I stayed for 2 weeks with a friend and my daughter.
There are 3 pools so plenty of choice, all different atmospheres. I preferred the main pool which had a good atmosphere and gorgeous views of the bay. The food served there was always lovely, the staff there were great. Thanks Manos and Vangelis!
The entertainment was very enjoyable and my daughter wanted to see it every night.
Restaurants and bars in Koutoulafari were great but if you don't mind a 20min walk to Hersonnisos you can find cheaper alternatives, plus have a meal or drinks by the sea - a must do.
I don't often go back to the same place twice, however i want to go again next year.