59 W 44th St, Between Fifth & Sixth Ave
| New York City, NY 10036
TripAdvisor Traveler Rating:
Based on 345 traveler reviews
Most Recent Traveler Reviews:
“Not recommended”
Nov 29, 2009Maxyman, Miami
This Hotel really sucks... from outside it looks nice and is close to Times Square, however, the hotel does not deserve 4 Stars.
Its an old Hotel and the Hotel...
more »
This Hotel really sucks... from outside it looks nice and is close to Times Square, however, the hotel does not deserve 4 Stars.
Its an old Hotel and the Hotel Lobby is nice, but the rooms are really bad and small.... I was there with my Mother and we had to split a Queen size bed, they said that they dont have double beds and not even King beds and that i received a complimentary upgrade to Queen Size Bed anyways....usually they give out full size... even for 2 people...
I found out then that they had Kingsize Beds and did not gives us those...Anyways, rooms are really small and very dark...some rooms doesnt have a window etc... If you get a nice room, it might be ok... but the standard for this Hotel is not 4 Stars !! « less
“The Algonquin Hotel just oozes charm and elegance.”
Nov 21, 2009ABERNADETTE, Dublin irelanad
It was our first trip to NY....the hotel was so central,it made life very easy for us.The Staff were very helpful and courteous.We will be back!
It was our first trip to NY....the hotel was so central,it made life very easy for us.The Staff were very helpful and courteous.We will be back!
“Algonquin lived up to my expectations”
Nov 21, 2009adirondacksailor, Annapolis, MD
I have long wanted to stay at the Algonquin due to its history. We stayed just one night on a weekend trip to the city for a couple of Broadway...
more »
I have long wanted to stay at the Algonquin due to its history. We stayed just one night on a weekend trip to the city for a couple of Broadway shows. The hotel was just as I had imagined. They are quite proud of the literary history of its Round Table group, and this shows from the detail in their gorgeous lobby/restaurant to the New Yorker cartoon wallpaper in the corridors to your room. Though our reservation booked via a deeply discounted website was for their smallest room type, we were upgraded to a larger room with bay window and two beds. The bellman who showed us to our room was very pleasant and obviously proud of the hotel. The room decor was absolutely lovely and the place was spotlessly clean. The location is absolutely perfect and I will definitely make this my hotel of choice when a reasonable rate is available - so hard to find in NYC. « less
“Fabulous New York Hotel”
Nov 11, 2009WyeValleyHavana1, Wye Valley
We stayed from 5th November to 9th November for shopping/site seeing and Bruce Springsteen concert at MSG. We had been to NY before - this stay was truely memorable. Such...
more »
We stayed from 5th November to 9th November for shopping/site seeing and Bruce Springsteen concert at MSG. We had been to NY before - this stay was truely memorable. Such an amazingly comfortable and friendly hotel. Beds - so comfortable - bliss - as mentioned in other reviews. Lovely hot showers. Relaxing room space. NYC is noisey, you expect it - so what - we always travel with ear plugs, but hey, it did not spoil our sleep time and did not always need them. Would readily book the Algonquin for another visit to NYC. « less
“The Algonquin Hotel is FANTASTIC!”
Nov 9, 2009K1067, Toronto
After reading some of the reviews before my trip; I must say I was a little nervous. Well, the hotel exceeded my expectations! The historic elegance and charm is absolutely...
more »
After reading some of the reviews before my trip; I must say I was a little nervous. Well, the hotel exceeded my expectations! The historic elegance and charm is absolutely wonderful. Matida (the resident cat) greeted us upon arrival (she is so cute, fluffy and has a little attitude - which is just fine. We arrived before regular check-in time (12:00 noon), so our suite was not ready. I was a little disappointed as I wanted to get settled in before we started our day. The conceriage checked our luggage so we left for awhile until the room was ready. The front desk staff were very accommodating and courteous. Our suite was actually better than I anticipated (given the photos and comments on the size of the rooms). The suite has a living room with pull our Queen size bed and adjoining bedroom with a King size bed and a nice size washroom, walk in closet, bathrobes, etc. etc. The other adjoining room was a twin room which was small, but more than adequate. The decor is a combination of old and retro, very chic and has various books for your reading pleasure and funky prints on the wall (and yes, there may be a spec of wall paper peeling or grout discolouration but it is cleaniness that really matters - The maid service was excellent, and rooms were very kept and well equipped. The room rate was fairly good, given the location; and yes the drinks and food was little pricey (but excellent!). Let me remind you....you are in New York City. The Bartenders were amazing and I highly recommend the Lemondrop Martini (made with fresh lemon juice - simply divine). 10++ I will definitely return to the Algonquin. « less
These reviews are the subjective opinions of individual travelers and not of TripAdvisor LLC nor of its partners.