We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Anguilla
Log in Join
More
    Help Center

    Scilly Cay

    161 Reviews
    #2 of 5 things to do in Island Harbour
    Islands, Nature & Parks
    Island Harbour, Anguilla
    +1 264-497-5123
    Website
    Save
    All photos (92)
    Full view
    Certificate of Excellence
    Review Highlights
    “Scilly Cay / Anguilla”

    This restaurant welcomes you to an idylic and famous setting; they propose a varied menu... read more

    Reviewed December 16, 2017
    Manuela L
    ,
    Luxembourg City, Luxembourg
    “20 Minutes on Scilly Cay”

    We told the folks at our hotel (Zemi) that we were looking for a beach with shallow water where... read more

    Reviewed August 20, 2017
    Lisa B
    Read all 161 reviews
    Map
    Satellite
    Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
    Reset zoom
    Overview
    More
    Scilly Cay Anguilla is a family owned and operated restaurant/private island that has been open for 32 years. We are an offshore cay located on the eastern part of Anguilla. We are open for lunch on Wednesdays (with DJ) and Sundays (with live reggae band) from noon til 5. Serving lobster, crayfish (indigenous to Anguilla), chicken and fish (catch of the day). We are famous for our lobster and our potent rum punches. Also available for private events (both day and night).

    About Scilly Cay

    Scilly Cay Anguilla is a family owned and operated restaurant/private island that has been open for 32 years. We are an offshore cay located on the eastern part of Anguilla. We are open for lunch on Wednesdays (with DJ) and Sundays (with live reggae band) from noon til 5. Serving lobster, crayfish (indigenous to Anguilla), chicken and fish (catch of the day). We are famous for our lobster and our potent rum punches. Also available for private events (both day and night).
    4.0
    161 reviews
    • Excellent55%
    • Very good14%
    • Average13%
    • Poor5%
    • Terrible13%
    Travelers talk about
    “lobster” (68 reviews)
    “chicken” (39 reviews)
    “rum punch” (46 reviews)
    Closed
    Hours
    Hours Today: Closed
    Suggested Duration: More than 3 hours
    LOCATION
    Island Harbour, Anguilla
    CONTACT
    Website
    +1 264-497-5123
    Improve This Listing
    Write a ReviewReviews (161)
    Traveler rating
    Traveler type
    Time of year
    Language
    • More languages
    All reviews
    "lobster"
    in 68 reviews
    "chicken"
    in 39 reviews
    "rum punch"
    in 46 reviews
    "lounge chairs"
    in 6 reviews
    "hermit crabs"
    in 4 reviews
    "private island"
    in 4 reviews
    "a lot of fun"
    in 4 reviews
    "fun afternoon"
    in 2 reviews
    "spent the afternoon"
    in 2 reviews
    "great lunch"
    in 2 reviews
    "worth the trip"
    in 2 reviews
    "island feel"
    in 2 reviews
    "great hosts"
    in 2 reviews
    "toes in the sand"
    in 2 reviews
    "beautiful beach"
    in 3 reviews
    "sandra"
    in 16 reviews
    "wednesday"
    in 11 reviews
    Filter

    1 - 10 of 155 reviews

    Reviewed December 16, 2017
    Scilly Cay / Anguilla

    This restaurant welcomes you to an idylic and famous setting; they propose a varied menu; speciality is fresh seafood, fresh lobster; After the meal dont' forget to go down to the nice beach for a romantc and relaxing walk on a beautiful beach.

    Ask Manuela L about Scilly Cay
    Thank Manuela L
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed August 20, 2017
    20 Minutes on Scilly Cay

    We told the folks at our hotel (Zemi) that we were looking for a beach with shallow water where we'd be able to walk out for a distance. They recommended Scilly Cay. They warned us about the strong rum punch (which other reviews have mentioned),...More

    Ask Lisa B about Scilly Cay
    2  Thank Lisa B
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed August 16, 2017
    Great relaxation, great lunch

    We always include Anguilla as a nice day trip when we're in St.Maarten, and we regularly chose Scilly Cay for lunch. Is the lobster lunch expensive? At $75 I don't think so. They're huge, tasty (and freshly caught -- it is across from a fishing...More

    Ask GJNOttawa about Scilly Cay
    Thank GJNOttawa
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    See more reviews
    Reviewed August 7, 2017
    A must do when visiting the island!

