Went here with friends without a reservation on a Monday night. Had to wait a little bit since they were booked, but the staff was so friendly and accommodating. Very casual and good for people of all ages. The food is so good that we wanted to come back again, but the restaurant is closed on Tuesdays ... so we'll have to come to Anguilla again just to come to Picante. From the chips, guacamole, and salsa that they bring to the table to start to the tuna tacos served Picante style (hard shell taco wrapped with a soft shell taco with all kinds of good stuff in between), you can't go wrong. Ask for the Serrano pepper margarita. It is not on the menu. We heard about it from a couple that we met at Scilly Cay.
If you own or manage Picante, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.