My now husband and I went to Bahama Beach Club to get married. If you are planning to get married in the Bahamas, I would recommend BBC. Our wedding was beautiful. After the ceremony, they served us a four course meal of surf and turf that was our best meal while staying in the Bahamas. It was lovely and very peaceful.
Positives:
The beach was gorgeous. The sand is pure white, and the water is completely clear when the weather is calm. I'm sure this is the nicest beach I will ever lay my eyes on. The rooms were well furnished, and our unit even had three shower heads in the main shower. Those were the best showers I've ever taken.
The staff is very friendly and incredibly laid back. This may or may not be a positive for some people, as things are done on "Bahama" time. It was a very relaxing vacation, and we spent the majority of it in the beautiful ocean.
Negatives:
Over the course of the week, I had the following meals: burger and fries, burger and fries, scrambled eggs, hot dog and fries, lobster burger and fries, lobster dinner, burger and fries. If you go during the off season as we did, do NOT expect variety in your food choices. The Tiki Bar (the resort restaurant) was not stocking conch or fish. They had burgers, hot dogs, lobster burgers and a couple wraps and salads. Their lobster burger is delicious, but it's also 18 dollars. If I could, I probably would have gotten that every meal. Also, the Tiki Bar was closing for the off season while we were still there, and no one bothered to tell us. The Spinnaker has some incredibly good dinner food, but it is also very expensive. The entrees alone are 30-35 dollars. Their breakfast was just ok (and they are the only place in the area that serves breakfast). Coco beach bar and grille is the same food as the Tiki Bar, just in a different setting. It has a really nice view of the perfect white beach, but only the same fried food choices. If you want to cook all your meals, the grocery store has limited options and is expensive, but you could find enough food to keep you full for the entirety of your vacation.
While staying at BBC for 6 days, we lost power 3 times. Each time lasted at least 3-4 hours. No power means no electricity, no running water, no restaurants open, no ability to cook food etc. The resort also did not have internet nor long distance calls for three days. We were completely unable to have contact with the US during this time. That was pretty frustrating.
There is not a whole lot to do here. Granted, I wasn't looking for a whole lot to do. My goal going on this vacation was to have a relaxing time sitting on the beach. And that's just what I did. However, when we tried to do something adventurous and go snorkeling, it did not work out. The first day we were scheduled, they canceled because there were not enough reservations. During the off season, this is probably more often than not going to happen. The second day we were scheduled, the ocean was too violent to take a boat out. So, our plans were foiled, and we were completely unable to go snorkeling. If you are interested in island hopping frequently, you may be able to find more activities in other places. Just be aware that there are barely any activities on Treasure Cay. If you're looking to shop, there is one small gift shop behind The Spinnaker.
In conclusion, if you're looking to sit out on a gorgeous beach all day and cook your own food, this place is for you. If you're looking for a more bustling area with lots of restaurants and shops, try a less isolated island.