    This is our 3rd time here--and we will go again when we visit next. Just a great place to enjoy great food, good drinks and a fun atmosphere. Make no mistake, it can be pricey, but well worth it. The chicken and lobster were awesome!

    Ask Larry B about Scilly Cay
    Thank Larry B
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed July 25, 2017 via mobile
    Not worth the price

    I was really disappointed in Scilly Cay. The place wasn't clean. There were plastic cups littered around, the lounge chairs need to be fixed, and our table was dirty. The food is very expensive!

    Ask Krnorgaard about Scilly Cay
    Thank Krnorgaard
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed July 21, 2017
    Great Lobster!

    My partner and I just returned from our trip to the Caribbean. It always includes a trip to Scilly Cay for great rum punch and fantastic freshly cooked lobster. It is a relaxing beach hut atmosphere with friendly people and good food. Get there a...More

    Ask TonyWestenbroek about Scilly Cay
    1  Thank TonyWestenbroek
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed July 6, 2017 via mobile
    Memory

    We visited here a few years ago. A day on Scilly Cay was magical. Felt like we had our own island. The rum punch packed one! They served only two choices for lunch with sides, lobster or chicken. We did one of each. It was...More

    Ask TROWE39850 about Scilly Cay
    3  Thank TROWE39850
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed July 5, 2017
    We had a great time as always!

    My wife and I spent the afternoon at Scilly Cay during our recent visit to Anguilla, as we do every time we visit the island (see my previous reviews). This time we went with another couple, and were joined later by some of their local...More

    Ask DeeEss about Scilly Cay
    3  Thank DeeEss
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed June 30, 2017
    Biggest Rip off on Anguilla

    terrible, we ended up with a frozen chicken which was not well cooked and a terrible lobster which was so overpriced, you can go for the same price or less to the Four Seasons for dinner. Please Do Not Go. THEY WILL MAKE YOU DRUNK...More

    Ask JenArkisson about Scilly Cay
    1  Thank JenArkisson
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    Reviewed June 18, 2017 via mobile
    Rustic and cool

    What a little gem... this place is authentic island cool.. We had lobster and cray fish and roast chicken.. tasty and served with extra strong run! The water is spectacular around the island.. Go, relax and enjoy!!More

    Ask miak008 about Scilly Cay
    1  Thank miak008
    This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    ScillyCayAnguilla, Owner at Scilly Cay, responded to this reviewResponded June 20, 2017

    Hi Miak008, we are happy to hear you had a great time on your recent visit to Scilly Cay. We are delighted you enjoyed spending time on the island, while you feasted on our famous grilled lobster and chicken! We look forward to seeing you...More

    Report response as inappropriate
    This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
    123456…16
    Nearby
    Nearby HotelsSee all 31 hotels in Anguilla
    Arawak Beach Inn
    123 reviews
    .19 miles away
    Wesley House
    11 reviews
    .67 miles away
    Sydans Apartments and Villas
    50 reviews
    1.69 miles away
    Shoal Bay Villas
    210 reviews
    1.87 miles away
    Nearby Restaurants
    Artisan
    121 reviews
    .40 miles away
    Falcon Nest
    128 reviews
    .27 miles away
    Le Bon Pain
    164 reviews
    .52 miles away
    Hibernia
    173 reviews
    .43 miles away
    Nearby Attractions
    Anchor Miniature Golf
    28 reviews
    .33 miles away
    Shoal Bay
    971 reviews
    1.90 miles away
    Little Bay
    150 reviews
    4.88 miles away
    Ask a question
    Questions & Answers
    Luvu2travel
    February 29, 2016|
    AnswerShow all 2 answers
    Response from MrsElicia | Reviewed this property |
    I'm sure the owner and staff would appreciate and welcome your patronage, whether you're there just for the Rum Punch or decide to grab something to nosh. ☺ I would encourage you to go for the drinks. It's a beautiful... More
    1
    Vote
    cody56
    April 3, 2015|
    Answer
    Response from ScillyCayAnguilla | Property representative |
    Hi Cody56, you can check us out when you get to Island Harbor, just come by the dock and wave your hands, our ferry (free boat ride) will come pick you up. We are open on Wed (with DJ) and Sun (with live reggae band) from... More
    0
    Votes