Went here on our first night on the island. It took a little longer to find because our GPS coudn't find the address, but we drove around Frenchtown and finally spotted it. I'm pretty sure we passed the McDonalds and then the street curved to the left and it was on your left. We did call for reservations after being instructed to do so on TA. There was seating for about 20, including the bar, but we got seated right away, but others after us were told about a 1.5 hour wait.
Lively place and seemed fast-paced. The lady that waited on us seemed to be doing too much and seemed a little overwhelmed. They had some unique pizza flavors and cool beers. We ordered some pesto bread ($4) for our appetizer and half beer-braised chicken and half pepperoni with ricotta cheese on all. It was really good! They are open for lunch M-F 11-3pm and Dinner M-Sat 5-11pm. Nice place to check out, but be sure to call ahead (340) 642-5074
If you own or manage The Pie Whole, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.