (has stairs and railings) and appreciated hearing the interesting history though this was a self-guided tour. What vision the Bannerman had! Restoration will be fun to watch now that I know about this gem. Stroll Beacon’s art galleries, loved @beachglass and restaurants (though not gluten free friendly) after the Bannerman Island visit. Covid precautions present everywhere.
Written October 19, 2020
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Simon H
1 contribution
Jun 2021
We thought the tour of Bannerman Castle was pretty cool. If you’re a history buff, or have an interest in firearms and military surplus, you will enjoy the tour. It seems like the Bannermans started the whole concept of selling military surplus. There are also interesting stories to here about the history of the island and the families who linked and worked there. Lastly, you will get to see some gorgeous views. We highly recommend the tour.
Written June 27, 2021
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
lorip713
Freehold, NJ49 contributions
Jul 2023 • Friends
I read through the bad reviews and these people did not take the same tour my daughter and I did yesterday. We had a wonderful, very knowledgeable, tour guide (Margaret) who has been giving tours there for 20 years. The first mate on the boat told us what all the building we were passing were and some history of the area. There was a snack bar on the island to purchase souvenirs, snacks and water/soda. Plenty of opportunities to take pictures. Lovely gardens. Clean bathrooms. I was originally scheduled to go 2 weeks earlier but called because I was in the hospital and the owner graciously issued me a gift card to reschedule for another day. He didn’t have to, his website clearly says no cancellations. He also cannot control the weather just like a pro sports game or any outdoor event that won’t refund your money. Check the weather and be prepared. That’s on YOU! We had a great time and would return. There is also a food truck in the parking lot where you get onto the boat. If not, Sal’s Pizza is nearby and the pizza and knots are very good.
Written July 30, 2023
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Jeanette G
1 contribution
Jun 2023 • Friends
It was lovely to be able to visit this island and our tour guide was very friendly and seemed to know plenty of the history however the time alloted for the tour is extremely short. You're told it's a 2.5 hour tour but that is very misleading because they include the 30 min to and from the island as part of it. By the time you make it to the residence which is a self guided tour museum you only have a few minutes to look around before you are ushered back to the boat for the next tour coming in. The tour guide we were assigned, I think also made poor use of the time we had. Although very nice and knowledgeable, she took a little too long in the stops we did make. First she had us stop.for a while by the steps coming up from the boat to give us a history lesson on the name of the island which is great to know but could have been explained as we walked. We also went to our first stop only to back track the same way we came to our second stop to once again back track once again to where our first stop was. It wasn't a very efficient way to conduct the tour and use of our time. At the second stop she just lingered for so long. I think she could have walked us along and continued her history lesson to allow us more time to see and explore. Our tour never got the chance to explore any of the open areas open to the public on the islands after the tour guide was done because their was no time. I had to rush through two thirds of the very small museum because we just had to go. I understand from the tour guide that they were asked to shorten the tours sometime ago. I also understand that there is only a single boat that seats 44 people to and from the island. I am sure they are trying to maximize on however many tours they can squeeze in a day to help with funds for the Bannerman Trust but it's also unfair not to have an opportunity to really be able to explore the museum and island. The island itself is lovely and seeing part of the remaining castle was also enjoyable but for all the reasons above I rated my visit a 3. My hope is that they extend the allocated tour time a bit and have the tour guides develop a strategy to use the time more efficiently.
Written June 18, 2023
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Curious New Yorker
5 contributions
Jul 2022
Overall, an enjoyable experience. We learned a lot of interesting things about the history of the place from Adam who was truly excellent as a guide/docent. However, I agree with other reviewers that it was not quite a “tour.” Of the 1.5 h or so we had on the island, almost 60m was spent on an extended history lecture by Adam and less than 30 min on exploring the island and the grounds on our own. I wish we had at least 45-50 mins for exploration of the grounds, and much less time spent on the history presentation. On the boat, the captain/associate captain tried to give us some additional information about the area, but we couldn’t hear anything because they didn’t use a microphone. So that part was rather useless. My suggestion would be to move at least 15 min of Adam’s (or other guides’) materials to the boat ride (using a proper microphone), and then break the rest of the lecture/presentation into 2 pods of 15 min at 2 different locations: one inside the residence and the other in front of the arsenal, so that we can have a fuller narrated experience of the whole site. I also thought that it was too much to ask us to be there 30 min early, just to have us wait 15+ min under the sun to get checked in. Arriving 15-20 min early should be more than enough for a timely departure.
