The house itself is quite beautiful. The view of the inlet is great. The house is close to its neighbors but secluded and quiet. The kitchen is nice and well equipped and stocked. The beds are really, really comfortable. The living room and large LCD TV were a nice distraction during the two days and nights it rained.
Those are the pros. For me the cons outweighed them.
First, on the map the house looks close to Vineyard Haven (2 miles) but the first half mile or so is a dirt road which is chock full of deep holes and sand pits. I had hoped to just bike to and from town to use the gym, shop, etc. While we were there is rained very heavily a few times and one of the two ways into and out of the house was washed out. The description of the house says nothing of the dirt road. It's not a huge deal but just know what you are getting before you book the house.
Second, the private beach is rocky and has a small sliver of water without seaweed. Again the...