97Reviews3Q&A
Reviews
Traveler rating
- 92
- 3
- 0
- 0
- 2
Traveler type
Time of year
Language
Selected filters
- Filter
- English
Popular mentions
We were 1st time deep sea fishing and enjoyed the experience so much. We were grateful for a knowledgeable and friendly crew.
Read more
Date of experience: April 2021
Helpful
Great trip. Adam and Don got us on the fish. Very knowledgeable and experienced. I’ve been chartering boats for years and they are as good as it gets!
Read more
Date of experience: April 2021
Helpful
Fantastic day out on the water. Captain Adam and Mate Don where a very knowledgeable and put us on fish. Will definitely be fishing with them again! Nice smooth ride on a choppy day!
Read more
Date of experience: April 2021
Helpful
They put six of us in a boat that DOES NOT comfortably seat six people (Forever & Always). Everyone had to sit in one cramped position the entire trip because there is not room to adjust and there isn’t even room to stand up. Five of us are experienced fishermen yet NONE of us ever held a rod in our hands. EVER. When a fish was hooked, the rod was transferred from a side mounted rod holder to a center mounted one and we each stepped up, one at a time, to crank the reel, without touching the rod, all the while being yelled at by Don, the deck hand: “FASTER. . . STOP. . . STOP. . . STOP!!!!” $450 What a waste of money. It’s a shame I have to choose ‘at least’ a one star rating to submit a review. Should be zero. …
Read more
Date of experience: March 2021
1 Helpful vote
Helpful
Response from Adam F, Owner at Fishing St. Croix
Responded 2 weeks ago
Thank you for your review. We try to offer different fishing styles to cater to our guests. In the safety briefing, we talked about what trolling was and asked everybody to let us know if they would rather use the battle station or hold the rod and fight the fish themselves. We wish that somebody would have let us know so that we could give you a better experience. Our seating area normally accommodates 6 -8 people comfortably. Clients who want to experience a more hands-on style of fishing opt to do one of our bottom fishing trips. We are surprised with your review since the rest of your party thanked us and said how much fun they had and even inquired about booking with us again.
Read more
Forever & Always Fishing Charter highly recommended. Captain Adam and First Mate Don pulled out all the stops to get us on fish in spite of Mother Nature making some big waves and trying her best to skunk us. These guys have tons of experience and are walking encyclopedias regarding all things boating, fishing and USVI history. We had a great time and look forward to the next trip.…
Read more
Date of experience: February 2021
Helpful