Written July 19, 2022
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Eyst p
1 contribution
Sep 2022
the Dracula play at Bannerman island was a good idea, especially this fall season, the actors were great BUT it fall flat ! starting with :
1) the email stated to arrive by 5:30 at the docks to take the ferry boat ride to the island for a 7pm show.
they ( at the docks ) say this was a mistake. Some people were taken on the ferry at 6pm , why they got chosen first, I don't know.
the rest of us had to wait till 6:48pm to get on the ferry. SO from 5:30- 6:48pm we waited!
2) when we finally got to the island we had to climb 3 flights of stairs ( No where did it said it was not handicap accessible.
3) of course the people on the first ferry ride got the best seats, my husband was not able to see the stage very well.
4) the lighting and sound settings where horrible, we sat in front of one of the speakers.
Did I mention it was our Anniversary !!
I wanted a special treat for my husband and it was a bust. For $62.50 a ticket, I expected a better set up and I was very disappointed.
1) the email stated to arrive by 5:30 at the docks to take the ferry boat ride to the island for a 7pm show.
they ( at the docks ) say this was a mistake. Some people were taken on the ferry at 6pm , why they got chosen first, I don't know.
the rest of us had to wait till 6:48pm to get on the ferry. SO from 5:30- 6:48pm we waited!
2) when we finally got to the island we had to climb 3 flights of stairs ( No where did it said it was not handicap accessible.
3) of course the people on the first ferry ride got the best seats, my husband was not able to see the stage very well.
4) the lighting and sound settings where horrible, we sat in front of one of the speakers.
Did I mention it was our Anniversary !!
I wanted a special treat for my husband and it was a bust. For $62.50 a ticket, I expected a better set up and I was very disappointed.
Written September 17, 2022
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Open Toe
5 contributions
May 2021
Very much a let down. No one paid attention to this site until 1993, and 2 of it's the walls of Bannerman Castle have already fallen. We took a boat from Beacon as part of a tour. Guide on the boat only spoke to people who asked questions, instead of sharing the great trivia of the hudson valley to all passengers. Tour guide at the actual castle location was great, sharing the history of the person who built this "castle" which was just an armory to hold his cache of weapons from being an international arms dealer. Good place to take pics. This whole trip could be much better, especially for the amount of money they charge.
Written June 1, 2021
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Jay C
3 contributions
Sep 2022 • Friends
Saw photos of this place and expected a lot more for the price. $40 is too much money for the quality of the tour. You take a boat to the island. Climb up a series of steps and the tour guide walks you to two spots and talks for about an hour. You can’t actually go to the castle structure. And after the lecture there isn’t much time to explore the island. The experience should cost like $20-$25, not $40
Written September 4, 2022
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Is this trip appropriate for a 1 year old ?
Written July 11, 2019
On our visit it was all adults. If an adult could hold your child’s hand or carry your child it should be ok. Might be best to call the Castle for their opinion.
Written July 11, 2019
What's the best way to book a tour to Bannerman Castle? From their website? I also saw a MTA deal says to call to make a reservation then buy the package deal from any metro north ticket vending machine. Has anyone tries that?
Written October 17, 2018
hello
is this property open and free for public viewing?
how do you get there by car?
Written October 2, 2017
No, it is owned by New York State but operated by a private trust. It is only available by private tour, it is $35. You can park at the beacon train station and take the ferry which is part of the tour.
Written October 3, 2017
So sorry I just saw this now...actually it isn't handicap accessible..there also is a lot of slight uphill climbing...there are tree roots to look out for too...hope that helps
Written September 9, 2017
Free tours? Free Parking? How to you get there if youre driving?
Written July 1, 2017
Ara L
White Plains, New York
How much per adult and kids under 12yrs of age?
How long is the tour, and what times are available on a sunday?
Written May 8, 2015
It is a 2 1/2 hour excursion, kids are 11 and under so you would have to pay adult prices. The cost of the tour is $35 per adult.Saturday and Sunday at 11:00am and from the Beacon, NY ferry dock each Saturday and Sunday at 12:30pm are the times. If you want you can call ahead to make a reservation call Zerve at: 845 834-4200 locally or Toll Free at 855 256-4007.
Written July 9, 2015
This is not a hotel, this is a historic site and tour. It's an old abandoned castle on an island and in it's current state it cannot be slept in. They are working on restoring so maybe one day. The tour was $40 when i took it. They are closed in winter. The Roundhouse at Beacon Falls is a hotel option in the area (845) 765-8369 as is the Swann Inn at Beacon (845) 831-6346 and the Quality Inn which is the next town Fishkill (845) 897-9300. It's recommended to use a car service from Newark rather than a taxi. charges $44. Tolls will add ~ $10 and a tip of 15-20% of the base fare will make the trip in a regular sedan cost ~ $60-65. Prices could have increased since the last time I went. You can call and give an estimate.
Written January 12, 2015
Showing results 1-9 of 9
Is this your Tripadvisor listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim your listing