If the rating were based on the menu and the food, the rating would be excellent. However I regrettably had to downgrade the overall rating because of poor service. Things started off very well, with prompt and courteous service. Orders taken, starters delivered, but then things sort of fell apart. Four of us ordered and three of the main courses came out quickly (we were early diners and few other guests). After waiting at least 15 minutes I found our server and asked about the missing meal. I was told "2 minutes". After waiting another 10 minutes, I found the server again and reminded her that the 4th meal was still not delivered and was told "it is coming". After waiting an additional 10 minutes, I finally got a reluctant "I'm sorry" and a few minutes later my grilled lamb chops appeared (brought by another server). By then everyone in our group else had finished their meals and were ready to head back to the Ca' Beatrice (the great little agriturismo tucked behind the restaurant).
A little more responsiveness from the server would have gone a long way to salvage our dinner. But we were left with a bad impression. That said, I will chalk this up to some bad luck which happens occasionally when you do a lot of traveling. The food definitely makes me want to return.
If you own or manage Trattoria da Olindo, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.