There are two restaurants by the same name owned by the same person. Have your cab driver take you to the older one downtown by the soccer field for the best food. The other one has great views. It's only slightly cheaper than the states... but that is true of most food down there. Costa Rican food is not spicy at all, but still has good flavor.
If you own or manage Sabor Tico, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.