As a local, this is one of our saving graces. Very different from most places on island where you often get hit with a shabby experience and steep bill. The pizza is great, and pastas and salads are fantastic. Cozy atmosphere and mostly friendly, quick service. Another great thing-- consistency. It's very hard to recommend restaurants on island as they're hit or miss depending on their turnover that month. Pie Whole truly makes it a mission to train their staff well!
Another plus, they have an entire beer menu featuring beers from all over the world, another rarity on island. My personal favorite is the Ommegang Witte. Yum! Great, safe place for visitors on island who are often referred to pricey, disappointing restaurants. Enjoy your night!
If you own or manage The Pie Whole, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
- Manage your listing